Controversial The defenitive thread about swordsmanship skills and titles.

AL sama

Red Haired
Why the fuck did you put my WSS Rules thread in Ground Floor and then Battledome?
wasn't me
Why couldn't you keep it in manga section like this bait bullshit?
this thread is in the correct place
Stop antagonising him.
I was teasing so not the same thing lol
I am only pissed off because of @AL sama biased ass moderation putting mine and @SakazOuki 's threads first in ground floor then in battle dome and keeping your garbage in manga section.
lmfao xD
 
No he doesn't. He doesn't do anything.

He has a BURNING SWORD STYLE where he uses acoc on his sword just like zoro

Using coc waves that do no damage means fuck all

Ace novel says when his coc doesn't work he reaches FOR HIS SWORD

And if Shanks is a swordman as YOU SAY
Then he is WEAKER THAN THE WORLDS STRONGEST SWORDSMAN MIHAWK

Checkmate.
So Mihawk>Roger?
 
Says who? Give me a single manga panel or official source or anything in 20+ years of history of One Piece which says that?

There's an official source which calls a blasting technique swordsmanship. You can disagree, but it got a lot of backing by Oda than you or me and it has nothing which contradicts it.

There's not a single instance in entire manga history which says swordsmanship is limited only to cutting.

The peak of swordsmanship is apparently "cutting only when you want to" and having "slashes that cut nothing", as well. As proven in Alabasta.
I think better continue the discussion here

Says who? Give me a single manga panel or official source or anything in 20+ years of history of One Piece which says that?
All swordsmen like Zoro and Mihawk focus on cutting things, Zoro lives to cut everything he wants, Mihawk lives cutting icebergs, cutting ships and all his skills are based on cutting.
So it's only fair to say that in OP criteria, slashing skills are swordsmanship skills.
Also because it is very dumb and lame to associate meteors, fire dragons, meteors and CoC blasts are part of swordsmanship skills.

There's an official source which calls a blasting technique swordsmanship. You can disagree, but it got a lot of backing by Oda than you or me and it has nothing which contradicts it.
Which one are you talking about? Are you still in the shit over the Ikoku discussion?

Let's do the following, if this non-canonical information is that important to you, what does tell me about databook saying that Vista has fencing skills equal or greater than Mihawk?

There's not a single instance in entire manga history which says swordsmanship is limited only to cutting.
Something extremely obvious doesn't need to be said. It's like saying that a character with Black Leg Style needs to use kicks to attack. There is no ambiguity for something so obvious to be revealed.

The peak of swordsmanship is apparently "cutting only when you want to" and having "slashes that cut nothing", as well. As proven in Alabasta.
And that's precisely a technique to cut tougher things :gokulaugh::gokulaugh::gokulaugh:
 
Top