Questions & Mysteries Why didnt Imu shift delete Ohara?

[Sir Yasheen]

That was your logic dude. You guys said "the government wanted to make an example out of O'hara". Like you guys aren't making any sense.

We’re not. We’re telling you what’s written in the manga? But I guess a manga for 11 year olds may be too complex for you to understand it seems…

 

[lee33]

As I suspected you are just dumb.

I am not the one committing run on sentences. Make sure to proof read your sentences before commenting.

 

[Strawhats Bible]

I am not the one committing run on sentences. Make sure to proof read your sentences before commenting.

Make sure to take some low level basic reading comprehension classes before reading a manga for kids

 

[lee33]

We’re not. We’re telling you what’s written in the manga? But I guess a manga for 11 year olds may be too complex for you to understand it seems…

A manga for 11 year olds proofs my point dude. That doesn't help your cause. A manga for 11 year olds will be littered with inconsistency since its target audience are children. And yet you Oda angels continue to create your mental gymnastics to defend this "manga for 11 year olds".

To yall "The government wanted to make an example of Ohara and yet make it secret so that no one knows what happened", that makes no sense.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

A manga for 11 year olds proofs my point dude. That doesn't help your cause. A manga for 11 year olds will be littered with inconsistency since its target audience are children. And yet you Oda angels continue to create your mental gymnastics to defend this "manga for 11 year olds".

To yall "The government wanted to make an example of Ohara and yet make it secret so that no one knows what happened", that makes no sense.

Ohara wasn’t kept secret?? Everyone knows that the world government attacked Ohara because the devils that lived there were looking into how to activate the ancient weapons…

It’s not an inconsistency??

 

[Buggy D Clown]

We don't know if Imu could(prep required?) or even wanted to(the way Ohara destruction happened didn't seem like it at all). We also don't really know why this Kingdom was deleted

 

[dirtyLarry]

I think Imu really just acts in person when the truly "forbidden" things are getting leaked.

Ohara did some research and stuff, but I think they still didn't learn about Imu still ruling the world or anything like that. Just about an ancient kingdom once existing and stuff like that, but all rather vague.

That's why a Buster Call as a warning to all the other nations was good enough for Imu and actually a smart move to "show" them the power of the WG and what happens if you ask the wrong questions ("devils of Ohara" propaganda).

In terms of Sabo on Lulucia: Dude was about to drop a THE most forbidden/bombshell info in the world with all the marines and God knows who else wire-tapping because of this mickey-mouse phone-line Sabo had to use.

That's why Imu just went scorched earth on Lulucia and Sabo.

Imu didn't want to send out warnings or show the WG's power, they just wanted to erase any trace of the kingdom/Sabo/this conversation point blank.

That's how you can explain it. Easier explanation would be: It's just kind of a plothole bc Oda didn't plan this much in advance back at Ohara.

 

[Buggy D Clown]

I'm not gonna lie I was kinda confused reading this chapter, wasn't really sure who was saying what on some pages. But I was under the impression that Lulucia was set to be deleted even before they found out Sabo was there

 

[Malio]

Imu didn't exist in the story back then, so plothole

 

[lee33]

Ohara wasn’t kept secret?? Everyone knows that the world government attacked Ohara because the devils that lived there were looking into how to activate the ancient weapons…

It’s not an inconsistency??

My god. You guys are so deep into Oda's balls that you don't even see the mental gymnastics you guys are creating with your excuses.

Let me take this real slow. Your logic was that they didn't use Uranus on Ohara because the "WG wanted to make an example out of Ohara.", right? So tell me Einstein, what is the difference between nuking them vs buster call them in regards to "make an example of"? Both serve as making an example out of them so that excuse "making an example of" makes no sense. They can still make up propaganda that Robin was the one who did it, just like how they did with her "sinking war ships" propaganda.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

My god. You guys are so deep into Oda's balls that you don't even see the mental gymnastics you guys are creating with your excuses.

Let me take this real slow. Your logic was that they didn't use Uranus on Ohara because the "WG wanted to make an example out of Ohara.", right? So tell me Einstein, what is the difference between nuking them vs buster call them in regards to "make an example of"? Both serve as making an example out of them so that excuse "making an example of" makes no sense. They can still make up propaganda that Robin was the one who did it, just like how they did with her "sinking war ships" propaganda.

You seriously can’t tell the difference between a well organized military attack from a trusted military and a space laser that can be fired off and kill you at any given moment???

You’re so up your own ass if you honestly can’t figure that out.

 

[Strawhats Bible]

My god. You guys are so deep into Oda's balls that you don't even see the mental gymnastics you guys are creating with your excuses.

Let me take this real slow. Your logic was that they didn't use Uranus on Ohara because the "WG wanted to make an example out of Ohara.", right? So tell me Einstein, what is the difference between nuking them vs buster call them in regards to "make an example of"? Both serve as making an example out of them so that excuse "making an example of" makes no sense. They can still make up propaganda that Robin was the one who did it, just like how they did with her "sinking war ships" propaganda.

The difference is that the world would know the WG has the power to nuke countries without moving a finger. It's one thing to call a whole fleet of ships with Vice Admirals on board and another one sending a remote instant nuke to a place.

Can't you tell the difference?

 

[dirtyLarry]

My god. You guys are so deep into Oda's balls that you don't even see the mental gymnastics you guys are creating with your excuses.

Let me take this real slow. Your logic was that they didn't use Uranus on Ohara because the "WG wanted to make an example out of Ohara.", right? So tell me Einstein, what is the difference between nuking them vs buster call them in regards to "make an example of"? Both serve as making an example out of them so that excuse "making an example of" makes no sense. They can still make up propaganda that Robin was the one who did it, just like how they did with her "sinking war ships" propaganda.

Oda's writing has a ton of flaws and Wano's act 3 was a mess especially.

Having said this, the erasing of Lulucia is not one of those problems.

Even if Oda didn't think about it back during Ohara, it is easily explainable in retroperspective.

 

[lee33]

You seriously can’t tell the difference between a well organized military attack from a trusted military and a space laser that can be fired off and kill you at any given moment???

You’re so up your own ass if you honestly can’t figure that out.

Like I said you guys are making no sense. Your logic is "make an example of", that is your logic. There is obviously a difference between nuking vs war ships however that isn't the argument at all. The argument is "make an example of". That is the argument. Why are you changing your argument now to something different? When making an argument, make sure you are clear and concise because right now you both are incoherent as hell.

 

[Strawhats Bible]

Holy hell that boy dumb af lmao

 

[lee33]

Oda's writing has a ton of flaws and Wano's act 3 was a mess especially.

Having said this, the erasing of Lulucia is not one of those problems.

Even if Oda didn't think about it back during Ohara, it is easily explainable in retroperspective.

I have no issues with the erasing of Lulucia as we still don't know why they erased it. That isn't the argument I making. The argument I am making is that the excuses people are now making trying to explain the inconsistency, aren't valid excuses. "Trying to make an example of" isn't a valid excuse.

 

[Tai long]

I have no issues with the erasing of Lulucia as we still don't know why they erased it. That isn't the argument I making. The argument I am making is that the excuses people are now making trying to explain the inconsistency, aren't valid excuses. "Trying to make an example of" isn't a valid excuse.

the best option for ohara would be to make an example out of them rather than just erasing them out of existence. if the wg erased ohara what stops other places from being the next ohara

 

[lee33]

the best option for ohara would be to make an example out of them rather than just erasing them out of existence. if the wg erased ohara what stops other places from being the next ohara

but the government literally erased Ohara. They even took Ohara off the map as Ohara isn't even drawn on the map anymore.

 

[Tai long]

but the government literally erased Ohara. They even took Ohara off the map as Ohara isn't even drawn on the map anymore.

they did not erase ohara they killed ohara citizens it is like how the US did not erase hiroshima and nagasaki but they gave a stern warning and no nation would try to backstab the US anytime soon

 

[Strawhats Bible]

I have no issues with the erasing of Lulucia as we still don't know why they erased it. That isn't the argument I making. The argument I am making is that the excuses people are now making trying to explain the inconsistency, aren't valid excuses. "Trying to make an example of" isn't a valid excuse.

You made up an inconsistency. Because there is none.

• Imu didn't order the Buster Call on O'Hara, hell Gorosei didn't even want to kill it's citizens (this was Akainu's decision)
• IF Imu wanted to erase O'Hara from history he would have done which he clearly didn't which is why it wasn't nuked.
• The Gorosei Buster Called O'Hara to make an example that if you sneak your nose under the wrong piece of information you will receive heavenly hell for it.
• The Gorosei are actively working on erasing Lulusia existence from the world hence they are clearly hiding that they hold such destructive power.

So all in all, no the Gorosei couldn't have nuked O'Hara because they don't have control of whatever Imu used this chapter.
If Imu wanted to erase O'Hara from the world he would have used his weapon but instead the Gorosei were the ones that decided this and used the event as example to the world.

The Demons of O'Hara are known throughout the entire world of One Piece.