General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Carrota Guco]

lmao running away because you couldnt stoop too low insults how pathetic

Here is the thing buddy, we can't just throw mud directly at each other. At least let there be a topic.

 

[Rottkins]

GET OUT OF HERE
:laughmoji:

I JUST GOT HERE! Let me enjoy the show

This thread is in a rough place rn

Enjoy the show!

like this fine fella

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

like this fine fella

:cheers:

 

[Seatonnes]

Here is the thing buddy, we can't just throw mud directly at each other. At least let there be a topic.

So you scared go crawl back into the burrow you came from

Post automatically merged: Oct 20, 2022

eh aren't carrot fans suppose to be polite??

Thats only pot

 

[Carrota Guco]

So you scared go crawl back into the burrow you came from

Post automatically merged: Oct 20, 2022

Thats only pot

What am I suppose to be scared of?

 

[Peppercore]

sweet lord

hisss

 

[Rottkins]

hisss

what is it? I just lurk here

 

[Uncle Van]

You can tell oda didnt put much thought into carrot since he named her after the first thing rabbits are known for eating

And that we already had a character named Carrot in Syrup Village lol

 

[Garp the Fist]

You can tell oda didnt put much thought into carrot since he named her after the first thing rabbits are known for eating

Female Bepo appeared in two panels and had a better design that Carrot as well

 

[Rottkins]

And that we already had a character named Carrot in Syrup Village lol

the original... the one who should take the cabin boy role in the crew

 

[Uncle Van]

eh aren't carrot fans suppose to be polite??

I remember my very first encounter with Carrot4Nakama back in 2016. They called me a Carrot hater and theory elitist lol

This was during early WCI, and a bunch of C4N supporters on OJ got together to make a big C4N theory, and asked me to give an honest review since I was known theorist as the time. They were absolutely livid that I gave them a 1 star because of all the speculative what if scenarios they gave including potential merchandise sales(I shit you not).

 

[ShiShiShi]

I remember my very first encounter with Carrot4Nakama back in 2016. They called me a Carrot hater and theory elitist lol

This was during early WCI, and a bunch of C4N supporters on OJ got together to make a big C4N theory, and asked me to give an honest review since I was known theorist as the time. They were absolutely livid that I gave them a 1 star because of all the speculative what if scenarios they gave including potential merchandise sales(I shit you not).

Carrot4Nakama sounded kind of unlikable.

 

[Roo]

Stop the carrot fans bullying

 

[Emmazrine]

carrot fans have been getting attacked too much lately stop playing victim when you guys went overboard

 

[Roo]

carrot fans have been getting attacked too much lately stop playing victim when you guys went overboard

Shut up

 

[Emmazrine]

Shut up

where is your manners

 

[Sigran101]

Yeah but this is just arbitary, it's the same with role, if you just add criteria. Every SH also has a role.

If you're more or less strict you eliminate almost everyone including Yamato, also like i said for point 2) Zoro and specially Sanji don't fit whatsoever.

Carrot has more of a thematic connection to defeating the BM pirates (Perospero/Katakuri) then Sanji has defeating freaking Don Krieg and ..... Pearl...

Looks like someone needs to re-read Baratie.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Carrot4Nakama sounded kind of unlikable.

In it's peak it was very similar to Yamato4nakama in the aggressive department. Like with Yamato you had a lot of people who were convinced she was guaranteed to join only made worse by the ending of WCI, even I (who was a Carrot4nakama guy at the time) was catching shit when I suggested reason why it wasn't at all guaranteed. Because while WCI did a lot for Carrot, he character was still littered with flaws, she didn't have anything unique about her that set her apart from Chopper (at the time people were even theorizing Chopper would learn electro which just completely kill her candidacy).

Orojackson and Reddit during that time were something else

 

[Peppercore]

being bullied becau7se i enjoy cheery girl characters who r silly

 

[Uncle Van]

Remember that Carrot fans can say whatever they want. If you retaliate in any way, it's bullying.

Apparently