General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

Who will be the Next Strawhat?

  • Total voters
    506
Uncle Van

Uncle Van

Bullets don't hurt. But Taxes do.
‎
#1,841
#1,841
Warback said:
That's just your own personal opinion, i can just say every SH candidate needs to have a role and to have at least hints at it or they don't even break good candidate territory.

Furthermore by your own logic Connis is a better candidate than Yamato was, because she was much more the focus of the SHs while sharing the same big baddy opressing all of the island routine.

Every character in Wano suffered under Kaido, they all equally get liberated by Luffy defeating him, Tama and Kiku and Yamato are in the same boat by that logic because usually the big baddie opresses every primary/secondary/terciary supporting character in an given island.
Post automatically merged:

Also forgot to add even when you go down the line of each SH, it's not really as rigid

- Zoro was circustancially on that island
- Sanji was completly arbirtarly at the crossfire of some random pirates and had to fight them off
- Nami i agree, she was the culmination of the saga and the start of the sort female princess-esque rescue trope
- Ussop is true to a certain extent
- Chopper is the same
- Robin's enemy is the WG, Luci was jsut the avatar, Robin's enemy wasn't techinically stopped by the end of her arc
- Franky is the same, Spandam was an enemy purely in name, it's CP9 and the WG who were the real villains
- Brook same as Ussop/chopper
- Jinbei is the worst because Hody Jones wasn't Jinbei's existencial issue, if anything BM was, he was more of a political issue

If you look at Vivi, Rebeca and Nami they fit your mold much better then say Sanji who only incidentally had to fight pirates. Don Krieg has no narrative importance in the life of Sanji, not compared to Vivi /Crocodile, Nami/arlong, Rebbeca/don flamingo.


That's why Nami, Robin, Vivi, Rebecca and Yamato all fit perfectly in a princess of the arc character not necessarily a SH candidate.

Specially Rebbeca and Yamato which only interacted during the entirety of their arcs with Luffy almost exclusively and no other SHs.
Click to expand...
OK but....it's not my opinion that every single SH was:
1) the main or one of the main factors of the arc
2) connected to the villain in some way and has the strongest connection to them thematically
3) Have a problem caused by the main villain(s)
4) helped by Luffy by way of having their problem solved with Luffy taking out the main villain

If the character isn't even going to be important or have any story telling relevance that Oda is obsessed with, it stands to reason that the candidate would have no chances. Carrot for example had nothing what was stated above and spent most of her days as a minor character.
 
C

Carrota Guco

‎
#1,842
#1,842
Yamato fans have comprehension issues. That not my problem. If they can't communicate effectively, flip burgers. These little basters complain about me ruining their day and being sad and shit. What about my fucking day? What about when somebody randomly pops up to make jokes about carrot dying and trolling and shit? What about my point of view?

These basters counted their chicken without eggs. They believe what they think to be true and act like ugly losers when someone challenges them. These idiots don't deserve respects. They have fantasies about what Oda thinks and gets their asses blown off at every turn. They act like people are going to treat them like decent people after being a douchebag. No, welcome to the real world where you're treated like a douche forever for being one.
 
Warback

Warback

‎
#1,844
#1,844
Uncle Van said:
OK but....it's not my opinion that every single SH was:
1) the main or one of the main factors of the arc
2) connected to the villain in some way and has the strongest connection to them thematically
3) Have a problem caused by the main villain(s)
4) helped by Luffy by way of having their problem solved with Luffy taking out the main villain

If the character isn't even going to be important or have any story telling relevance that Oda is obsessed with, it stands to reason that the candidate would have no chances. Carrot for example had nothing what was stated above and spent most of her days as a minor character.
Click to expand...
Yeah but this is just arbitary, it's the same with role, if you just add criteria. Every SH also has a role.

If you're more or less strict you eliminate almost everyone including Yamato, also like i said for point 2) Zoro and specially Sanji don't fit whatsoever.

Carrot has more of a thematic connection to defeating the BM pirates (Perospero/Katakuri) then Sanji has defeating freaking Don Krieg and ..... Pearl...
 
Seatonnes

Seatonnes

playing Marvel Rivals
‎
#1,846
#1,846
Carrota Guco said:
Yamato fans have comprehension issues. That not my problem. If they can't communicate effectively, flip burgers. These little basters complain about me ruining their day and being sad and shit. What about my fucking day? What about when somebody randomly pops up to make jokes about carrot dying and trolling and shit? What about my point of view?

These basters counted their chicken without eggs. They believe what they think to be true and act like ugly losers when someone challenges them. These idiots don't deserve respects. They have fantasies about what Oda thinks and gets their asses blown off at every turn. They act like people are going to treat them like decent people after being a douchebag. No, welcome to the real world where you're treated like a douche forever for being one.
Click to expand...
grow up
eat grass
git gud
wank
better
characters
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top