General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
The topic of the thread is new nakama; I am asking you to explain why Carrot should join the crew; you respond with any other shit and then say I’m doing the same thing, but you have yet to answer my perfectly on-topic question, it’s the one thing you haven’t nitpicked out of what I’ve said. Really have no confidence that you CAN answer it, even though it’s the only question I’m asking that has to do with the purpose of this thread according to your logic 
Why would i engage in a completly new conversation of why Carrot should join, when you can't even resolve the previous conversation?
You think a doctor has more reasons to join the PK crew for his dream than a person who actually wanted to join the PK crew.
First you didn't accept Pedro's will was to not rule Zou and that has nothign to do with it, then you get the excuse that Carrot doesn't need to be a copy of his will.
I know you were desesperate to switch topics, but this little act you're doing makes as much sense as if i started asking you obssesively why Yamato should join.
The topic was, does Carrot conclusion make sense given what Pedro's will is? The answer is no, you in your little headcanon thinks it makes sense, most readers don't.
You don’t like Carrot’s ending because you think she should join the crew, not hard to follow how we get from A to B there…except you still can’t fucking C your way to explaining why she has to be Luffy’s crewmate 
Do you need me to be here? I mean you're literally making up what i'm saying, what's the point of me talking when you just invent things to respond to
Yeah i told you i'm not going to engage in a new conversation with someone that lacks the capacity to understand basic English and repeatedly makes up a conversation in his head but since you can't read you're going to ask me again.
Post automatically merged:
Also do you understand you didn't even answer the basic question of why Brook needs to be on the crew to rejoin Laboon?
You just said something about Luffy knowing Laboon therefore connection something, you just spout some random nonsense and move on.
Since you can’t defend your opinion on Carrot, how do you see Brook getting through the Grand Line by himself to get back to Laboon? I don’t understand why we have to hash out someone who joined the crew many years ago instead of one who hasn’t, but I guess I misunderstand the purpose of a thread called “NEXT Straw Hat Crew Members” :laughmoji:
I can read, but I wanna keep showing everybody that a Carrot fan refuses to explain why she deserves to join the crew because it just can’t be done 
>Can't answer a simple question on why Brook needs to be on a ship to see Laboon
>Insist to change the topic into me defending why a character should join
Stay classy my guy
Post automatically merged:
Yeah that's because like i said you have a goldfish memory, and you already forgot your argument that the SH dreams have to connect to sailing on the ship.
That's why you we're unironically saying curing all diseases makes more sense to join the SH as opose to getting the RP/ bringing the dawn helping the SHs, don't worry i'll keep reminding you of what you said, regardless of how many times you switch topics
Fuck, actually, you’re right…he should just run across the entirety of the Grand Line instead!! Guess there’s no reason for him to be in the story, let’s get him out of here!!
Titanic levels of dishonesty, expected tho
Can’t believe I’m being challenged because Luffy’s ship happened to sail into the Florian Triangle and he asked Brook to join after getting his shadow back, like it’s my fault Brook didn’t tell him to fuck off and set sail on his own…can you just put all your bitching on a piece of paper and send it to Oda? He’s the one who decided Brook should exist AND be a part of Luffy’s crew despite your apparent resistance. If you’re as smart as you think you are, tell me what Brook should have done instead of demanding it from someone you view as dumb, it sounds like you have all the answers but you’ve just been so God damn coy about sharing them 
Can’t believe I’m being challenged because Luffy’s ship happened to sail into the Florian Triangle and he asked Brook to join after getting his shadow back, like it’s my fault Brook didn’t tell him to fuck off and set sail on his own…can you just put all your bitching on a piece of paper and send it to Oda? He’s the one who decided Brook should exist AND be a part of Luffy’s crew despite your apparent resistance. If you’re as smart as you think you are, tell me what Brook should have done instead of demanding it from someone you view as dumb, it sounds like you have all the answers but you’ve just been so God damn coy about sharing them
Right extrapolate your mind a little think after he got his shadow back to present story. Do you think at any point in his existance with the SH it was absolutely 100% necessary for him to be on the Sunny to get to Laboon?
Post automatically merged:
Ok if that's a criteria you find relevant sure, you'll find almost every SH ally fits that criteria tho, from Vivi to random Wano citizens.
The author sure thought so!! Can’t imagine why he would have chosen to have him sail with the guy who mentioned the whale he wanted to find, especially when no other people had ever done what Luffy did to save Brook’s life and no other ships offered to take him away from Thriller Bark!! This is what an explanation looks like, by the way…I’m sorry you don’t recognize it, just don’t want you accusing me of some more bullshit in the next four posts 
And Warback still hasn’t explained why Carrot should join the crew ☺️😊😇🥰
Post automatically merged:
And Warback still hasn’t explained why Carrot should join the crew ☺️😊😇🥰
The author sure thought so!! Can’t imagine why he would have chosen to have him sail with the guy who mentioned the whale he wanted to find, especially when no other people had ever done what Luffy did to save Brook’s life and no other ships offered to take him away from Thriller Bark!! This is what an explanation looks like, by the way…I’m sorry you don’t recognize it, just don’t want you accusing me of some more bullshit in the next four posts
And Warback still hasn’t explained why Carrot should join the crew ☺️😊😇🥰
Post automatically merged:
And Warback still hasn’t explained why Carrot should join the crew ☺️😊😇🥰
I tried, but i'm not paid for this so ye.
Brook had two full years during the timeskip (when he was actively traveling as a rock star!!) to go find Laboon on his own, and as far as we know, he didn’t…is it hard to believe that could be due to his dream of seeing Laboon being tied to when Luffy returns to Reverse Mountain as Pirate King like he promised?? Is this thing on, am I speaking English or Warback’s dialect??
God, you haven’t actually explained a single thing, you just actively criticize because you can’t stand up for your beliefs, it’s kinda sad…
Post automatically merged:
Right i see it is completly pointless to talk to you, now you've snapshoted yourself into the end of Thriller Bark and your brain can't leave that timeframe and you don't understand the basic scenario i'm leading you into, so you'd understand one iota of something.
I tried, but i'm not paid for this so ye.
I tried, but i'm not paid for this so ye.
