Manga Discussion wHicH mAnGa iS bEttER?
- Thread starter MUUGEN
- Start date
It's tough to say either way imo
They have different strengths while also being somewhat similar - a warrior that ends up living the civilian life and experiencing life from that side (this is very general ofc, there are differences in their circumstances)
Vinland Saga will go down as the better one if the ending isn't a let down. And judging by the story so far it shouldn't be, but we've all said that before for other stories as well lol
Vagabond is my personal favorite and the one I enjoyed more, but sadly it won't see a conclussion.
They have different strengths while also being somewhat similar - a warrior that ends up living the civilian life and experiencing life from that side (this is very general ofc, there are differences in their circumstances)
Vinland Saga will go down as the better one if the ending isn't a let down. And judging by the story so far it shouldn't be, but we've all said that before for other stories as well lol
Vagabond is my personal favorite and the one I enjoyed more, but sadly it won't see a conclussion.
And this is exactly why I asked you those questions so that I can understand if I am dealing with a dimwit but it turns out that I am indeed dealing with a dimwit. So you said Naruto is a character driven story but has worse character development than One Piece, gotcha. Believe what you want dude. This is why I ask questions before I debate someone.
Vagabond also my all time fav, i just got this tattooed:
i didnt feel it was right when i kept adding more titles to the poll haha
[automerge]1678648204[/automerge]
I mean you havent said anything to disprove me nor have you still listed out 8/10 things better than FMA that I outlined for you.
you'll just chop up you not having any rebuttals to me being a dimwit.
Thank fuck I could do multiple votes 
[automerge]1678648204[/automerge]
I mean you havent said anything to disprove me nor have you still listed out 8/10 things better than FMA that I outlined for you.
you'll just chop up you not having any rebuttals to me being a dimwit.
I mean you haven't said anything to discredit me have you?
oh wait im a dimwit, you didnt even answer if naruto is your all time and what other shonen you watched in general.
you do also realize you're the only one who believes your own nonsense. I mean you can call in your friends for a lifeline.
next time dont piggyback off of @notAfanboy nonsense if you cant back up your own stance on something.
you would've had a better chance if you debated Naruto v Bleach
haaha i'll keep it at 5 i feel like thats fair cause i also want to vote others hahahaha
oh wait im a dimwit, you didnt even answer if naruto is your all time and what other shonen you watched in general.
you do also realize you're the only one who believes your own nonsense. I mean you can call in your friends for a lifeline.
next time dont piggyback off of @notAfanboy nonsense if you cant back up your own stance on something.
you would've had a better chance if you debated Naruto v Bleach
haaha i'll keep it at 5 i feel like thats fair cause i also want to vote others hahahaha
You can't tell shit, because I love character driven stuff and actual literature.
I literally said that my favourite manga is Slam Dunk, which your favourite manga completely copied the protagonist friend dynamic btw.
Or Berserk.
As you said, Lee, One Piece is not a character driven manga, and as such, it doesn't need that.
It's a battle shonen with a stong emphasis on the overall mistery of the One Piece.
And Naruto doesn't solve anything, they literally recant their whole life because Naruto shows them that the Ninja way is to trust yourself and your friends.
I literally said that my favourite manga is Slam Dunk, which your favourite manga completely copied the protagonist friend dynamic btw.
Or Berserk.
As you said, Lee, One Piece is not a character driven manga, and as such, it doesn't need that.
It's a battle shonen with a stong emphasis on the overall mistery of the One Piece.
And Naruto doesn't solve anything, they literally recant their whole life because Naruto shows them that the Ninja way is to trust yourself and your friends.
the simple fact of how illiterate both you and @lee33 is telling.
I donโt even have Naruto or One Piece in my top 10.
not even my topic point you said:
I asked you to list what was better than 5 separate mangas had nothing to do with one piece to begin with Lee somehow managed to convince not just himself but you as well that that was my focal point, never even mentioned one piece.
youโre both claiming Naruto is greatest piece of manga to exist when it isnโt itโs not even a top 10 probably not even top 20.
I did however answer your question of:
[automerge]1678651932[/automerge]
furthermore my topic points against Lee had nothing to do with any nonsense you listed for the Naruto haters criticisms or as you referred childish insults.
I donโt even have Naruto or One Piece in my top 10.
not even my topic point you said:
I asked you to list what was better than 5 separate mangas had nothing to do with one piece to begin with Lee somehow managed to convince not just himself but you as well that that was my focal point, never even mentioned one piece.
youโre both claiming Naruto is greatest piece of manga to exist when it isnโt itโs not even a top 10 probably not even top 20.
I did however answer your question of:
[automerge]1678651932[/automerge]
furthermore my topic points against Lee had nothing to do with any nonsense you listed for the Naruto haters criticisms or as you referred childish insults.
Last edited:
https://myanimelist.net/profile/iammuugen
I havenโt logged in since 2016 though so a bit outdated.
I havenโt logged in since 2016 though so a bit outdated.
