That’s what I am saying dumbass, you believed his claim without any proof.
>I figured out his identity
>He reveals to me that he has mech info confirming you as town
>He tells me the details of his wincon (including that you and he shared a chat)
>I then ask him to use that chat for him to pass my claim along to you (this indicates that I knew you had a chat, so your claim that I didn't know before you said so is, obviously, bogus)
Throughout this I analysed what he was saying, what I know of the player and how it was presented, and decided they were trustworthy. I probably know more about his wincon than you do, actually. I will be shocked if he's Mafia, and considerably surprised if he's serial. And that's all I needed.