Current Events What plot holes Oda should explain before he finishes the Wano arc?
- Thread starter Seth
- Start date
Why Hiyori acting so weak and mousie when we saw her Komurasaki persona Isn't taking shit from nobody, and the Tomboy parts, a pretty specific thing to say or trait to add to a women of all things from Oda and not only do nothing with it but hardly show it.
IIRC it was described for her??
Germa 66 and the Vinsmokes escaping or not from Big Mom. Jinbei's crew... etc...
Pound. I don't mind if he's alive but How and why.
How did/does the WG know about Kaidou taking over Wano but Marines don't and just think Wano is full of Super Strong Samurai... Don't give me that crap about "news" suppression... There's no reason why the Marines of all thing should be out of the loop.
IIRC it was described for her??
Germa 66 and the Vinsmokes escaping or not from Big Mom. Jinbei's crew... etc...
Pound. I don't mind if he's alive but How and why.
How did/does the WG know about Kaidou taking over Wano but Marines don't and just think Wano is full of Super Strong Samurai... Don't give me that crap about "news" suppression... There's no reason why the Marines of all thing should be out of the loop.
I've re-read One Piece multiple times and there's only one thing that could fall under my definition of Plothole.
It was about Madam Shyarly's Scrying.
1) When she's asked when Luffy will destroy FI she says "I don't know, I can only see WHAT happens. I don't know if it'll be tomorrow or a year from now".
2) When Roger asks baby Shyarly about Poseidon's birth she says "In 10 years".
So that leaves me with:
A) The translation on the Fishman Island prophecy is wrong. Her ability can see what and when an event occurs. So she's not establishing a universal rule on all of her prophecies. She's just referring to that specific prophecy, that she only knows what happens regardless of time frame.
B) When she was young her ability could discern both content and time of prophesied event. And as she got older the ability weakens losing that added perk. (But this still needs to be mentioned in the story if it's the case so for now it's a possibility)
C) Shyarly is lying about not knowing the time of Luffy's destruction of FI (Very very very very unlikely)
D) It's a Plot Hole.
For now I won't legitimately say it's a plot hole until I can find the raw of said scenes and double check with a qualified translator whether the wording in the Fishman's Island scene was specific to the timing of Luffy's prophecy, or a general rule related to her Scrying ability.
It was about Madam Shyarly's Scrying.
1) When she's asked when Luffy will destroy FI she says "I don't know, I can only see WHAT happens. I don't know if it'll be tomorrow or a year from now".
2) When Roger asks baby Shyarly about Poseidon's birth she says "In 10 years".
So that leaves me with:
A) The translation on the Fishman Island prophecy is wrong. Her ability can see what and when an event occurs. So she's not establishing a universal rule on all of her prophecies. She's just referring to that specific prophecy, that she only knows what happens regardless of time frame.
B) When she was young her ability could discern both content and time of prophesied event. And as she got older the ability weakens losing that added perk. (But this still needs to be mentioned in the story if it's the case so for now it's a possibility)
C) Shyarly is lying about not knowing the time of Luffy's destruction of FI (Very very very very unlikely)
D) It's a Plot Hole.
For now I won't legitimately say it's a plot hole until I can find the raw of said scenes and double check with a qualified translator whether the wording in the Fishman's Island scene was specific to the timing of Luffy's prophecy, or a general rule related to her Scrying ability.
I've re-read One Piece multiple times and there's only one thing that could fall under my definition of Plothole.
It was about Madam Shyarly's Scrying.
1) When she's asked when Luffy will destroy FI she says "I don't know, I can only see WHAT happens. I don't know if it'll be tomorrow or a year from now".
2) When Roger asks baby Shyarly about Poseidon's birth she says "In 10 years".
So that leaves me with:
A) The translation on the Fishman Island prophecy is wrong. Her ability can see what and when an event occurs. So she's not establishing a universal rule on all of her prophecies. She's just referring to that specific prophecy, that she only knows what happens regardless of time frame.
B) When she was young her ability could discern both content and time of prophesied event. And as she got older the ability weakens losing that added perk. (But this still needs to be mentioned in the story if it's the case so for now it's a possibility)
C) Shyarly is lying about not knowing the time of Luffy's destruction of FI (Very very very very unlikely)
D) It's a Plot Hole.
For now I won't legitimately say it's a plot hole until I can find the raw of said scenes and double check with a qualified translator whether the wording in the Fishman's Island scene was specific to the timing of Luffy's prophecy, or a general rule related to her Scrying ability.
It was about Madam Shyarly's Scrying.
1) When she's asked when Luffy will destroy FI she says "I don't know, I can only see WHAT happens. I don't know if it'll be tomorrow or a year from now".
2) When Roger asks baby Shyarly about Poseidon's birth she says "In 10 years".
So that leaves me with:
A) The translation on the Fishman Island prophecy is wrong. Her ability can see what and when an event occurs. So she's not establishing a universal rule on all of her prophecies. She's just referring to that specific prophecy, that she only knows what happens regardless of time frame.
B) When she was young her ability could discern both content and time of prophesied event. And as she got older the ability weakens losing that added perk. (But this still needs to be mentioned in the story if it's the case so for now it's a possibility)
C) Shyarly is lying about not knowing the time of Luffy's destruction of FI (Very very very very unlikely)
D) It's a Plot Hole.
For now I won't legitimately say it's a plot hole until I can find the raw of said scenes and double check with a qualified translator whether the wording in the Fishman's Island scene was specific to the timing of Luffy's prophecy, or a general rule related to her Scrying ability.
Because he already knows about Kaido and his gang, but he doesent know about Wano and its forces. For what he knows, the Wano from 20 years ago and all its military might could have just allied with Kaido, so he has all those strong samurai (who no one knows how strong and how many there are) working for him, instead of what actually happened and most of them getting killed and imprisoned. Thats the danger of a closed of country, you have no clue what youre dealing with