ONE PIECE Live Action - Episodes Discussion Thread

[kurwa]

What did Dragon do? Why no one posting him?

 

[York]

Finished it. Its good. I liked it. Usopp was very cute and fun. Mihawk's voice is almost too campy but it makes having him on screen a lot funnier. Shame about Hachi being cut


Don't know why everyone is complaining about Shanks he felt very Shanks-like to me. "He looks like a hobo" yeah. Shanks looks like a hobo. Its like Shanks fans only care about Shanks because of like 3 panels of glaring instead of everything else about him.

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

What did Dragon do? Why no one posting him?

Had a cameo in Rogers execution we see the green cloak

 

[Franz]

Finished it. Its good. I liked it. Usopp was very cute and fun.

Oh God

Post automatically merged: Sep 1, 2023

What did Dragon do? Why no one posting him?

Nothing

 

[Logiko]

BTW guys. I have a question for you. Do you think we should consider the sentence: "you didn't earn that scar" as Canon ? It feels like something Oda has pushed in (although I might be wrong) and I find it interesting in term of characterization.

 

[Fujishiro]

Honestly a weird moment lmao
Fella did his best smh

Garp feels very off this series
Chobro and I have been callin him Mean Garp
Koby probably my least favorite LA character as well

Yeah Garp stringing him in the courtyard for no reason makes him look bad lmfao.

 

[NikaInParis]

Honestly despite enjoying season 1, I don't think I want a season 2 simply for the fact that live action chopper is gonna be more cursed than those transponder snails. Those fuckers gave me a jump scare.

Chopper could work imo. We had half beast-half human characters for years in fantasy and sci-fi movies (X-Men, Jumanji).
With today's tech, Chopper could be a relatively easy thing to get right.

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

Yeah Garp stringing him in the courtyard for no reason makes him look bad lmfao.

The reason was that Axe hand Morgan lied about what happened in shell town

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Yeah Garp stringing him in the courtyard for no reason makes him look bad lmfao.

Your signature is the entrance I wanted to see from Mihawk...

Post automatically merged: Sep 1, 2023

Chopper could work imo. We had half beast-half human characters for years in fantasy and sci-fi movies (X-Men, Jumanji).
With today's tech, Chopper could be a relatively easy thing to get right.

Why do you think Arlong went wrong?

 

[Fujishiro]

The reason was that Axe hand Morgan lied about what happened in shell town

So? Its just a white lie to make himsef not look bad for letting them escape. Does that warrant being strung up in the yard?

 

[York]

Yeah, they should've made it more obvious how twisted Morgan was

 

[Fujishiro]

Yeah, they should've made it more obvious how twisted Morgan was

Aye for me it was just a guy doing his job, he even had a heroic moment of saying hes the wall that protects his town against scum,etc and then he gets punished for basically boasting to save face lmfao.

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

So? Its just a white lie to make himsef not look bad for letting them escape. Does that warrant being strung up in the yard?

Curruption within military ranks is a serious offense it's not a simple white lie

 

[Fujishiro]

Curruption within military ranks is a serious offense it's not a simple white lie

How is this corruption lmfao? All he said is that he made them run away because of how strong he is. He was basically boasting to save face. Thats not corruption mate.

 

[NikaInParis]

So? Its just a white lie to make himsef not look bad for letting them escape. Does that warrant being strung up in the yard?

Curruption within military ranks is a serious offense it's not a simple white lie

Basically this
The Marines are like the military. Order needs to be maintained otherwose they as an organization lose face in the long run

But I agree that Morgan should've been presented as more derranged. A victim of the pacing, but not that important in the long run

 

[Fujishiro]

Basically this
The Marines are like the military. Order needs to be maintained otherwose they as an organization lose face in the long run

But I agree that Morgan should've been presented as more derranged. A victim of the pacing, but not that important in the long run

How is this corruption lmfao? All he said is that he made them run away because of how strong he is. He was basically boasting to save face. Thats not corruption mate.

The punishment for him boasting is too severe.

 

[NikaInParis]

The punishment for him boasting is too severe.

He said they retreated because of how strong he was, right?
So if he's lying about that to Garp's face, what else could he be witholding from the Marines and/or WG?

But again, it was a rushed and not well developed resolution for a plotpoint that could have even been scrapped in totality

 

[Fujishiro]

He said they retreated because of how strong he was, right?
So if he's lying about that to Garp's face, what else could he be witholding from the Marines and/or WG?

But again, it was a rushed and not well developed resolution for a plotpoint that could have even been scrapped in totality

Yeah, thats the thing it was rushed. And fealt unearned. We also saw that Morgan seemed to actually care about protecting civilians and do his duty. So the “what else could he be witholding” line of thought doesnt hold much weight atleast in the eyes of the viewer.

Basically the randoms who are watching this and know nothing about OP will be left wondering why Morgan was so harshly punished and also think of Garp as someone more sinister then he really is.

 

[NikaInParis]

Yeah, thats the thing it was rushed. And fealt unearned. We also saw that Morgan seemed to actually care about protecting civilians and do his duty. So the “what else could he be witholding” line of thought doesnt hold much weight atleast in the eyes of the viewer.

Basically the randoms who are watching this and know nothing about OP will be left wondering why Morgan was so harshly punished and also think of Garp as someone more sinister then he really is.

Garp was (for some reason) presented as way more villainous than he ever was in the manga

Even when we didn't know his identity, he was never presented as some sort of ruthless, ends-justify-the-means type of guy.

Granted, I've yet to watch the last two episodes, so I don't know how his arc is resolved in this Season. But from what I've seen he's far removed from the unhinged but jolly manga and anime Garp

 

[Fujishiro]

Garp was (for some reason) presented as way more villainous than he ever was in the manga

Even when we didn't know his identity, he was never presented as some sort of ruthless, ends-justify-the-means type of guy.

Granted, I've yet to watch the last two episodes, so I don't know how his arc is resolved in this Season. But from what I've seen he's far removed from the unhinged but jolly manga and anime Garp

Aye.