General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
The only one to say why* granted. Predicted how and why the moment 985 dropped.
Nothing "crashed", the conclusion to my theory was just proven false, but everything, every strange points - again as always - still remains. Carrot was build like a strawhat while Yamato was build as the opposite. There is still a chance for Carrot but none for Yamato.
Nothing "crashed", the conclusion to my theory was just proven false, but everything, every strange points - again as always - still remains. Carrot was build like a strawhat while Yamato was build as the opposite. There is still a chance for Carrot but none for Yamato.
That why she faded into the background in Act 1 😂
And when she got the chance to shine in Onigashima against ya know, Pedro's killer she fails. In a 2v1 mind you. Gets bailed out by Neko and that's that.
And I don't want to hear the excuse of "well they would have won if the moon didn't disappear" yes. But they didn't win. So invalid.
And when she got the chance to shine in Onigashima against ya know, Pedro's killer she fails. In a 2v1 mind you. Gets bailed out by Neko and that's that.
And I don't want to hear the excuse of "well they would have won if the moon didn't disappear" yes. But they didn't win. So invalid.
Didn’t you also analyze the story and come to the conclusion that Carrot would join? How did that end up? You can pretend to me a master story analyzer all you want, you prediction didn’t happen. Yamato was written to join and then Oda changed his mind. You can tell by the way he changed handling her but also that they left with the promise that she could join latter on.
Indeed, she failed. Carrot+Wanda and the scabbard are the ONLY protagonist who failed to defeat their ennemy. In the case of Carrot its not really a defeat of Wanda its more portrayed as a defeat for Carrot.
But the question is, WHY? What purpose does it serves. We know for the scabbard, but for Carrot we still don't.
No. I analysed a very specific tool.
Yes she was. I'm sorry but that just a fact.
Really ?
Like I said, yes my conclusion was proven wrong. But a theory is constructed because there are unusual things happening. Those things still remains.
No. Sorry, but no.
And it might be the same for Carrot, its just that for Carrot, there was no subversive affirmation.
Nothing changed.
But the question is, WHY? What purpose does it serves. We know for the scabbard, but for Carrot we still don't.
No. I analysed a very specific tool.
Yes she was. I'm sorry but that just a fact.
Really ?
Like I said, yes my conclusion was proven wrong. But a theory is constructed because there are unusual things happening. Those things still remains.
No. Sorry, but no.
And it might be the same for Carrot, its just that for Carrot, there was no subversive affirmation.
Nothing changed.
He crashed harder because he dedicated his life to his theory for 5-6 years analyzing every panel of every chapter and still came to wrong conclusion. We just stan Yamato cuz she is amazing she still has better chances as Carrot.
Yes but it means you read those things wrong and very adding your own bias onto them. Because everybody else was reading them properly and saying she will not join.
Post automatically merged:
Yes but it means you read those things wrong and very adding your own bias onto them. Because everybody else was reading them properly and saying she will not join.
Last edited:
No, I just deduced the most logical outcome being that Carrot was meant to be on the seas, not on Zou. Her being kidnapped by the ennemy was a probability but it didn't made much sence. Same, her forming a crew was unlikely as she was not portrayed as a leader in the story and by not portrayed as a leader I mean that she was portrayed literally as the OPPOSITE of a leader. So the most logical option looking at all the little clues, was that she was meant to join the strawhats.
It was just a deducing game, nothing more.
That's why nothing "crashed" for me. Through Carrot I learned a LOT about storytelling and Oda's writing so nothing was "lost", only the conclusion was wrong, which was a possibility also. Its just that.. it doesn't make much sence.. or does it ?
Well I read one piece and analyzed the story and deduced that Carrot will not join. I saw her “leadership” skills and deduced she would end up ruling Zou. Nothing that happened to her surprised me. Also the fact that Yamato remained in Wano for now is not surprising to me. Also that Yamato will join later is guaranteed. So don’t worry to much about it.
