Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    501
you forgot my rule of being in approximate distance. It’s very important so that one can join.

Stussy: with the strawhats +150 points +50 points guy it looks like she will travel with them and VP to Elbaf

Bonney: also with them +150 points

Larrot: far away in Zou and keeps moving further away -10038 points so currently she is at -10000

you can’t not count my points because they come from made up rules. So do your points
No. This could be an actual rule... if only it was supported by the storytelling. And in this case, its not, a character can go back to the story at any time so we can't take the distance into account.
 
So you do admit that Yamato can join :myman:
Well let's see how Yamato does.

Let's not forget:

Stussy: 12 Points
Bonney : 24 Points
Carrot : 38 Points

So Yamato do check easily the 5 golden rules.

As for the 10 Pillars:


- Fighting skill, Check. 1 point.
- Antagonistic introduction, Check ONLY because she was mentionned as the son of Kaido so its an indirect one. 2 Points
- Multilayered characterization. Check. 3 points
- Symbolic reach. Check. 4 Points
- Strong character arc. Small character arc so half the point +0.5. 3 Points
- Hint of the 2 driving forces. Check. 6 Points
- The rescue. Only if you think Luffy freeing her from the cuff counts, so half the points + 0.5. 4 Points
- The Nakama need. Nothing. 0 point
- Post. Nothing. 0 point.
- Shining Nakama action. Nothing 0 point.

Yamato wins 23 Points which puts her behind Bonney in term of probability of joining the crew.
 
Well let's see how Yamato does.

Let's not forget:

Stussy: 12 Points
Bonney : 24 Points
Carrot : 38 Points

So Yamato do check easily the 5 golden rules.

As for the 10 Pillars:


- Fighting skill, Check. 1 point.
- Antagonistic introduction, Check ONLY because she was mentionned as the son of Kaido so its an indirect one. 2 Points
- Multilayered characterization. Check. 3 points
- Symbolic reach. Check. 4 Points
- Strong character arc. Small character arc so half the point +0.5. 3 Points
- Hint of the 2 driving forces. Check. 6 Points
- The rescue. Only if you think Luffy freeing her from the cuff counts, so half the points + 0.5. 4 Points
- The Nakama need. Nothing. 0 point
- Post. Nothing. 0 point.
- Shining Nakama action. Nothing 0 point.

Yamato wins 23 Points which puts her behind Bonney in term of probability of joining the crew.
Shining Nakama action omega check or did you not see the last episode. Her post is look out. It’s been foreshadowed as she always looked out to the see.

and she also gets a 1million points from my rule of glowing friendship activity
 
Yeah it's also logic that a "false enemy/friend" doesn't apply to Lucci or Franky. Lucci was never on the SH side and Franky was a straight up enemy untill they found a common enemy.
:lawsigh:

I don't even know why I try sometimes. And after that I'm said to be obnoxious. Lmao


Lucci was never on the SH side and Franky was a straight up enemy untill they found a common enemy.
The purpose of the concept of a false ally is that its a character that is an ally that transforms into an adversary, what Lucci did in waterseven. as for the false ennemy its the same but in the inverse. And Franky was always meant to be an ally just as Lucci was always meant to be an ennemy. Gosh.. this is tiring.


I've seen it several times, but I gotta ask.

What the flying fuck is a Shining Nakama Moment?
Its a bit long to explain that's why I propose that you check this page of my blog where I explain this concept in detail.

Here.
 
So you do admit that Yamato can join :myman:
I already told that Yamato will never join for the simple reason that she knows information about the meaning of D


Yamato has never left Wano, So how can she knows that the D has a certain value ?

Looking at the journal, she tells us that it’s thanks to it that she knows that the D has a certain value

It’s Robin who has to learn the meaning of D to the SH, So if one SH already know, it kill all of the symbolism of Robin telling the story to the SH
 
I already told that Yamato will never join for the simple reason that she knows information about the meaning of D


Yamato has never left Wano, So how can she knows that the D has a certain value ?

Looking at the journal, she tells us that it’s thanks to it that she knows that the D has a certain value

It’s Robin who has to learn the meaning of D for the SH, So if one SH already know, it kill all of the symbolism of Robin telling the story to the SH
Did I ask you? Or are you a C4N alt and mixed the accounts up?
 
Here I was thinking it was going to be some crazy iconic moment that you could instantly relate to each Strawhat like Nami begging Luffy for Help or Zoro saying he'll never lose again.

Hell, what thing did Carrot see that nobody else saw that constitues a "shining nakama moment"?

I thought you were just gonna big up her first Sulong transformation.
The shining Nakama action is closely related to the post so iconic moment like "help me" have nothing to do with that. Sad thing is that you missed really amazing moments.
 
Top