General & Others Pudding vs Hiyori
- Thread starter Albino 👑
- Start date
As a character Pudding is quite better for now.
Pudding is far from being a perfect character and her backstory of being bullied for her 3rd eyes etc was not really my cup of tea.
The two baking the cakes during hours was also average. And she fell in love for Sanji a bit too fast.
But she has good sides : her treason was "good", the evil Pudding was fun, and the way she betrayed Luffy and Sanji was nice in WCI first half.
Also Pudding and Sanji relationship can be interesting in the future : the end with the erased kiss was a good one and can lead to further plot point and interactions.
And the fact that she stayed in her family was good too, this didn't end "well" for her at the end of WCI and this is nice.
The fact that she is a 3rd eyes tribe linked to the Poneglyphes etc can be interesting too.
Her memory powers are cool too. And her second personality is mostly "fun".
Hiyori as a character for now is quite a mess.
As a Komurasaki she was nice. Her bitch side was cool.
But Hiyori is weirddd.
Her relationship with Zoro is insane : the girl has hide her identity for 20 years and she tells everything to the first nice guy who saved her ?!?!
and her attraction for Zoro come from 0 to 100% in no time.
She also played the damsel in distress a lot too much for now.
I hope she will be better in the future but for now her character is not really appealing
Pudding is far from being a perfect character and her backstory of being bullied for her 3rd eyes etc was not really my cup of tea.
The two baking the cakes during hours was also average. And she fell in love for Sanji a bit too fast.
But she has good sides : her treason was "good", the evil Pudding was fun, and the way she betrayed Luffy and Sanji was nice in WCI first half.
Also Pudding and Sanji relationship can be interesting in the future : the end with the erased kiss was a good one and can lead to further plot point and interactions.
And the fact that she stayed in her family was good too, this didn't end "well" for her at the end of WCI and this is nice.
The fact that she is a 3rd eyes tribe linked to the Poneglyphes etc can be interesting too.
Her memory powers are cool too. And her second personality is mostly "fun".
Hiyori as a character for now is quite a mess.
As a Komurasaki she was nice. Her bitch side was cool.
But Hiyori is weirddd.
Her relationship with Zoro is insane : the girl has hide her identity for 20 years and she tells everything to the first nice guy who saved her ?!?!
and her attraction for Zoro come from 0 to 100% in no time.
She also played the damsel in distress a lot too much for now.
I hope she will be better in the future but for now her character is not really appealing
Last edited:
Hiyori, and the fact that everyone else is saying “Pudding FOR NOW” should tell you everything you need to know about this subject. Big Mom’s daughter is already little more than a Sanji stan with the potential to activate VOAT, whereas Oden’s daughter is poised to bitchslap his usurper with impunity by the end of this arc. Not a tough choice for me, nor should it be for the rest of you.
Pudding... The Third-Eye tribe is something that makes her very interesting. Hiyori's just not it for me design and character-wise. Her eyes look like they're about to melt (Pudding has a third eye, but it serves purpose). Hiyori's droopy eyes has no damn business lookin like dat. I hope Zoro ends up with Tashigi/Perona
Last edited:
. only if i had 10% of this drawing skills
I'll wait 2 years to answer that question because if I'm correct, pudding is only 16 years old!!
For real I prefer pudding as a character, I like the inner struggle she had and it was good to see sanji act normally most of the time around a girl for once. So I thank her for that.
I also need to see more of hiyori, so far imo she is a good character, she just needs more panel time. Like her mother, but I expect that to happen in the near future.
For real I prefer pudding as a character, I like the inner struggle she had and it was good to see sanji act normally most of the time around a girl for once. So I thank her for that.
I also need to see more of hiyori, so far imo she is a good character, she just needs more panel time. Like her mother, but I expect that to happen in the near future.
Anyway, Pudding for the win
