Not remotely close, Kaido wasn't smacking his crew while Luffy was on his own to get food. He was pushed out of the island.
I'm not even pushing any agenda, I think the fight was meant to be inconclusive, but this is weird from Luffy's character, to just leave and grab food while making his crew get into unrealistic winning odds.
Kaido was oppressing Wano and going after everyone and especially Momo, it has the exact same consequences.
Then, if we are not pushing agendas, let's discuss this seriously and not with this agenda nonsense.
Luffy slowed down Kizaru and punched him. Kizaru was temporarily paralyzed. Saturn had to land on Egghead to take over the mission.
Luffy succeeded in his mission and won that fight or duel, or whatever you call it, like he won against Lucci before.
He even stood up before Kizaru so the "who stands up first" argument is not even valable anymore.
Did Luffy kill Kizaru? No. Did Luffy win that fight? Yes.
Is Kizaru over for good? Of course that no.