If you can trace back to justify events that happened then those events weren't pre planned. This is simple.
That's not how storytelling works lol
You can claim he didn't let any clues for us so his revelation makes no fucking sense because the entire story contradicts it therefore it is a retcon.
I didn't claimed that. He did let clues for us, just not at the very beginning of the story, more like around chapter 300/400 with the arrival of gear 2. You could say that the simple nature of Luffy's fighting style since the beginning of the story is also a clue and a forshadowing in itself tho.
And here you are accepting G5 too fast that shouldn't be possible.
G5 is self explanatory, there nothing more to accept mate. It makes perfect sence.
G2 and G4 were perfectly explained
Indeed, because the story is goofy by essence it made sence, but in reality, those were HUGE forshadowings
G3 that would be his most obvious and well explained power up after G5 since we saw that a lot in cartoon (Tom & Jerry for example).
Oh, you are right, gear 3 is also a forshadowing, I don't know why I forgot it.
Or you talking about his meat? Well G5 doesn't explain that. It makes no sense.
Yes it does. G5 is the power of imagination over matter and body. In other words:
- If Luffy thinks he can stretch, he will stretch. (If Luffy thinks he can't stretch anymore then his arm will be ripped appart)
- If Luffy thinks he can create a baseball hat, he will create a baseball hat
- If Luffy thinks he will reach his limits, he will shrink, get older or flat out like a balloon
- If Luffy thinks he can enhance his body by pumping his blood he will create gear 2
- If Luffy thinks he can make his arm bigger and stronger by blowing into it (even if it doesn't make sence), he will create gear 3
- If Luffy thinks that he can apply haki to his muscles and create stronger attack by blowing into his bones he will creates G4 and make different variants
- If Luffy thinks he can't die, he won't die (and if Luffy thinks he will die then he WILL die)
- If Luffy thinks that he can lose weight he will lose weight just by running
- If Luffy thinks he can recover just with a nap and a chunk meat he will recover just with a nap a a chunck of meat
Etc.
Luffy will only be stopped by his own mind, thoughts and imagination. That's why his fruit will be both his strenght AND his weakness. Because Luffy KNOWS that there is no shortcut toward victory, so he will create his own weaknesses. But he will also create his own strenght like the way he can recover.
Luffy is Luffy. He is serious when he needs to be and goofy the rest of the time. So his fruit will follow the pattern.
The ship spirt has nothing to do with Nika. I believe Franky knew about it and told Usopp.
How can you be sure ? Did you ever see any other Klabautermann ? Not really hm?..
In reality its a myth. And its probably a myth because the first one to create one was most probably Joy Boy.
We saw how the fruit of Luffy warped reality (at least visually) in chapter 1044.. so the creation of the soul of the Merry due to a long exposure to the fruit and the will of Luffy for the ship to be a real crewmate should not be excluded.
Law DF isn't supposed to do a lot of what he does. Kid DF too. Queen, Sasaki are just ridiculous. Kaido coated in magma-like fire makes no fucking sense.
Technically, ALL fruits are the "fruits" of imagination.. so what I said still stands. its not because Nika is Nika that other fruits can be a little bit pushy on the imaginative side as well
At the end Oda is just making whatever the fuck he wants as he told when making G5 and coming with low effort excuses that makes no sense.
And that's just pure ignorance.
G5 is literally the pinncacle of the theme of the entire story. The story IS gear 5 and gear 5 IS the story. The theme of happyness and joy is literally imprinted in EVERY aspect of the story.
Trust me that any one with a bit of writing skill can see how beautiful and well thought of it is for gear 5 to exist in such a context.
Karakuri DF being logia like makes no sense.
He is not a logia.
Perospero making a functioning arm made of his DF makes no sense.
Of course it does.. He can literally control candy... Are you for real ?
Enel "God form" that Luffy beated makes no sense.
Why ? Enel can shape electricity as he wants and he is a logia, of course it makes sence.
It you who doesn't make sence right now lol
And it doesn't make sense for Luffy to be immune to high voltage lightning.
Okay, I don't even now why you can take yourself seriously sometimes ...