Multiverse General Who is the better older brother?

[TheAncientCenturion]

Wrong it could be just quick coup, Uchiha surely have their connections with other groups, such as Hyuga, who also hated Sarutobi.

Headcanon

 

[Alarica]

No, there is no “couldve”

Instead of making fanfic and headcanon im going with what the story tells us. The Uchiha Coup would spell the end for the entire village, Uchiha included

Danzo manipulated Itachi, he was leader of radical military organization such as Alkaida. And this organization was against law.

 

[Roo]

He had many other options he could join Uchiha clan in coup .

He could take Sasuke and run away, we dont know how things would play out if coup would happen , maybe his parents would survive maybe not.

He could just stay neutral , leave and run away , I doubt Hiruzen would order slaughter of Uchiha children .

Every option is better than murdering your own parents .

He didnt prevent Konoha civil war or anything because in reality he completely slaughtered entire fighting side in potential civil war that could happen.

This is all fanfic. The story tells us there’s two option so there’s only two options. If you want to start writing alt universe I suggest you go to Fanfiction.net

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Honest question for @TheAncientCenturion @Roo would you kill your entire extended family for the sake of your country

 

[Natalija]

Even Obito agreed the Uchiha coup was short sighted. He wasn’t manipulated

Obito had his own interest here, which is to end them. Of course he's gonna agree to it and add fuel to the fire, that's literally all he does in the manga.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Life long PTSD, not to mention how he didn’t think through what Sasuke would do if he found out the truth

PTsD was guaranteed regardless of what happened. The coup would’ve been as traumatic

Only 4 people knew the secret to Itachi’s knowledge, himself included. So he was covered there.

 

[Alarica]

Headcanon

Hiruzen didn't even try to protect most famous and rich clan from killing their leader. There was a lot of hatred against LV goverment.

 

[Roo]

Obito had his own interest here, which is to end them. Of course he's gonna agree to it and add fuel to the fire, that's literally all he does in the manga.

You realize everybody involved kinda sees the writing in the wall, but you’re dismissing it for some reason and another right?

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Hiruzen didn't even try to protect most famous and rich clan from killing their leader. There was a lot of hatred against LV goverment.

And they show zero signs of holding a grudge against Konoha for it. Even Neji blamed his uncle

 

[Natalija]

You realize everybody involved kinda sees the writing in the wall, but you’re dismissing it for some reason and another right?

No, everybody is just you and TAC

Look, I'm not arguing Itachi didn't feel like he had no choice. I'm arguing it's stupid.

 

[AL sama]

Your family is on the verge of erasing the entire village. How is that a psycho thing to do? If anything only killing them for doing something wrong to you is more psycopathic. Psychopaths only care about what people do for them, they have 0 empathy

roo are you trying to justify his act as a brother a son or as konohana's hero??

 

[Roo]

roo are you trying to justify his act as a brother a son or as konohana's hero??

Considering he’s called a hero in the story, his brother and parents forgive him? Yes

jokes aside it’s just that he’s not some crazed sociopath. Being a murderer doesn’t make you one

 

[Alarica]

And they show zero signs of holding a grudge against Konoha for it. Even Neji blamed his uncle

That wasn't showed in story, nothing more. Plus Neji blamed clan leader. Also it was obvious that Goverment in Konoha was corrupted.

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Your family is on the verge of erasing the entire village. How is that a psycho thing to do? If anything only killing them for doing something wrong to you is more psycopathic. Psychopaths only care about what people do for them, they have 0 empathy

You would kill an entire ethnic group which has faced discrimination for decades for a village that doesn’t care about you? It’s retarded

 

[Natalija]

It's his love scaling which is nonsense in this whole story.

Brother > Village and its shadow leadership > Family

His whole existence is contradictory

 

[Djordje]

This is all fanfic. The story tells us there’s two option so there’s only two options. If you want to start writing alt universe I suggest you go to Fanfiction.net

Story tells us there are 2 possible outcomes regarding Uchiha - Konoha civil war not course of action Itachi could take. Are you slow or something btw ?

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

That wasn't showed in story, nothing more. Plus Neji blamed clan leader. Also it was obvious that Goverment in Konoha was corrupted.

Okay so again, the idea of the Hyuga having any grudge against Konoha is your headcanon and doesn’t reflect the manga

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Considering he’s called a hero in the story, his brother and parents forgive him? Yes

His parents had no reason to forgive him

 

[Roo]

Story tells us there are 2 possible outcomes regarding Uchiha - Konoha civil war not course of action Itachi could take. Are you slow or something btw ?

No but you’re definitely retarded. Itachi only had two options, help Konoha or side with his clan. Inaction was never a choice

Post automatically merged: Apr 12, 2024

You would kill an entire ethnic group which has faced discrimination for decades for a village that doesn’t care about you? It’s retarded

So discrimination is a good reason for leading the village into its eventual doom?

see how I can also play this game?

 

[Djordje]

No but you’re definitely retarded. Itachi only had two options, help Konoha or side with his clan. Inaction was never a choice

Only one retarded is you with your takes and limited way of thinking