Versus Battle Which manga has the worst fight choreography in the Big 3

[Adeer Ruckus]

Ichigo vs Ikkaku alone clears this fight choreography wise.

You goddamn liar, this is the Ikkaku vs Ichigo has 4 pages of actual choreography and even those pages aren’t even half as fluid or easy to follow as the One Piece pages

Outside of this and a little in the Kenpachi fight bleach had no choreography. I don’t even need Luffy vs Katakuri or Luffy vs Lucci to show how clear of Bleach

Naruto/Bleach >>> One piece

Naruto is carried by the anime even then it far better than Bleach fights

 

[MonsterKaido]

You goddamn liar, this is the Ikkaku vs Ichigo has 4 pages of actual choreography and even those pages aren’t even half as fluid or easy to follow as the One Piece pages

Outside of this and a little in the Kenpachi fight bleach had no choreography. I don’t even need Luffy vs Katakuri or Luffy vs Lucci to show how clear of Bleach


Naruto is carried by the anime even then it far better than Bleach fights

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

1 Bleach fight that’s even close to One Piece choreography

 

[Ssg super suit coby]

Name 1 good bleach fight

Hisagi vs findorr

Yamamoto vs Yhwach

Kenpachi vs gremmy

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Bleach has a lot of style but nothing really happens in those fights.

A handful of cool moves, a character is tossed backwards with scuff mark damage, then someone attacks the character from behind the deals grievous/fight ending injuries.

One Piece fights have never been good though. It's mostly movement lines lol. Any sword fight in OP is garbage

 

[Roo]

Obviously Naruto is the best

one piece fights are mid, bleach is literally all flash no substance. If bankais weren’t a thing Bleach would’ve flopped hard

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Hisagi vs findorr

Yamamoto vs Yhwach

Kenpachi vs gremmy

No of these have good choreography lol

Bleach has a lot of style but nothing really happens in those fights.

A handful of cool moves, a character is tossed backwards with scuff mark damage, then someone attacks the character from behind the deals grievous/fight ending injuries.

One Piece fights have never been good though. It's mostly movement lines lol. Any sword fight in OP is garbage

No bleach sword fight has as good choreography as Zoro vs Kaku or Mr. 1. Bleach has ass fights. Naruto fights are carried anime too

Post automatically merged: Apr 16, 2024

Obviously Naruto is the best

one piece fights are mid, bleach is literally all flash no substance. If bankais weren’t a thing Bleach would’ve flopped hard

Naruto is mediocre and bleach is ass. OP easily has the best fights

 

[SkySanji]

One Piece losing in a One Piece forum is fucking hilarious, shows how bad it really is and how skewered the poll would be anywhere else

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

One Piece losing in a One Piece forum is fucking hilarious, shows how bad it really is and how skewered the poll would be anywhere else

Nope, it shows that most people here have no idea about fight choreography. I’ve asked numerous guys here to explain their viewpoint yet none have.

 

[Krusher1357]

If you have a problem with oda having bad choreography bleach isn't much better.

You don't even see the blokes go to swing, it's always finished slash, slash is flying then impact. That's literally just as bad as zoro vs apoo... which is one of the worst one piece fights that's ever happened in the entirety of the fukn manga

 

[Moegara]

I'd have a harder time if the question was which one is the best.

But which one is the worst is easy.

 

[Buusatan94]

Neither One Piece nor Bleach are good at fight choregraphies, Naruto is far ahead of them.

 

[mario time]

Bleach fights are repetitive and boring imo

Post automatically merged: Apr 16, 2024

Neither One Piece nor Bleach are good at fight choregraphies, Naruto is far ahead of them.

I agree

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Neither One Piece nor Bleach are good at fight choregraphies, Naruto is far ahead of them.

Naruto has mid choreography in the manga.

 

[Blahmigooo]

One piece is a dramatic fight with plot and narratives taking the lead.
70% offscreen/stall and then straight to the climax of the fight that ends with 2, 3 moves.

The other two are battle oriented drawn out fights with complex and versatile abilities and perhaps more choreography
You get the answer...

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

One piece is a dramatic fight with plot and narratives taking the lead.

The other two are battle oriented with complex and versatile power and abilities.
You get the answer...

Name one good bleach fight

 

[Blahmigooo]

Name one good bleach fight

Byakuya vs Ichigo
Ulq/Grim vs ichigo
Etc

Sadly the final war arc has rush fights due to certain problems from Kubo.
But still most of them are technical and better drawn than One piece fights.

You name good one piece fights......Eg: Kaido vs Luffy R2, Kata vs Luffy, EL Lucci vs Luffy those are at the top but still doesn't compare to Bleach top fights. Especially after time skip, it's just haki spark exchange. Anime carry one piece fights.
There isn't an actual 1v1 showdown like Bleach tbh in one piece,
It's like a messy multi tasking/mission battle.

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Byakuya vs Ichigo
Ulq/Grim vs ichigo
Etc

Sadly the final war arc has rush fights due to certain problems from Kubo.
But still most of them are technical and better drawn than One piece fights.

You name good one piece fights......Eg: Kaido vs Luffy R2, Kata vs Luffy, EL Lucci vs Luffy those are at the top but still doesn't compare to Bleach top fights. Especially after time skip, it's just haki spark exchange. Anime carry one piece fights.
There isn't an actual 1v1 showdown like Bleach tbh in one piece,
It's like a messy multi tasking/mission battle.

None of those fights have choreography close to Zoro vs Mr. 1 much less something Luffy vs Lucci. Ichigo vs Byakuya has 2 instances of good choreography for the whole fight same for the rest of these

 

[Blahmigooo]

None of those fights have choreography close to Zoro vs Mr. 1 much less something Luffy vs Lucci. Ichigo vs Byakuya has 2 instances of good choreography for the whole fight same for the rest of these

He beat up Zoro 99% of time and then Zoro drops him after one deep breath and it's over. I won't say that's better than anything Bleach has offer lol.
Not saying it is trash, as it is still top notch in op standard since most of them are trash due to lack of effort from Oda.
EL Luffy vs Lucci might be the closest to match Bleach standard.
The thrill from the get go, both ups and down for the villain and good guy throughout the course of the battle

In addition the drawings, panel and choreography of Bleach fights are fking smooth and aesthetically beautiful compared to the likes of op.
One piece fights are more dramatic that is the main selling point.
If Oda has to write one piece with Bleach plot it won't even reach the rank that Kubo has it with Bleach.

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

L

He beat up Zoro 99% of time and then Zoro drops him after one deep breath and it's over. I won't say that's better than anything Bleach has offer lol.
Not saying it is trash, as it is still top notch in op standard since most of them are trash due to lack of effort from Oda.
EL Luffy vs Lucci might be the closest to match Bleach standard.
The thrill from the get go, both ups and down for the villain and good guy throughout the course of the battle

In addition the drawings, panel and choreography of Bleach fights are fking smooth and aesthetically beautiful compared to the likes of op.
One piece fights are more dramatic that is the main selling point.
If Oda has to write one piece with Bleach plot it won't even reach the rank that Kubo has it with Bleach.

We’re talking about choreography here keep up. Show me a single set of panels which is as fluid as Zoro vs Mr. 1. Bleach fights are just energy blasts with no rhyme or reason. The constant power ups aren’t fun either.