Controversial General Political Discussion
- Thread starter AL sama
- Start date
- Tags #freepalestine are you having fun al? are you having van al? dei must go gaolang > your fav is not paying tax sexist is van having fun al? life goal sister harem real madrid reloaded is innocent tax is the best thing ever happened to us trans rights = human rights trans women are not interested in any of you watch for haters weebs discussing politics lmao worst thread ever
So it wasn’t going to work lol
“Surrounded” is probably a better word, regardless it was that he described. Mainly a state around the Jaffa area
Post automatically merged:
Aside from the Peel commission's plan and the partition plan of 1947, I don't know of any other proposals Britain gave, especially not one within a "a greater Palestinian" state.
Here's the map for the Peel's commission plan:
This is true, Zionism was always against the idea of a Palestinian state, and have lobbied against it decades before the Nakba in 1948.
Here is one of the leading zionist leaders in the early 20th century, echoing these thoughts in 1931:
Here's the map for the Peel's commission plan:
This is true, Zionism was always against the idea of a Palestinian state, and have lobbied against it decades before the Nakba in 1948.
Here is one of the leading zionist leaders in the early 20th century, echoing these thoughts in 1931:
UK did propose a smaller jewish state in their partition plans mainly around jaffa tho, that was my point
http://passia.org/media/filer_publi...cde6f2c/pdfresizercom-pdf-crop_8-page-001.jpg
http://passia.org/media/filer_publi...cde6f2c/pdfresizercom-pdf-crop_8-page-001.jpg
Last edited:
Thats what I asked about, tell me about the proposal since its my first time hearing of it. Aside from the Peel comission and partition plan of 1947, I do not know of any attempts of Britain to create a small Jewish state centered in Jaffa's region.
That was the understanding of Balfour's declaration from the first place, that all of Palestine (and Transjordan) was gonna be a Jewish state.
This was a part of the response of the Zionist congress in response to the Peel commission:
Never have I ever heard of this plan you're talking about.
That was the understanding of Balfour's declaration from the first place, that all of Palestine (and Transjordan) was gonna be a Jewish state.
This was a part of the response of the Zionist congress in response to the Peel commission:
Never have I ever heard of this plan you're talking about.
i literally linked it
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodh...roposed a coastal Jewish,Arab state in Plan A.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodh...roposed a coastal Jewish,Arab state in Plan A.
The link didn't show up for me when I first read the post.
This was a follow-up on the Peel commission's plan that utterly failed.
The way you phrased it in your first post was misleading. Plan C would only make a Jewish state in Jaffa's until Jews and Arabs would decide what pieces of land they would take. The plan was gonna create mandatory areas that would later join either the Jewish or Arab states.
It reached a point where the British government thought it was mess.
They still brought the plan to both Jews and Arabs, and both rejected the plans. No need to single out Arabs as the ones who declined it.
This was a follow-up on the Peel commission's plan that utterly failed.
The way you phrased it in your first post was misleading. Plan C would only make a Jewish state in Jaffa's until Jews and Arabs would decide what pieces of land they would take. The plan was gonna create mandatory areas that would later join either the Jewish or Arab states.
It reached a point where the British government thought it was mess.
They still brought the plan to both Jews and Arabs, and both rejected the plans. No need to single out Arabs as the ones who declined it.
Misleading? not my fault you inserted your own assumptions into my comment/
Because Monkey D Theories was talking about approval, as in they(palestinians) would be okay with a jewish state in the area around Jaffa as the main opponents of a jewish state at all were them. Clearly that wasn't the case.
They still brought the plan to both Jews and Arabs, and both rejected the plans. No need to single out Arabs as the ones who declined it.
