Town
4. Emil - Usopp
7: Yo Tan Wa
14: RippedCal - Franky
23: Alwaysmind - Jinbei
24: T
yrant Muugen
27: Dr. Watson - Carrot
28: Naomi - Chopper
29: Charlie
Beast Pirates
16: The Orca - Queen
Big Mom Pirates
8: Pot Goblin - Pero or BM
31: Mashiro Blue - Caesar Clown
35: Worst V2 - Rayleigh? I don't f know.
This leaves 1 member of each mafia group, Blackbeard and Doflamingo within this group. If you're Town and you're here, it should be easier for you.
5: Kiku
6: Lord Melkor
9: Random Asshole
11: Ratchet
19: Mr. Reloaded
20: CoC. Color of Clowns
30: Crowned Witch
My guesses:
Blackbeard - either LM or Ratchet. Probably LM. Impossible
Doflamingo - either Kiku or CoC. Thinking Kiku. She'd have balls to fake out Lynch redirect imo. Impossible for Asshole.
Big Mom Pirate - tbh, no idea. Couldn't be Asshole either. If it's Perospero, it can't be Ratchet and Reloaded either, leaving Kiku, LM, CoC and Witch. If it's BM, it could be anyone (other than Asshole).
Kaido - could be literally anyone. Rn i'd guess Reloaded probably.
Least likely to be scum from this list are CoC and RA imo. Then Relo and Ratchet. Then rest.
My reads are usually shet so feel free to ignore parts where i share my opinions.