Speculations The Return of Scopper Gaban

Is this Scopper Gaban?


  • Total voters
    32
Shiki makes zero sense honestly.
Yorki less than zero.
As for why it could be Gaban and what relevance he could offer - info on the 4th poneglyph, on how to arrange the poneglyphs to get the location of LT, any trickery surrounding LT and how to reach it once you know where it is etc
He was shown drawing coordinates on the map when the Roger pirates were about to go there so he was probably their navigator, or close to it
 
Agreed about the Roger pirates. I just don’t see it being Shiki since this individual seems more connected to the Roger pirates
The fact Is back in the day that person had far more sense It was Shiki:

- chapter 631 came a years after SW was released, and so It made more sense that It was Shiki and not Gaban, Who had zero focus;

- the official coloring made It clear It was Shiki.

Now who knows.
 
Wasn't that meant to refer to Dorry and Broggy?
Maybe? Doesnt make sense to me:
So let's assume Roger and his crew, or Shanks very early on, visited Little Garden (as otherwise "old" probably doesn't make sense)

We see Shanks during the East Blue Saga in East Blue, that means he was easyl able to check on them going through rivers mountain as its very close to Little garden.

This is also about the same time the Strawhats Pirate meet the Giants. And they don't receive any news about them for almost 3 years yet not one of them thought they were dead

And Mr. 3 told us no one heard about broggy and dorry since they started their duel 100 years ago. So there was no world news concerning them being dead in any semi-recent times.


Also, we know from Oimo and Kashi that the giants pirate dissolved after they left Dorry and Broggy behind on little garden, so their location never changes.

Shanks seems to allied with Elbaf of giants, so even if he would go there and ask, they would refer them to Little garden

I personally don't see how Shanks logically ever thought they were dead
 
Shiki makes zero sense honestly.
Yorki less than zero.
As for why it could be Gaban and what relevance he could offer - info on the 4th poneglyph, on how to arrange the poneglyphs to get the location of LT, any trickery surrounding LT and how to reach it once you know where it is etc
He was shown drawing coordinates on the map when the Roger pirates were about to go there so he was probably their navigator, or close to it
For this we have the man marked by flames
 
Maybe? Doesnt make sense to me:
So let's assume Roger and his crew, or Shanks very early on, visited Little Garden (as otherwise "old" probably doesn't make sense)

We see Shanks during the East Blue Saga in East Blue, that means he was easyl able to check on them going through rivers mountain as its very close to Little garden.

This is also about the same time the Strawhats Pirate meet the Giants. And they don't receive any news about them for almost 3 years yet not one of them thought they were dead

And Mr. 3 told us no one heard about broggy and dorry since they started their duel 100 years ago. So there was no world news concerning them being dead in any semi-recent times.


Also, we know from Oimo and Kashi that the giants pirate dissolved after they left Dorry and Broggy behind on little garden, so their location never changes.

Shanks seems to allied with Elbaf of giants, so even if he would go there and ask, they would refer them to Little garden

I personally don't see how Shanks logically ever thought they were dead
All true but the next panel reveals them standing behind Shanks. It could be an Oda hiccup
 
Top