@Flower Let me try this again for you.
If we think Rej needs to be lynched, we lynch Rej. This is because, the contention is not that he's attached to scum. The contention is that Rej is making backdoor deals with scum. It could be an ability or a third wincon that he has omitted - the point is it's being done without Melkor's knowledge. So if we lynch Melkor, and he flips Town, we don't address any part of the above. Do you see now why what you're saying we do doesn't work?
If we think Rej needs to be lynched, we lynch Rej. This is because, the contention is not that he's attached to scum. The contention is that Rej is making backdoor deals with scum. It could be an ability or a third wincon that he has omitted - the point is it's being done without Melkor's knowledge. So if we lynch Melkor, and he flips Town, we don't address any part of the above. Do you see now why what you're saying we do doesn't work?