Speculations Could Garling replace Saturn as Gorosei?

[Monkey D Theories]

Saturn led the invasion of egghead

As a result I think he’s going to be held responsible for the WG’s blunder in letting Luffy escape.

Given the last page of 1121, I do wonder if Saturn could get booted from the Gorosei due to his failure.

The final spread showed Garling and someone who looked very similar to the #2 holy knight.

With all the hype Garling has been getting, I wonder if Oda might have him replace Saturn as Gorosei. While he isn’t an immortal, perhaps immortality can be transferred somehow.

As punishment for his failure, Imu might demand Saturn transfer his immortality to Garling and step down as Gorosei.

Ultimately think it’s possible that Garling becomes a new member of the Gorosei, silhouette man becomes commander of the holy knights, and Saturn loses his immortality and just becomes a regular holy knight.

Kinda what happened to Snack after his loss.

 

[Roo]

Garling needs to immortality and I don’t think Imu can just gift it

 

[Reborn]

No

Devon will

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

Yeah Saint Shanks’ father could probably job this hard

 

[K!NG HARA$H!MA]

I think that's will happen

Garling joining the Gorosei


Thanks become the leader of Holy Knight's, Garling previous post

 

[MarineHQ]

Garling is stronger than the Gorosei so no. Devon will take Saturn's place.

 

[JoNdule]

Yup

 

[Monkey D Theories]

No

Devon will

Garling is stronger than the Gorosei so no. Devon will take Saturn's place.

This can’t happen

Saturn has powerful haki so much so that the entire island felt it when he arrived.

There’s no way Hancock’s victim could fool Imu and the gorosei.

My guess is she just uses her Saturn disguise to sneak into mariejois, trick some fodder, and steal DFs and some other treasures for Teach.

 

[comrade]

All of the Gorosei failed though, along with Kizaru, who basically refused to serve. And Saturn seems to be held in high regard by the other Elders, given he is probably the oldest. He was even seen giving command/instructions to the other elders, e.g. telling Mars not to destroy the lab (saying that is out of question) and telling Ju Peter to finish off the ancient robot. They won't just make him resign.

 

[NexusLord]

Why should such a thing happen suddenly like that?

Saturn has been part of their plans for who knows how long?

Any one of them being removed is a huge loss.

There are certain assumptions at play here...

People are assuming the Gorosei get replaced regularly.

People are assuming Saturn is too weak.

People are assuming Garling has what it takes.

How many of these assumptions can be true?

People are assuming Garling is Shanks' dad

People are assuming a silhouette is Shanks brother

It's a lot of assumptions.

 

[Cozy Sofa]

Why should such a thing happen suddenly like that?

Saturn has been part of their plans for who knows how long?

Any one of them being removed is a huge loss.

There are certain assumptions at play here...

People are assuming the Gorosei get replaced regularly.

People are assuming Saturn is too weak.

People are assuming Garling has what it takes.

How many of these assumptions can be true?

People are assuming Garling is Pranks' dad

People are assuming a silhouette is Pranks brother

It's a lot of assumptions.

- Satori (Enels priest) replaced somebody
- Law was groomed to become a Seat
- Snack was demoted
- Jack might have replaced somebody
- Hanafuda, Moriah and Crocodile were replaced
- Magellan was demoted

It’s not out of the picture someone might get replaced or demoted.

 

[NexusLord]

- Satori (Enels priest) replaced somebody
- Law was groomed to become a Seat
- Snack was demoted
- Jack might have replaced somebody
- Hanafuda, Moriah and Crocodile were replaced
- Magellan was demoted

It’s not out of the picture someone might get replaced or demoted.

And while each of those things happened the Five Elder Stars remained the same

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

The man who scarred Whitebeard isn't strong enough to be a Gorosei

 

[zenox]

Garling needs to immortality and I don’t think Imu can just gift it

and thats exactly why they will start hunting law

this is how law gets connected to the final saga
imu will be after his fruit

 

[park_min young]

Either Saturn loses early and gets replaced or Ju Peter is a traitor and he will be replaced. I can see either events happening and Garling gets a powerup from Imu (yokai powers). This will compensate for his old age and he will be a really legit threat, probably on par with St Shanks tbh

 

[Roo]

and thats exactly why they will start hunting law

this is how law gets connected to the final saga
imu will be after his fruit

"...Trafalgar Law has the OP OP no mi he's Luffy's friend and he's currently in Wano. Please capture him so Daddy gets the immortality surgery Gorosei-san"

 

[Monkey D Theories]

W

 

[HA001]

W

If you throw enough 💩 at a wall some will stick

 

[KingOnizam]

W

Good job.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]