You shouldn't do any handpicking as a matter of principle, almost anything outside of this is bias and favorable treatment.
So yes, you can't just season a little bit of it in and then be upset when you're given shit about it. Fairness is really a binary thing. The easy countermeasure is to, of course, stop sucking Blue's tit and treat him like a regular person.
At no junction have you explained why it's remotely neccessary for you to do this besides "he wouldn't like it if he actually had to play an honest game"
Once again, meme game, meme rules - but at some level you think it is permissible to rig an outcome, so it isn't the biggest slap in the face to speculate you rig other outcomes. It's just duly consequential, if you want the right to be offended, you need to not do it on any level.