[FNZ] Role Madness Star Wars OT - Game Thread

[Polar Bear]

@Lord Melkor i now know why you wanted me as a possible sub, lol. I really didn't want back in but would have if I knew that many needed replacing, my bad.

 

[SoulKiller]

It's more warnings for me at the moment. I've git it in hand, think you're fine as you are.

You can give me a warning by the way. I deserve it.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Anyway. I do not think it is controversial that scum played better than town this game overall, both in terms of threadplay and night actions?

 

[Ratchet]

Nah bro, you tried your best. At the end of the day you can only do so much with certain slots.

I still had the capacity to come up with the right answers. And I didn't do that. Was far too co corned about not being the reason Town lose by being horribly wrong instead of just playing unburdened by those sentiments. In other words, my ego cost the team, all I can do is try to play better next time.

 

[Lord Melkor]

I still had the capacity to come up with the right answers. And I didn't do that. Was far too co corned about not being the reason Town lose by being horribly wrong instead of just playing unburdened by those sentiments. In other words, my ego cost the team, all I can do is try to play better next time.

You were good, but Emil and Ultra deserved the win.

Yoho and Orca i think also played better than average townie this game.

 

[Ultra]

Anyway. I think it is controversial that scum played better than town this game overall, both in terms of threadplay and night actions?

 

[The Orca]

i think it wud be much more appreciated if u were more forthcoming with what you planned to do before hand in the chat. i.e if you said i intend to bus vote ultra here because i do it as town etc... that wuda sufficed. the way you were doing it felt very unplanned spite vote. ultra was leading at some point in day 1 cuz of it. thats the part we r having bigger issue with. there is nothing wrong with bussing but make sure u coordinate it with the team. it felt like u were doing whatever u want alone here

He maxed out at 3 votes of 16. At some point D1 I told you all strategically based on my role and given everything it was probably the best case for us to win. Ultra went after me from the start as well without telling me anything. Even lied to get suspect on me. Maybe it felt like I was doing it alone, but strategically that's how you don't get tied to anyone. Difference of opinion on how to play as mafia imo. Too much planning in chat gets you caught

 

[Lord Melkor]

Should be "i do not think" in that post, corrected. One word which changed meaning.

Do we have a system of MVP and HM here like in OLF?

 

[Emil]

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. Are we in the Ultra/Ekko scum world?

this post was the spark, ratchet. needed a bit more town to be cooking with u to light up that fire though

 

[Polar Bear]

@Polar Bear can you tell me the player you are most confident is scum?

I truly believe ultra

@York

Were you planning something off of this?

 

[Ultra]

He maxed out at 3 votes of 16. At some point D1 I told you all strategically based on my role and given everything it was probably the best case for us to win. Ultra went after me from the start as well without telling me anything. Even lied to get suspect on me. Maybe it felt like I was doing it alone, but strategically that's how you don't get tied to anyone. Difference of opinion on how to play as mafia imo. Too much planning in chat gets you caught

Yeah, difference of opinion alright.

I can play however I see fit for my wincon. Best outcome I can see is to play as I would as town, you are playing like shit scum and I'm calling it out, you flip makes me semi clear and I flip makes you semi clear. No rules against bussing and based on your comments here, before the game, and elsewhere this is the logical outcome. Maybe try being a better person

The bolded is showing your hand, blatantly. Not really any way to misinterpret what this is. Try again.

 

[Ratchet]

this post was the spark, ratchet. needed a bit more town to be cooking with u to light up that fire though

Like I said, I had the opportunity to come to the right answers. I didn't get it done. Simple as that really. I will always default to the notion that I could have done better, I don't want to take away from scum of course so I will leave it at that.

 

[Emil]

Like I said, I had the opportunity to come to the right answers. I didn't get it done. Simple as that really. I will always default to the notion that I could have done better, I don't want to take away from scum of course so I will leave it at that.

ggs

 

[The Orca]

Yeah, difference of opinion alright.



The bolded is showing your hand, blatantly. Not really any way to misinterpret what this is. Try again.

The bolded is exactly what I said. Can you not read?

 

[Flower]

He maxed out at 3 votes of 16. At some point D1 I told you all strategically based on my role and given everything it was probably the best case for us to win. Ultra went after me from the start as well without telling me anything. Even lied to get suspect on me. Maybe it felt like I was doing it alone, but strategically that's how you don't get tied to anyone. Difference of opinion on how to play as mafia imo. Too much planning in chat gets you caught

I was day vigged by my team mate once without even discussing anything first. It's stuff that works well as a strategy, but your team mates do tend to get angry at this. I recommend telling your team what you do beforehand, but everyone is different I guess.

 

[Polar Bear]

Yeah, difference of opinion alright.



The bolded is showing your hand, blatantly. Not really any way to misinterpret what this is. Try again.

Ultra literally would be perma banned bc the 3 or 4 games that he (without any discussion at all) voted me d1 and got me lynched when we were both scum together

Ultra is just a trash player

 

[Ultra]

Like I said, I had the opportunity to come to the right answers. I didn't get it done. Simple as that really. I will always default to the notion that I could have done better, I don't want to take away from scum of course so I will leave it at that.

Not taking anything away by acknowledging this was a trainwreck. I was pretty resigned to taking the piss this game the first cycle, then I saw Kekko flipped you as stump and our team mate was outted and I decided to try a bit more, because I felt those circumstances made it worth doing. I'd probably feel like a zombie playing this otherwise.

To your point about balance - I agree Melkor tends to stack Mafia. In practice you can expect game to average about 3 mislynches instead of 4 based on setup. Though if this were a competent town in the least bit, the propensity of roles and the amount of free clears could have made this a town sweep, in another universe

 

[The Orca]

I was day vigged by my team mate once without even discussing anything first. It's stuff that works well as a strategy, but your team mates do tend to get angry at this. I recommend telling your team what you do beforehand, but everyone is different I guess.

Possibly, depends on the team I guess as well. But definitely not playing against my wincon

 

[Flower]

Possibly, depends on the team I guess as well. But definitely not playing against my wincon

It's not. Nothing ban worthy about it, but your team mates getting angry is normal. I think you all need to chill.

 

[Rej]

Yikes, I am overall disappointed reading this post-game, and also while I read about your conflicts during the game.

Individually I really like everyone of you guys, but ingame as team and opponents, you hate to see it.

This game is a prime example on why I became anxious to host and distanced myself from playing and hosting mafia. Seeing these kind of player behaviour as host is just discouraging and saddening, when your job is to host an enjoyable game for everyone where everyone can have fun.

I will sadly continue to act retired until I see an enviroment where these things will occur rarely and not game in and game out. This goes for both WG and OLF because OLF seems to suffer from similair problems. That's just the shared community at this point.

As players it is also your job to give newer hosts a chance to have an enjoyable game, also in it's conclusion and post-game discussion.
Please guys, learn to let go and start anew with every game. This circle beefing and eager competetiveness while aruging is just doing too much harm to the community. Also the refusal to play in alot of circumstances...that's also a real thorn in a host's heart.

Anyway gg to everyone and nice setup @Lord Melkor
I hope you continue to host and enjoy hosting in future. You def need more games up your sleeve and refinement and you will become just amazing.