Future Events Kid will wash ashore Pirate Island, not Elbaf

#21
There is no such thing as “too few.” The point is that important characters do in fact die in One Piece, so just writing off his death as impossible is bad reasoning. It seems very clear by the differences in the epitaphs when Shanks defeated Bartolomeo vs when he beat Kidd that Barto is alive and Kidd is dead.
There is a thing as such as too few, and given that we haven't seen Kid's dead body and weaker characters survive worse, chances are extremely high that Kid is alive.
 
#22
Blud just saw Saul being revived, Vegapunk preparing his own revival, Bonney asking if her dad could be revived and he has the gall to think Kid is dead

:milaugh::milaugh::milaugh:
What does Kid being alive add to the story? Killing him off would at least show how scary Shanks can be when he’s serious
 
#24
And what does reviving the Stella or Kuma add to the story?

If you think Kid is dead you’re the reason why Oda keeps doing fake out deaths
Booma deserves it, Vegapunk is being revived for lore drop purposes only and to fully convert Kizaru later now that he is disaffected. Kidd had a full arc, no backstory, and was also a horrible human being. His death lines up perfectly.

Saying “this is One Piece” is not an argument. People die in the story, so Kidd may be dead. He is likely dead because of the circumstances of his death and his opponent. He was shown getting dropped while Law was shown as clearly escaping. Bartolomeo was given a blurb that said “status unkown” but Kidd was not.
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
#25
No way a half dead man is floating on a piece of wood all the way to Pirate island, it's not like its right next door there's a significant amount of ocean between the two islands
 
#27
No way a half dead man is floating on a piece of wood all the way to Pirate island, it's not like its right next door there's a significant amount of ocean between the two islands
Finally logic

The one power Oda has never subverted is the ocean. Kidd isn’t a fish man so he is dead at the bottom. Fruit users don’t swim or float, they sink like hammers.
 
#28
Booma deserves it, Vegapunk is being revived for lore drop purposes only and to fully convert Kizaru later now that he is disaffected. Kidd had a full arc, no backstory, and was also a horrible human being. His death lines up perfectly.

Saying “this is One Piece” is not an argument. People die in the story, so Kidd may be dead. He is likely dead because of the circumstances of his death and his opponent. He was shown getting dropped while Law was shown as clearly escaping. Bartolomeo was given a blurb that said “status unkown” but Kidd was not.
Kid is so dead Oda didn’t even bother to confirm it in the SBs nor VC. And lmao, Luffy literally got the same blurb when his crew was decimated by Kuma, if anything that leads to the idea that he’s still alive

You guys are seriously gullible and this will be a funny thread to bump when we see him again.
 
#29
Kid is so dead Oda didn’t even bother to confirm it in the SBs nor VC. And lmao, Luffy literally got the same blurb when his crew was decimated by Kuma, if anything that leads to the idea that he’s still alive

You guys are seriously gullible and this will be a funny thread to bump when we see him again.
He is in an underwater Training Camp just Like during wano:finally:
 
#32
The fact that Demalo Black’s crew copied the Kidd pirates is already damning evidence that Kidd is alive. They also thought that the SHs were dead.

It’s just a reverse Sabaody situation, SHs were wiped out - narrator even said it with the same exact words while Kid/Law were unharmed. Kidd and Law will come back with pretty big upgrades.
 
#33
Finally logic

The one power Oda has never subverted is the ocean. Kidd isn’t a fish man so he is dead at the bottom. Fruit users don’t swim or float, they sink like hammers.
Logic doesn't work in One Piece, I used to think it has to but it doesn't.
The story works through hype so whatever is hype at the moment is gonna be used and then disregarded as if it never happened.
Kid was used to hype Ratto-san and that's it, there is no follow up to this.
Sure there is a chance that Kid and Killer are actually dead but I wouldn't bet anything on it, not even a banana peel.
 
Last edited:
#34
I mean this without joking. If Kid somehow gets washed ashore at Pirate Island, without him dying during however long the waves take to drift them there? Kid might as well be Jika for all the plot armor Oda gives him.

Like, I am already mentally prepared for him to show up at Elbaf. Fuck it. But how the HELL would the guy that was sunk of the coast of Elbaf that has also eaten a devil fruit not sunk/drowned during the journey?

On the low end, these islands are still several hours if not days of travel time via ships apart unless you can literally see Pirate Island from Elbaf or something like that.

So how would Kid ever survive this scenario? What, does Elbaf just happen to have a portal at the bottom its sea that leads to Pirate island that Kid fell through? Hell, how would he even drift like that? From what we know, all devil fruit eaters sink like stones.
 
Top