I remember reading years ago speculation about Marguerite joining the crew, due to her interactions with Luffy in Amazon Lily arc. Of course nothing has come out of it and Marguerite has been nearly totally nonexistent since, but at the time I wouldn't have been against it if she had been developped more.
General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
Admittedly not a theory I believe in any more but admittedly did years ago lol. Bringing it back because fuck it poneglyph hype
It’s as simple as there are 4 road poneglyph and maybe we’ll get a member that originates from where each was originally placed. Each location was important enough to have them placed there so maybe they important enough to have crew representation
So far we know 3/4 original locations of the road poneglyph. That being fisman island, zou, and wano. As for the last one while not confirmed it’s likely that it was in elbaf before Linlin decided to steal it from them imo. Elbaf also coincidentally has a special tree like the other 3 locations aka tree piece
Could oda handle highlighting so many crew members evenly? No but it’s oda doesn’t mean that’s going to stop him from doing it regardless lol
Okay so we obviously already have a fishman island rep with Jinbe. With his recruitment high key being a pain in the ass for some who’s been around since impel down
As for a zou representative we obviously don’t have one in the crew. The 3 most relevant mink to the crew besides inuarashi and nekomamushi being carrot, Pedro, and Wanda. Not to get the 4 carrot stans too excited but out of the 3 characters I’d guess she is the most viable option lol
As for how it’d happen idk lol. If I were to theorize further I’d say her best shot is for Pedro to come back. Pounds alive somehow, pekoms is likely alive, Pell is alive, pagaya is, so Pedro might be too lol. The will of p lives on. Maybe “reviving” him through cloning or some soul hax. It also means we can see sulong Pedro
As for why Pedro being alive could help carrot? She has the same will/dream. Neko and inu asked her to rule over zou so maybe Pedro with Wanda can come together to rule and set her free. She obviously doesn’t want to be ruler at least now
Again for the 5 carrot stans I apologize for getting your hopes up
Heads up if you didn’t like the carrot suggestion you’re gonna probably hate this one lol
When it comes to people from wano close to the stawhats we have Yamato, Momonosuke, kinemon, and tama. At face value Yamato wants to join the most so they should join obliviously right? Imo I gotta disagree
While Yamato wants to join I don’t think they will in the common typical way. I believe Yamato like katakuri and weevil should lead a remnants group of their previous crews. Potentially flying the strawhats flag but not being on the sunny. It could be when Yamato decides to take their own path completely separate from oden
It’s gonna sound ridiculous but kinemon showing the least interest in joining the crew and staying with the stawhats in comparison to momo, Yamato, and tama he has a hidden massive advantage over them
That advantage being his devil fruit the fuku fuku no mi aka the clothes fruits. Why is his fruit so important? His fruit unlike the other 3 actually fits the number theory
Momo being able to eat it because he doesn’t have a real devil fruit would be cool. Him temporarily leaving instead would be dope imo but that’s just me. Have hiyori temporarily take over like toki did when oden left
Momo for apprentice hype is back
As for why would oda keep postponing and using random excuses to stop them from joining when they were introduced? Jinbe
As for why would he’d neglect them and not focus on them more? Usopp and crew splits
Oda gonna oda
Who in elbaf should join assuming that’s where the last poneglyph was? Man idk
There’s probably a lot of characters and races
Odens son joins so odins son next
It’s as simple as there are 4 road poneglyph and maybe we’ll get a member that originates from where each was originally placed. Each location was important enough to have them placed there so maybe they important enough to have crew representation
So far we know 3/4 original locations of the road poneglyph. That being fisman island, zou, and wano. As for the last one while not confirmed it’s likely that it was in elbaf before Linlin decided to steal it from them imo. Elbaf also coincidentally has a special tree like the other 3 locations aka tree piece
Could oda handle highlighting so many crew members evenly? No but it’s oda doesn’t mean that’s going to stop him from doing it regardless lol
Okay so we obviously already have a fishman island rep with Jinbe. With his recruitment high key being a pain in the ass for some who’s been around since impel down
As for a zou representative we obviously don’t have one in the crew. The 3 most relevant mink to the crew besides inuarashi and nekomamushi being carrot, Pedro, and Wanda. Not to get the 4 carrot stans too excited but out of the 3 characters I’d guess she is the most viable option lol
As for how it’d happen idk lol. If I were to theorize further I’d say her best shot is for Pedro to come back. Pounds alive somehow, pekoms is likely alive, Pell is alive, pagaya is, so Pedro might be too lol. The will of p lives on. Maybe “reviving” him through cloning or some soul hax. It also means we can see sulong Pedro
As for why Pedro being alive could help carrot? She has the same will/dream. Neko and inu asked her to rule over zou so maybe Pedro with Wanda can come together to rule and set her free. She obviously doesn’t want to be ruler at least now
Again for the 5 carrot stans I apologize for getting your hopes up
Heads up if you didn’t like the carrot suggestion you’re gonna probably hate this one lol
When it comes to people from wano close to the stawhats we have Yamato, Momonosuke, kinemon, and tama. At face value Yamato wants to join the most so they should join obliviously right? Imo I gotta disagree
While Yamato wants to join I don’t think they will in the common typical way. I believe Yamato like katakuri and weevil should lead a remnants group of their previous crews. Potentially flying the strawhats flag but not being on the sunny. It could be when Yamato decides to take their own path completely separate from oden
It’s gonna sound ridiculous but kinemon showing the least interest in joining the crew and staying with the stawhats in comparison to momo, Yamato, and tama he has a hidden massive advantage over them
That advantage being his devil fruit the fuku fuku no mi aka the clothes fruits. Why is his fruit so important? His fruit unlike the other 3 actually fits the number theory
- Luffy - Gomu Gomu no Mi -Go(5) Mu(6) - 5.6
- Chopper - Hito Hito no Mi - Hi(1) To(1/10) - 1.10
- Robin - Hana Hana no Mi - Ha(8) Na(7) - 8.7
- Brook - Yomi Yomi no Mi - Yo(4) Mi(3) - 4.3
- Kinemon - Fuku Fuku no Mi - Fu(2) Ku(9) - 2.9
Momo being able to eat it because he doesn’t have a real devil fruit would be cool. Him temporarily leaving instead would be dope imo but that’s just me. Have hiyori temporarily take over like toki did when oden left
Momo for apprentice hype is back
As for why would oda keep postponing and using random excuses to stop them from joining when they were introduced? Jinbe
As for why would he’d neglect them and not focus on them more? Usopp and crew splits
Oda gonna oda
Who in elbaf should join assuming that’s where the last poneglyph was? Man idk
There’s probably a lot of characters and races
Odens son joins so odins son next
- Fishman island - eve tree - road poneglyph - Jinbe
- Zou - whale tree - road poneglyph - carrot?
- Wano - flower capital tree - road poneglyph - between tama/momo/kinemon/yamato
- Elbaf - Adam tree -road poneglyph - Loki or colon for now
Loki stocks rising. Luffy impressed by the ancient giant horns.
also similar to his beetle love with their horns to.
Also seen good parallel.
It's easy to understand why everyone likes Loki. 
Post automatically merged:
Also other good sign of Luffy interest in Loki, look how relaxed luffy is sitting on Loki.
and
Loki showed no interest in Luffy. As he gets luffy name wrong, and luffy corrects him.
compared to yamato, and carrot forcing there way to join luffy. (do like them)
Luffy already defending him.
never showed Loki kindness.. for loki reaction to not mention kindness around him.... yet he proven he kind but hides it behind tough act.
Mostly due to the dumb superstion around Loki birth, and the prophecy which is bs imo. sounds like manipulation to who ever the traitor is..most likely the one who made prophecy to set loki up to fail.
As loki is basically used as scapegoat to be blamed for things out of his control, just for existing.
well there is the zoro parallel to loki
and usopp lie/trickster parallel to loki...not enough loki actually use real heavy hammer....where usopp used a fake..and usopp wanted to go to elbaf badly....
you know, luffy said 10, but if don't count luffy, then that makes jinbei the 9th correct? usopp hammer says 10, could be early foreshadowing in the same arc with oars, and ancient giants.... so making loki the 10th.
Post automatically merged:
yeah he want 10 man.
he not counting himself, when recheck this.
so jinbei the 9th
if loki can make himself smaller.. then yeah can see him as next and final. as reason above for luffy interest in loki.
Edit:seems some of the images are vanishing. so had edit it back in XD
Last edited:
In an ideal world:
10 Yamato
11 Vegapunk
12 Loki
Realistically:
10 None
11 None
12 None
Hint: MFMM Pattern
10th member is a female from an enemy group (Beast Pirates) that is connected to a relevant item reaching One Piece (Oden's journal)...
11th member is an inventor with a long range weapon (guns and machines) leading a local group (SSG) that has caused mischief (the taboo broadcast)...
12th member is a gentleman with an eye quirk (covered with bandage) that follows a certain code (warrior code) and literally looked down to Luffy upon meeting (a giant)...
10 Yamato
11 Vegapunk
12 Loki
Realistically:
10 None
11 None
12 None
Hint: MFMM Pattern
10th member is a female from an enemy group (Beast Pirates) that is connected to a relevant item reaching One Piece (Oden's journal)...
11th member is an inventor with a long range weapon (guns and machines) leading a local group (SSG) that has caused mischief (the taboo broadcast)...
12th member is a gentleman with an eye quirk (covered with bandage) that follows a certain code (warrior code) and literally looked down to Luffy upon meeting (a giant)...
Last edited: