Controversial Worst writing in the manga
- Thread starter Buusatan94
- Start date
Simply introduced too late, doesn´t fit in with the characterization of the Gorosei as slow and conservative actors, ¨every 3 years an island is entirely gotten rid of and no one notices¨ is just dumb, The entire rocks pirates could leak it any time they want, the WG is never shown as that competent again, arguably even undermines the plot point about racism against fishmen
I still think the gorosei should of been introduced an arc at a time
Saturn big bad of egghead
Ju Peter god of Agriculture could of been the big bad of Elbaf working along side Shamrock and the god Knights
So on and so forth
That way each gorosei would have a chance to get their back stories flushed out, how they started serving imu and how their powers work
Instead they all got introduced at one time, Saturn never even got a proper back story before being snuffed out
Egghead should of stayed a murder mystery with Saturn being an overarching villain manipulating York and not revealed until the end
Egghead went from potentially top 1 arc to barely top 5 because Oda skipped the murder mystery aspect and rushed the gorosei introduction
Saturn big bad of egghead
Ju Peter god of Agriculture could of been the big bad of Elbaf working along side Shamrock and the god Knights
So on and so forth
That way each gorosei would have a chance to get their back stories flushed out, how they started serving imu and how their powers work
Instead they all got introduced at one time, Saturn never even got a proper back story before being snuffed out
Egghead should of stayed a murder mystery with Saturn being an overarching villain manipulating York and not revealed until the end
Egghead went from potentially top 1 arc to barely top 5 because Oda skipped the murder mystery aspect and rushed the gorosei introduction
Birdcage, Ace knowing that he´s roger son for reasons not shown in the manga, no one facing any consequences for MF, doing an arc without any other SH, Fake out deaths in general but especially in Alabasta, W7, Wano, Loki being offered a position in the HK, Haki being intro´d so late, the new world not feeling different from the grandline in asthetic
I understand your point, but meh it just wouldn´t work
Post automatically merged:
I understand your point, but meh it just wouldn´t work
1. fishman island nosebleed incident.
2. wano arc 1 okay, arc 2 come on , arc 3 what the fuck. any fight does not even make sense , so many unncessary character introduction instead of giving strawhat chemistry which people look for in the manga.
big mom treatment was terrible ,emperor of the sea becomes punching bag by all onigashima , this is very embrassing and i lost my respect emperor thing.
kaido did not even kill one person during all arc 3 .
3. wano arc :)
4. wano arc :)
2. wano arc 1 okay, arc 2 come on , arc 3 what the fuck. any fight does not even make sense , so many unncessary character introduction instead of giving strawhat chemistry which people look for in the manga.
big mom treatment was terrible ,emperor of the sea becomes punching bag by all onigashima , this is very embrassing and i lost my respect emperor thing.
kaido did not even kill one person during all arc 3 .
3. wano arc :)
4. wano arc :)
I found the key plotline dumb in Enies Lobby.
Why would the professional assassins each have a key with them, why would they even tell the Straw Hats that they have them, that shit was all dumb.
I will never ever in my life call Enies Lobby the best One Piece arc like so many of you do. It has high peaks, but it has some dumb stuff in it.
Why would the professional assassins each have a key with them, why would they even tell the Straw Hats that they have them, that shit was all dumb.
I will never ever in my life call Enies Lobby the best One Piece arc like so many of you do. It has high peaks, but it has some dumb stuff in it.
I'd say Wano is the worst arc in all of One Piece with some truly terrible stuff such as Oden's flashback and how everyone sings his praises and worship him despite how unjustified it is, and Udon mini-arc, Onigashima stuff, the lack of characterization and development for Kaido and the Beast Pirates, etc...
Big Mom's handling and treatment during Wano is on a whole other class of shit writing, and also to a lesser extent for her daughters Smoothie and Compote. The treatment of other female characters such as Tashigi and Rebecca is terrible as well.
There are also some minor and very annoying or bland antagonists in the manga, such as Vander Decken in Fishman Island arc.
Big Mom's handling and treatment during Wano is on a whole other class of shit writing, and also to a lesser extent for her daughters Smoothie and Compote. The treatment of other female characters such as Tashigi and Rebecca is terrible as well.
There are also some minor and very annoying or bland antagonists in the manga, such as Vander Decken in Fishman Island arc.