[FNZ] Super Role Madness Round 12: Death Note
- Thread starter Rej
- Start date
- Status
N
My reads:
Light: Scum light tends to asking questions instead of pushing the lynch. He read me, Gambit as townie and neutral on TAC. He hasn't sus anyone. Maybe because it's day 1 and he's busy. It's too early to tell.
Fujishiro: He matches his town meta. Giving reads and using inactivity as reason to sus someone. I think he did that in ToL and that got Seraphoenix frustrated. Lends townie. I think he needs to fix this since people have different timezone.
Queen: Too early to tell. Like TAC and Light said she's also inactive as town. I think as scum she tends to be more helpful. In ToL she was talking about mechanic and she was scum. Her scum meta was also diplomatic in kakegurui game. I think I need her opinion on Gambit vs TAC, TAC vs Zara.
@Queen What's your thoughts on Gambit vs Zara and TAC vs Zara?
TAC: I think he tends to fluff a lot. He did that in naruto game too but in this game he asked to stop fluf post so that gives townie vibe.
Gambit: Kiwipom explained his meta well. Nitpick what TAC said and voted TAC after some users said TAC was more sus than Zara. So Gambit looked sus now. His town meta seems to be easily annoyed when someone sus him. I want to see his reaction on Kiwipom and TAC vote before deciding.
@Gambit Kiwipom and TAC voted you. I also sus you after seeing Kiwipom's explanation. Do you have reason to convince me that you're townie?
Melontonin: Asking Poison weird reason to vote me so seems good for now. Her scum meta tends to sus someone who has already been sus by many players like in naruto when many players sus Zara, she also sus Zara.
Flower, Ali, Trismegistus: No read. Hasn't posted once. Only 1 post I think.
Kiwipom: She claimed Miller and she gave good case on Gambit. Her frustration also looked genuine to Reborn so leans townie.
Cobra: He plays with his same meta. Saying he is town and hope he's scum. I think he's townie for now since hsi play would be different if he's first time scum and moreover he's new player.
Natalija: Asking not to claim so she looks townie to me. Maybe to get towncreed but I have never seen her done this as scum.
Reborn: I sus him first but he looks more active in scum hunting so he lends townie.
Poison: Felt weird voting me to gain reaction when she sus natalija/Zara. later she explained to get reaction from me who she has no read. She later also sus Yo Tan Wa/Light but didn't push the case. Need to see more of her.
Yo Tan Wa: He townread me and Poison before logging off and now still gave townread to me and Poison so that looks consistent with his read.
He also sus Gambit but later townread him and his explanation doesn't convince me but later put Gambit neutral based on his read on Kiwipom.
He also put Queen as his scum list and today I think his read on her is consistent.
Zara: I think he lends townie. Asking how to proceed with the game. Looks townie and he didn't like Queen got free pass for being inactive.
No scum read for now. Maybe Gambit. I found Yo Tan Wa weird. he put Reborn as sus yesterday and he didn't give his read on Reborn today. He also asked Trismegistus to give reads on Kiwi, Melon, Tac, Gambit n Zara but not Reborn.
@Yo Tan Wa Why didn't you give your read on Reborn? Why didn't you ask Trismegistus read on Reborn too?
Light: Scum light tends to asking questions instead of pushing the lynch. He read me, Gambit as townie and neutral on TAC. He hasn't sus anyone. Maybe because it's day 1 and he's busy. It's too early to tell.
Fujishiro: He matches his town meta. Giving reads and using inactivity as reason to sus someone. I think he did that in ToL and that got Seraphoenix frustrated. Lends townie. I think he needs to fix this since people have different timezone.
Queen: Too early to tell. Like TAC and Light said she's also inactive as town. I think as scum she tends to be more helpful. In ToL she was talking about mechanic and she was scum. Her scum meta was also diplomatic in kakegurui game. I think I need her opinion on Gambit vs TAC, TAC vs Zara.
@Queen What's your thoughts on Gambit vs Zara and TAC vs Zara?
TAC: I think he tends to fluff a lot. He did that in naruto game too but in this game he asked to stop fluf post so that gives townie vibe.
Gambit: Kiwipom explained his meta well. Nitpick what TAC said and voted TAC after some users said TAC was more sus than Zara. So Gambit looked sus now. His town meta seems to be easily annoyed when someone sus him. I want to see his reaction on Kiwipom and TAC vote before deciding.
@Gambit Kiwipom and TAC voted you. I also sus you after seeing Kiwipom's explanation. Do you have reason to convince me that you're townie?
Melontonin: Asking Poison weird reason to vote me so seems good for now. Her scum meta tends to sus someone who has already been sus by many players like in naruto when many players sus Zara, she also sus Zara.
Flower, Ali, Trismegistus: No read. Hasn't posted once. Only 1 post I think.
Kiwipom: She claimed Miller and she gave good case on Gambit. Her frustration also looked genuine to Reborn so leans townie.
Cobra: He plays with his same meta. Saying he is town and hope he's scum. I think he's townie for now since hsi play would be different if he's first time scum and moreover he's new player.
Natalija: Asking not to claim so she looks townie to me. Maybe to get towncreed but I have never seen her done this as scum.
Reborn: I sus him first but he looks more active in scum hunting so he lends townie.
Poison: Felt weird voting me to gain reaction when she sus natalija/Zara. later she explained to get reaction from me who she has no read. She later also sus Yo Tan Wa/Light but didn't push the case. Need to see more of her.
Yo Tan Wa: He townread me and Poison before logging off and now still gave townread to me and Poison so that looks consistent with his read.
He also sus Gambit but later townread him and his explanation doesn't convince me but later put Gambit neutral based on his read on Kiwipom.
He also put Queen as his scum list and today I think his read on her is consistent.
Zara: I think he lends townie. Asking how to proceed with the game. Looks townie and he didn't like Queen got free pass for being inactive.
No scum read for now. Maybe Gambit. I found Yo Tan Wa weird. he put Reborn as sus yesterday and he didn't give his read on Reborn today. He also asked Trismegistus to give reads on Kiwi, Melon, Tac, Gambit n Zara but not Reborn.
@Yo Tan Wa Why didn't you give your read on Reborn? Why didn't you ask Trismegistus read on Reborn too?
Z
Nat is really town on everyones list for absolutely no reason
a lot of yall are gonna be looking silly if she ends up being scum
i honestly dont understand how everyone in this game has a town read on Nat so easily. I dont think thereโs a single person whoโs given reads on her that didnโt say that she leans town
not saying nat has done anything scummy, cuz she hasnโt. But she certainly hasnโt done anything to get the entire roster of players thinking she leans town either
a lot of yall are gonna be looking silly if she ends up being scum
i honestly dont understand how everyone in this game has a town read on Nat so easily. I dont think thereโs a single person whoโs given reads on her that didnโt say that she leans town
not saying nat has done anything scummy, cuz she hasnโt. But she certainly hasnโt done anything to get the entire roster of players thinking she leans town either
I like how im sus in almost everyoneโs list
Nat is really town on everyones list for absolutely no reason
a lot of yall are gonna be looking silly if she ends up being scum
i honestly dont understand how everyone in this game has a town read on Nat so easily. I dont think thereโs a single person whoโs given reads on her that didnโt say that she leans town
not saying nat has done anything scummy, cuz she hasnโt. But she certainly hasnโt done anything to get the entire roster of players thinking she leans town either
a lot of yall are gonna be looking silly if she ends up being scum
i honestly dont understand how everyone in this game has a town read on Nat so easily. I dont think thereโs a single person whoโs given reads on her that didnโt say that she leans town
not saying nat has done anything scummy, cuz she hasnโt. But she certainly hasnโt done anything to get the entire roster of players thinking she leans town either
Maybe we need to start looking at the people who agreed with this. I mean Iโm not so sure about Nat tbh, she didnโt have any red flags but she hasnโt contributed in any ways that makes me town clear her. So I feel like the people (especially saying sheโs clear for typing donโt claim in big fonts) could just be sheeping and giving fluff reads
Iโll look into this in the morning
Now, onto your reads. This post didn't feel like your usual you, Neutral.
I want more on Tac from you.
You want to see Gambit reactn and you tag him, ๐คฆโโ๏ธ.
And you are deducing his meta from one Game?
Melontonin point is good. She sus already sussed people as scum.
I read Cobra post saying he has played 6 Games, now. I am still under Dozen, so that shouldn't be excuse anymore @Cobra. You should try to be invested in the game, and improve your gameplay, if you want to learn.
Anyway Neutral, his play is different, Reborn pointed out. He is content with his role this time, maybe since he is not Vanilla anymore.
And also you shouldn't read people based on reads consistency D1. I gave my Rainbow reads both for reactions and based on instincts, in starting hours of Game when everyone mostly fluffed. You are looking for consistency in em?
But onto you, You gave reads on me as good and consistent, then call me weird?
I want more on Tac from you.
You want to see Gambit reactn and you tag him, ๐คฆโโ๏ธ.
And you are deducing his meta from one Game?
Melontonin point is good. She sus already sussed people as scum.
I read Cobra post saying he has played 6 Games, now. I am still under Dozen, so that shouldn't be excuse anymore @Cobra. You should try to be invested in the game, and improve your gameplay, if you want to learn.
Anyway Neutral, his play is different, Reborn pointed out. He is content with his role this time, maybe since he is not Vanilla anymore.
And also you shouldn't read people based on reads consistency D1. I gave my Rainbow reads both for reactions and based on instincts, in starting hours of Game when everyone mostly fluffed. You are looking for consistency in em?
But onto you, You gave reads on me as good and consistent, then call me weird?
N
I based my reads on previous game/meta. Is there something wrong with that?
I think that's because he put Reborn on your sus list yesterday but you didn't give your read on Reborn today.
You also didn't ask Trismegistus read on Reborn.
I want to see Gambit's react because he overreact when I and some players sus him. I want to see if his reaction similar to last game or not.
Yeah you make good point about Cobra but I still want to know your read on Reborn.
Oh yeah Rayan: No reads for now. Scum Rayan tends to be diplomatic. Same with Queen. Need to see more of them.
This is a good point. I haven't tried this. I gave my reads based on interaction between players. That's my play style.
I think that's because he put Reborn on your sus list yesterday but you didn't give your read on Reborn today.
You also didn't ask Trismegistus read on Reborn.
Post automatically merged:
I want to see Gambit's react because he overreact when I and some players sus him. I want to see if his reaction similar to last game or not.
Yeah you make good point about Cobra but I still want to know your read on Reborn.
Post automatically merged:
Oh yeah Rayan: No reads for now. Scum Rayan tends to be diplomatic. Same with Queen. Need to see more of them.
Post automatically merged:
This is a good point. I haven't tried this. I gave my reads based on interaction between players. That's my play style.
Last edited by a moderator:
Did you overlook my post, i gave my opinion and read on Reborn to a reply to his, and quoted it above.
Nah that i did, but because, it was based on hunch last Night and current ones are after reading through the posts and reactions from people on my reads. So even tho in this case mine are consistent, they easily couldn't have been. The logic to see Inconsistentency in there is bad.
Second, i am not a player to remain consistent with my reads, much less with something i stated first 2 hours of the Game after reading fluff posts. Last game, I sussed Jew n Melon D1 at first, changed to Rayan, Sera n Gambit after reading through the posts. D2, it was Rayan n Gambit, plus Beta n Jew. D3 it was Gambit, D4 it was Melon again.
And should we look into consistency in your reads? You made a list of sus if you die, and now you are ignoring my posts and sussing me? Inconsistent
And you will get his genuine reaction nw? that you have made your intentions known and tagged him?
Did you really wanted his reaction, or wanted to appear so?
Nah that i did, but because, it was based on hunch last Night and current ones are after reading through the posts and reactions from people on my reads. So even tho in this case mine are consistent, they easily couldn't have been. The logic to see Inconsistentency in there is bad.
Second, i am not a player to remain consistent with my reads, much less with something i stated first 2 hours of the Game after reading fluff posts. Last game, I sussed Jew n Melon D1 at first, changed to Rayan, Sera n Gambit after reading through the posts. D2, it was Rayan n Gambit, plus Beta n Jew. D3 it was Gambit, D4 it was Melon again.
And should we look into consistency in your reads? You made a list of sus if you die, and now you are ignoring my posts and sussing me? Inconsistent
And you will get his genuine reaction nw? that you have made your intentions known and tagged him?
Did you really wanted his reaction, or wanted to appear so?
N
Did you overlook my post, i gave my opinion and read on Reborn to a reply to his, and quoted it above.
Nah that i did, but because, it was based on hunch last Night and current ones are after reading through the posts and reactions from people on my reads. So even tho in this case mine are consistent, they easily couldn't have been. The logic to see Inconsistentency in there is bad.
Second, i am not a player to remain consistent with my reads, much less with something i stated first 2 hours of the Game after reading fluff posts. Last game, I sussed Jew n Melon D1 at first, changed to Rayan, Sera n Gambit after reading through the posts. D2, it was Rayan n Gambit, plus Beta n Jew. D3 it was Gambit, D4 it was Melon again.
And should we look into consistency in your reads? You made a list of sus if you die, and now you are ignoring my posts and sussing me? Inconsistent
And you will get his genuine reaction nw? that you have made your intentions known and tagged him?
Did you really wanted his reaction, or wanted to appear so?
Nah that i did, but because, it was based on hunch last Night and current ones are after reading through the posts and reactions from people on my reads. So even tho in this case mine are consistent, they easily couldn't have been. The logic to see Inconsistentency in there is bad.
Second, i am not a player to remain consistent with my reads, much less with something i stated first 2 hours of the Game after reading fluff posts. Last game, I sussed Jew n Melon D1 at first, changed to Rayan, Sera n Gambit after reading through the posts. D2, it was Rayan n Gambit, plus Beta n Jew. D3 it was Gambit, D4 it was Melon again.
And should we look into consistency in your reads? You made a list of sus if you die, and now you are ignoring my posts and sussing me? Inconsistent
And you will get his genuine reaction nw? that you have made your intentions known and tagged him?
Did you really wanted his reaction, or wanted to appear so?
When I died N1 and I was strong town read by some players they were mafia let's call it spite sus
I want to see Gambit's reaction from TAC and Kiwipom vote on Gambit.
Also could you quote me your read on Reborn?
N
N
I seriously didn't see your read on Reborn on this post.
In this post you gave your read on Poison, Gambit, Fujishiro and me
And in this post you gave your read on Kiwipom, Queen, Rayan, Melontonin, Natalija.
You also didn't plan to give your read Light, Zara and TAC
You also have no read on Tris, Ali, Cobra, Flower since they're inactive
No read on Reborn. Maybe you can bold the part about your read on Reborn.
In this post you gave your read on Poison, Gambit, Fujishiro and me
And in this post you gave your read on Kiwipom, Queen, Rayan, Melontonin, Natalija.
You also didn't plan to give your read Light, Zara and TAC
You also have no read on Tris, Ali, Cobra, Flower since they're inactive
No read on Reborn. Maybe you can bold the part about your read on Reborn.
Melotonin : her whole posts didn't have much in it : the only post that was vaguely useful was this one :
Except that her 20 posts here have barely nothing valuable. Not a good look.
Light : except the beginning of the games he made only 4 posts and those ones were to defend himself againts Fuji fluffing charge.
So we don't have much to judge him.
Queen : hadn't said anything except the beginning of the game, so we cannot judge her.
Same for Flower.
Same for Ali.
Trismegistus : not a lot of posts but 1 that might be interesting :
This one, she barely caught up with the thread but she was already answering people question and gave the reads she had. Good look in my book.
Now we are getting into players that talked much more :
Yo Tan Wa : he begins his game by a color list but he became serious after that so no problem for me.
After he caugh up to the thread he gave his reads : good points : his read of NW is good for me, he saw something special and called it and asked NW to explain. The rest was okayish but to be fair we don't have a lot of material.
Reborn not ending the early fluff is not really a bad point for him, it's not his job and he had maybe other things to do. And this is a 48h day phase so we can have 1h of early fluff.
Then you came up with your second full reads.
I agree that usual play or usual things are easy way sometimes to get yourself out of suss and lurk but here i think TAC and Light comments about Queen were genuine. I don't think this is some buddying or protecting of Queen it would be too obvious. She is not town cleared at all but her early inactivity is not suss for now.
After that you kept focusing on NW, and I think it's okay you had some doubts about his gameplay so it's fair to focus on him.
The moment you put some votes even weird ones people have rights to call you out for them.
Good to know ^^. With that claim I think you can understand why people can call you out for inconsistencies.
All in all seems pretty town to me. Especially his behaviour with Neutral.
Except that her 20 posts here have barely nothing valuable. Not a good look.
Light : except the beginning of the games he made only 4 posts and those ones were to defend himself againts Fuji fluffing charge.
So we don't have much to judge him.
Queen : hadn't said anything except the beginning of the game, so we cannot judge her.
Same for Flower.
Same for Ali.
Trismegistus : not a lot of posts but 1 that might be interesting :
This one, she barely caught up with the thread but she was already answering people question and gave the reads she had. Good look in my book.
Now we are getting into players that talked much more :
Yo Tan Wa : he begins his game by a color list but he became serious after that so no problem for me.
After he caugh up to the thread he gave his reads : good points : his read of NW is good for me, he saw something special and called it and asked NW to explain. The rest was okayish but to be fair we don't have a lot of material.
Reborn not ending the early fluff is not really a bad point for him, it's not his job and he had maybe other things to do. And this is a 48h day phase so we can have 1h of early fluff.
Then you came up with your second full reads.
I agree that usual play or usual things are easy way sometimes to get yourself out of suss and lurk but here i think TAC and Light comments about Queen were genuine. I don't think this is some buddying or protecting of Queen it would be too obvious. She is not town cleared at all but her early inactivity is not suss for now.
After that you kept focusing on NW, and I think it's okay you had some doubts about his gameplay so it's fair to focus on him.
The moment you put some votes even weird ones people have rights to call you out for them.
Good to know ^^. With that claim I think you can understand why people can call you out for inconsistencies.
All in all seems pretty town to me. Especially his behaviour with Neutral.
Yuelyn
๐๐๐พ๐๐๐๐ ๐ ๐ถ๐พ๐ ๐ฎ๐๐๐๐ฝ๐ ๐น๐๐๐๐๐
โ
Poison feeling like you are trying to pocket her is genuine, imo, especially if she susses you in the first place. But you gave her a town read yesterday and that was before she even sussed you if I remember correctly. I don't know what changed since then since I think you are town from judging from your reads.
Kiwi-Personally, I think it was a good thing that she claimed already in her second post, so the cop won't waste an investigation on her. Claiming that she is a Miller could be also a set up from her. But since nobody claimed to be a Miller, I believe that she is one. Though as others said she still could be scum but for me, she is town for now since.
Mel-I don't really have anything on her yet but judging from gut feeling she would be neutral for now.
TAC- I've got some problems with him lol. So, I didn't really like that he just jumped on Zara because he asked a genuine question about the setup. But later he said that his pushing was for reaction and some other stuff. So I give him that.
He also said that he likes betraying people but he is good. Like why would you say that? lol He mentioned multiple times that he plays always scummy and that is normal for him. I'm not really convinced by this, I have to say. I only played one game with him before and he was killed D1 but from judging that short experience, I think he MIGHT be scum but I'm not entirely sure yet. Since in that game he was co-operative/helpful etc. and he flipped scum. So this might be the case this time too since he has been answering questions etc
Gambit- Him claiming L, I didn't make much out of it. I just took it as a joke. But I agree with him that L is probably the most important role in this game though. But I do think he might be scum too. Maybe an indie or something but for sure not in the same team as TAC.
Zara- He said early on that he wanted to play the game but I found nothing wrong with it. He has been waiting to play for a while now, so that was expected that he will be hyped. About the Zara/TAC stuff, he did overreact a little bit but this happened in the last game too and flipped town. I think he is town.
Light- I didn't really see anything from him. He just came and said some stuff about Queen's meta and to stop the fluff posts. Other then this I don't think he said anything else.
Bonus for NW: Reborn- I just looked at his posts from today since yesterday he said he was drunk so yeah, I didn't bother make sense of those. I think he is just being himself. Asking question/scum hunting and stuff. So I don't think he is scum.
His vote on you is something I didn't really get since you mentioned that you are trying to play differently this game. (might have been Gambit who said that...) But I think you are town though. If you are scum, I'm guessing you would be more pushing like in that turbo game.
So, my sus list not in order:
TAC
Gambit
Poison
@Yo Tan Wa
Kiwi-Personally, I think it was a good thing that she claimed already in her second post, so the cop won't waste an investigation on her. Claiming that she is a Miller could be also a set up from her. But since nobody claimed to be a Miller, I believe that she is one. Though as others said she still could be scum but for me, she is town for now since.
Mel-I don't really have anything on her yet but judging from gut feeling she would be neutral for now.
TAC- I've got some problems with him lol. So, I didn't really like that he just jumped on Zara because he asked a genuine question about the setup. But later he said that his pushing was for reaction and some other stuff. So I give him that.
He also said that he likes betraying people but he is good. Like why would you say that? lol He mentioned multiple times that he plays always scummy and that is normal for him. I'm not really convinced by this, I have to say. I only played one game with him before and he was killed D1 but from judging that short experience, I think he MIGHT be scum but I'm not entirely sure yet. Since in that game he was co-operative/helpful etc. and he flipped scum. So this might be the case this time too since he has been answering questions etc
Gambit- Him claiming L, I didn't make much out of it. I just took it as a joke. But I agree with him that L is probably the most important role in this game though. But I do think he might be scum too. Maybe an indie or something but for sure not in the same team as TAC.
Zara- He said early on that he wanted to play the game but I found nothing wrong with it. He has been waiting to play for a while now, so that was expected that he will be hyped. About the Zara/TAC stuff, he did overreact a little bit but this happened in the last game too and flipped town. I think he is town.
Light- I didn't really see anything from him. He just came and said some stuff about Queen's meta and to stop the fluff posts. Other then this I don't think he said anything else.
Bonus for NW: Reborn- I just looked at his posts from today since yesterday he said he was drunk so yeah, I didn't bother make sense of those. I think he is just being himself. Asking question/scum hunting and stuff. So I don't think he is scum.
His vote on you is something I didn't really get since you mentioned that you are trying to play differently this game. (might have been Gambit who said that...) But I think you are town though. If you are scum, I'm guessing you would be more pushing like in that turbo game.
So, my sus list not in order:
TAC
Gambit
Poison
Post automatically merged:
@Yo Tan Wa
Neutral watcher : the fact that he was trying to play seriously since the beginning can be a good thing but I don't want to put too much thought into that. Early fluff is not bad at all and early seriousness is not a town credibity too.
This was obviously a joke, and you were a bit too defensive.
Once again I don't think the early fluff and the one who called it out can give us town read.
Now your first reads :
I think Melon post was weird I don't think this post and this is her only post that meant something cleared her.
TAC Light and Zara saying stop to fluff is not a holy thing.
Why do you think Reborn is weird ?
I don't like how you portrayed yourself has an easy or weak target...
and you saying that you have weak powers is not good too.
Don't a fan of this first read.
then again the victim card : why do you think you will die tonight ?
Don't think so. If you are a real townie go back to you old meta please.
Again...
Now your full read : nothing bad from those read it is still the beginning of the game so okay to have average reads and don't be sure.
The point that is interesting is about Poison. Her first vote againts you was clearly a joke. But I need to check Poison posts too.
All in all something is a bit off here.
This was obviously a joke, and you were a bit too defensive.
Once again I don't think the early fluff and the one who called it out can give us town read.
Now your first reads :
I think Melon post was weird I don't think this post and this is her only post that meant something cleared her.
TAC Light and Zara saying stop to fluff is not a holy thing.
Why do you think Reborn is weird ?
I don't like how you portrayed yourself has an easy or weak target...
and you saying that you have weak powers is not good too.
Don't a fan of this first read.
then again the victim card : why do you think you will die tonight ?
If I die tonight scum must be
Melontonin
Rayan
TAC
Queen
Light
Flower
Melontonin
Rayan
TAC
Queen
Light
Flower
Again...
Now your full read : nothing bad from those read it is still the beginning of the game so okay to have average reads and don't be sure.
The point that is interesting is about Poison. Her first vote againts you was clearly a joke. But I need to check Poison posts too.
All in all something is a bit off here.
- Status