Speculations Who is the slayer of Xebec?

Who killed Rocks?

  • Garp

  • Roger

  • Garling

  • Gorosei

  • Imu

  • Backstabber among Rocks Pirates

  • Someone else


Results are only viewable after voting.
#24
Imu/Garling/Gorosei/HKs

Roger beat him though.
In manga credit for defeating Xebec goes to Garp ( with hidden info for public that he had to ally with Roger to accomplish that ) . Unless I forgot some manga scan or there exist other source ( vivre card or something ) its never even hinted Roger was one that beat Xebec.

Where is scan that slightly hints Roger was one that beat Xebec ?
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
#25
God Valley flashback is perfect situation to reveal IMU.

I am gonna go with wild take ....

Garp and Roger tag teamed Xebec and were the reason why Rocks pirates scattered.

But they didn't beat Xebec.

It was IMU who then wiped out the entire island.

Perhaps this incident became catalyst for Roger to aspire to get to last island and learn everything.
 
#26
God Valley flashback is perfect situation to reveal IMU.

I am gonna go with wild take ....

Garp and Roger tag teamed Xebec and were the reason why Rocks pirates scattered.

But they didn't beat Xebec.

It was IMU who then wiped out the entire island.

Perhaps this incident became catalyst for Roger to aspire to get to last island and learn everything.
I agree with this completely. Having him go down to Imu makes a lot of sense especially given that Imu has a bounty poster of his son in his private room and Teach is being built up to kill Imu soon
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
#27
I agree with this completely. Having him go down to Imu makes a lot of sense especially given that Imu has a bounty poster of his son in his private room and Teach is being built up to kill Imu soon
There is one more thing - Garp and Roger beating Xebec and then IMU killing a defeated Xebec doesn't really make sense.

Oda would like to hype IMU.

And, what else than beating Xebec - someone even Garp and Roger struggled to take down.
 
#32
With all the hype around Xebec and the supposed W pending for Roger at GV.
What if all these build up is Oda trying to gassed Garling instead..
:risitears:

He is the only relevant old guy in the show at the moment that is still save for later.

But for real.
I'm convinced Imu is 100% involved.
Controlling or giving power to Garling and finishing off Xebec could be one of the possibility.
Garp doesn't like to talk about his heroic GV achievement, some say because he needs to protect CD which he dispise, or he was teaming up with Roger etc
But overall he isn't satisfied with that battle, which shows there might by fishy thing going on.

Roger likely the one to beat him, but till the end of the day until we saw GV in detail, i won't believe it's a pure 1v1 match.
Luffy have a rare pure 1v1 win, we probably won't 1v1 Imu or EoS BB either, somebody will be involve like that's always the case.
Same goes for Roger beating Rocks
 
#33
With all the hype around Xebec and the supposed W pending for Roger at GV.
What if all these build up is Oda trying to gassed Garling instead..
:risitears:

He is the only relevant old guy in the show at the moment that is still save for later.

But for real.
I'm convinced Imu is 100% involved.
Controlling or giving power to Garling and finishing off Xebec could be one of the possibility.
Garp doesn't like to talk about his heroic GV achievement, some say because he needs to protect CD which he dispise, or he was teaming up with Roger etc
But overall he isn't satisfied with that battle, which shows there might by fishy thing going on.

Roger likely the one to beat him, but till the end of the day until we saw GV in detail, i won't believe it's a pure 1v1 match.
Luffy have a rare pure 1v1 win, we probably won't 1v1 Imu or EoS BB either, somebody will be involve like that's always the case.
Same goes for Roger beating Rocks
Warling :steef:
 
#34
With all the hype around Xebec and the supposed W pending for Roger at GV.
What if all these build up is Oda trying to gassed Garling instead..
:risitears:

He is the only relevant old guy in the show at the moment that is still save for later.

But for real.
I'm convinced Imu is 100% involved.
Controlling or giving power to Garling and finishing off Xebec could be one of the possibility.
Garp doesn't like to talk about his heroic GV achievement, some say because he needs to protect CD which he dispise, or he was teaming up with Roger etc
But overall he isn't satisfied with that battle, which shows there might by fishy thing going on.

Roger likely the one to beat him, but till the end of the day until we saw GV in detail, i won't believe it's a pure 1v1 match.
Luffy have a rare pure 1v1 win, we probably won't 1v1 Imu or EoS BB either, somebody will be involve like that's always the case.
Same goes for Roger beating Rocks
nah

i know for a fact that this ain't gonna happen. Cause @Nik-san has voted for garling. So it's automatically not gonna happen :hihihi:



Garling most likely is gonna fight and scar WB so the WB comment to shank comes full circle.
 
#37
As we draw closer to the fateful day in God Valley, where Rocks D Xebec met his end, it is time to guess who gets to decorate himself with the badge of "killer of Rocks".
We know that many were present at the hunger games happening in God Valley where Pirates and Marines united to crush Rocks Pirates.
However, among all the Rocks Pirates, only Rocks himself died that day, it seems...

Who killed him?

On the opposing side, we had Roger Pirates, Garp's unit, Holy Knights and at least one Elder.
Imu is also worth considering due to remote takeover of bearer of mark of Abyss.

Top candidates that can be considered as the killer of Xebec are:

1 - Monkey D Garp
2 - Gol D Roger
3 - Figarland Garling
4 - Elder Saturn
5 - remote Imu
6 - betrayer among Rocks Pirates
It’s pre-conceptual Zoro or 5 year old Mihawk
 
#40
Imu killed him.
Though I can see he was betrayed by his crewmate (can be 1 or many) at a very crucial juncture during his 2 vs 1 battle against garp and Roger that turned the tide for the duo to take him down with joint haki attack. But that didn't kill him.

Everyone leaves. Imu descends from heaven to God valley. Has a final conversation with a battered, broken rocks. Shows him his/her face(silhouette to us still). Rocks smiles. Imu kills him and nukes God Valley. Leaves.
 
Top