Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1159 Spoilers Discussion
- Thread starter RayanOO
- Start date
- Tags goon valley gooner piece is real l sama xebec was the good guy
- Status
Yes it's "wiped out"
Depending on what translation you read, it says Roger destroyed a country or it's army.
Either way it's still collective punishment unless you want to argue All 100k of army members was making fun of Roger's crew.
It's literally destroying the country because you destabilize it.
No. Oda is portraying Xebec as Hero here and that his cause is a righteous one
When Oda showed Rocks Pirates looting it was shown to be shady organization.
So it's the same here
Xebec is attacking the towns because the people in the towns are the bad people. Not vice versa
Depending on what translation you read, it says Roger destroyed a country or it's army.
Either way it's still collective punishment unless you want to argue All 100k of army members was making fun of Roger's crew.
It's literally destroying the country because you destabilize it.
No. Oda is portraying Xebec as Hero here and that his cause is a righteous one
When Oda showed Rocks Pirates looting it was shown to be shady organization.
So it's the same here
Xebec is attacking the towns because the people in the towns are the bad people. Not vice versa
Rogers crew is literally there and took treasure (which is how Shanks was found). He could have been gifted it years later. Also a myriad of pirates were there, he could have plundered it from them later on.
[automerge]1756914967[/automerge]
Im expecting a little longer than that but due to the sheer number of characters and plot reasons.
We need to see:
- How Shanks was saved by Dragon
- What happens to Teach after GV (likely Whitebeards first "son" so to speak)
- Potentially what happens to many Rocks pirates after the event
- How Rocks dies and why Roger and Garp felt the need to stop him
- What Garling wanted in GV and why Saturn was there (probably connected)
And Im sure Oda will draw a few significant clashes but yeah not straight up fights.
Im thinking more than 2 but less than 4 to do all of this.
[automerge]1756914967[/automerge]
Im expecting a little longer than that but due to the sheer number of characters and plot reasons.
We need to see:
- How Shanks was saved by Dragon
- What happens to Teach after GV (likely Whitebeards first "son" so to speak)
- Potentially what happens to many Rocks pirates after the event
- How Rocks dies and why Roger and Garp felt the need to stop him
- What Garling wanted in GV and why Saturn was there (probably connected)
And Im sure Oda will draw a few significant clashes but yeah not straight up fights.
Im thinking more than 2 but less than 4 to do all of this.
Last edited:
Sure but for him to think about the scar he got from Roger by simply seeing his apprentice, it would be like Luffy thinking of the scar he got from Akainu by simply seeing Kizaru or Kuzan.
It's not impossible but I doubt it. Though you make a good point about him not having a scar in Oden's flashback, maybe it's just Oda forgetting about Garling scarring him. Who knows.
It's not impossible but I doubt it. Though you make a good point about him not having a scar in Oden's flashback, maybe it's just Oda forgetting about Garling scarring him. Who knows.
- Status