Powers & Abilities Roger isn’t a swordsman

[LolonoisZolo]

He literally did

No, it is Zoro punching the air with his right hand while simultaniously rotating.

 

[Terra Arseid7]

I'm saying it's not a cut, it's a bullet like type of penetration attack.. We see the visual impact effect..

Clown as always

Spoiler

Same visual effects as Roger here

 

[Rootbeer]

No that happened the panel before

it’s Zoro launching an air slash

Getting away from the main point.. How is Roger's attack cutting, if anything it's piercing through like a thrust.. Roger's Sword fighting style has been blunt damage.. I'm claiming it's akin to bullets..

u low iq or what? those are to show roger did multiple slashes

It shows Roger doing multiple Homeruns with black lightning haki bullets.. Slashes have never been Roger's style..

He literally did

This helps my argument, it's like clear lance, completely different visual impact effect..

Rootbeer passes time by trolling lol

I'm not trolling, since i came back i reflected on this for a long time..

Clown as always

You just showed a bunch of different things.. I'm saying Roger's attack was blunt damage like Garp beside him..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

How is Roger's attack cutting, if anything it's piercing through like a thrust.. Roger's Sword fighting style has been blunt damage.

It cuts through Xebec’s leg. It cuts him to pieces. That’s how it’s a cutting attack

 

[mly90]

It's over and none of these swordsmen haki could forge a kokuto not a single one of them

 

[Rootbeer]

It cuts through Xebec’s leg. It cuts him to pieces. That’s how it’s a cutting attack

Yeah but that's speculation merely based on him holding a Sword.. Also why would Roger do a long range attack when he's already in close range like Garp?.. Because Roger doesn't cut people with his Blade..

 

[Terra Arseid7]

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Yeah but that's speculation merely based on him holding a Sword.. Also why would Roger do a long range attack when he's already in close range like Garp?.. Because Roger doesn't cut people with his Blade..

Do you not see Rocks’ leg falling to pieces? You posted the panel yourself. In the panel you posted, you don’t see anything happening to Rocks’ leg?

Also are you now claiming king range attacks can’t cut?

 

[Rootbeer]

Do you not see Rocks’ leg falling to pieces? You posted the panel yourself. In the panel you posted, you don’t see anything happening to Rocks’ leg?

Also are you now claiming king range attacks can’t cut?

Yes, it's poorly represented..

Do you realize that it's Black on Black crime, Roger's attack is Black lightning versus Black whatever Immortal body, it's hard to depict with Black and White.. Are Garp's punches, discs.. No..

Wasn't Roger executing a Range attack in close quarter combat distance or not?..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Yes, it's poorly represented..

Do you realize that it's Black on Black crime, Roger's attack is Black lightning versus Black whatever Immortal body, it's hard to depict with Black and White.. Are Garp's punches, discs.. No..

Wasn't Roger executing a Range attack in close quarter combat distance or not?..

I posted a panel of Zoro “executing range attack in close quarter combat” why does this matter

so what exactly is happening to Rocks’ right leg here?

 

[Rootbeer]

I posted a panel of Zoro “executing range attack in close quarter combat” why does this matter

so what exactly is happening to Rocks’ right leg here?

I mean close quarter to physically strike with said Sword.. Zoro was close, but not close enough to not use a Range attack, that's my point..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

I mean close quarter to physically strike with said Sword.. Zoro was close, but not close enough to not use a Range attack, that's my point..

You mean Roger isn’t a swordsman because he chose to do a long range attack when he could have chosen a short range one?

you mean like this

 

[Rootbeer]

You mean Roger isn’t a swordsman because he chose to do a long range attack when he could have chosen a short range one?

you mean like this

Did Zoro not physically strike Hacchi with his Blades there though?..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Did Zoro not physically strike Hacchi with his Blades there though?..

Yeah. Is this not a long range attack?

I mean Roger’s sword attack can physically hit Rocks can’t it?

 

[Terra Arseid7]

This idiot is arbitrarily inventing new characteristics of what it is to be or not to be a swordsman. Although in the manga in more than 25 years nothing remotely close has ever been mentioned or that gave any indication of it xD

 

[Rootbeer]

Yeah. Is this not a long range attack?

I mean Roger’s sword attack can physically hit Rocks can’t it?

It's a long range attack that was performed as a close quarter combat attack like Onigiri..

Whereas Roger did a long range attack in close range without making contact with his blade..

Why get in Someone's face and do an aerial attack instead of striking them directly..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

It's a long range attack that was performed as a close quarter combat attack like Onigiri..

Whereas Roger did a long range attack in close range without making contact with his blade..

Why get in Someone's face and do an aerial attack instead of striking them directly..

Because Roger wasn’t actually close enough for his sword to hit him

again, are you implying that Roger’s swords physically cannot cut Rocks?

 

[Halyup]

This idiot is arbitrarily inventing new characteristics of what it is to be or not to be a swordsman. Although in the manga in more than 25 years nothing remotely close has ever been mentioned or that gave any indication of it xD

Its rootbeeer thats his motto

 

[comrade]

No way we reached a level of cope and delusion where people argue that this aren't slashes/cuts but thrusts/blunt tears/a mimicking bullets.

 

[Rootbeer]

Because Roger wasn’t actually close enough for his sword to hit him

again, are you implying that Roger’s swords physically cannot cut Rocks?

He was right there beside Garp..

I'm implying that Roger has a rule to not cut and do only blunt damage.. And i would even claim that it's a rule he has for his whole crew that's why Rayleigh's attack against Sommers was also Blunt Damage..

No way we reached a level of cope and delusion where people argue that this aren't slashes/cuts but thrusts/blunt tears/a mimicking bullets.

Yes that's my speculation, they are Blunt piercing attacks..