Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1185 Spoilers Discussion

[D. Plant]

God of fog soon

The fog surrounds the kingdom... does it mean Thriller Bark being part of Esperia actually real?

 

[D. Plant]

I am pretty sure this break is for live action.

When Oda returns to Japan

 

[Franz]

I am pretty sure this break is for live action.

Why ?

 

[Franz]

When Oda returns to Japan

?????

The fog surrounds the kingdom... does it mean Thriller Bark being part of Esperia actually real?

What are you talking about?

 

[D. Plant]

?????



What are you talking about?

There were a theory saying Thriller Bark is part of Esperia because Brook buried his crewmates in their homeland.

 

[Julius]

Coby’s a dumb character, but can we stop pretending like Oda isn’t obviously gonna bullshit him into becoming a top tier at EoS lol? He already has ACoC

Wrong Tweet bruh, it wasn't supposed to be this Koby shit lol

It was about Oda, break weeks and the poorly timed flashback

 

[DisasterDrew]

There were a theory saying Thriller Bark is part of Esperia because Brook buried his crewmates in their homeland.

Doesn't make much sense though, plus people tend to mix all kinds of stuff into convoluted theories.

Rumbar pirates hailed from the West Blue, but it hasn't been linked to much less confirmed that their homeland is Esperia. Tbh it doesn'teven look similar to what we've seen of Esperia.
Brook remarks that he's glad his crew could be buried at Thriller Bark since Thriller Bark is also an island that came from their homeland West Blue sea.

Also, Thriller Bark is surrounded by fog because it's located in the Florian Triangle on the Grand Line, that's it.
The easier explanation is that Moriah located his 'moving island-ship' inside an already foggy sea (Florian Triangle) to ambush ships easily.

 

[D. Plant]

Doesn't make much sense though, plus people tend to mix all kinds of stuff into convoluted theories.

Rumbar pirates hailed from the West Blue, but it hasn't been linked to much less confirmed that their homeland is Esperia. Tbh it doesn'teven look similar to what we've seen of Esperia.
Brook remarks that he's glad his crew could be buried at Thriller Bark since Thriller Bark is also an island that came from their homeland West Blue sea.

Also, Thriller Bark is surrounded by fog because it's located in the Florian Triangle on the Grand Line, that's it.
The easier explanation is that Moriah located his 'moving island-ship' inside an already foggy sea (Florian Triangle) to ambush ships easily.

I'm not sure how much of it being part of Esperia is true and I don't know if the translation is correct or not. Personally I feel like it's most likely not true due to many circumstances like what you said.

 

[Franz]

There were a theory saying Thriller Bark is part of Esperia because Brook buried his crewmates in their homeland.

He talked about how, since Thriller Bark is an island native to the West Blue, and since everyone was born in that sea, it's as if they were buried in the West Blue or in native soil.

I also doubt that Yooki and the others came from Esperia, or they would have already appeared.

But the fog is typical of the Florian Triangle, not Thriller Bark.

 

[PuckTheGreat]

Oda’s gotta to be taking the piss with this flashback 😭. Gunko is basically a non-factor until Ragnir decides to melt that frggin ice block so this shit could’ve been added after the climax or something for fcksakes. Another country getting fck’d over by Imu & characters getting Domi Reversi’d is honestly whatever at this point. Gunko killed her father? Cry me a river
Oda’s gotta be stalling for some nonsense chapter count of sumin mchew. I like Brook but gaddem.

 

[D. Plant]

He talked about how, since Thriller Bark is an island native to the West Blue, and since everyone was born in that sea, it's as if they were buried in the West Blue or in native soil.

I also doubt that Yooki and the others came from Esperia, or they would have already appeared.

But the fog is typical of the Florian Triangle, not Thriller Bark.

I don't know bro, I am just riding the hype train. If it's true then we got some lore progress, if it's nothing then it's fine for me.
I don't know Japanese language, so I don't know if the translation if correct in TCB scans. Here is the raw, you can give it a go to translate it. Maybe you will find something.

 

[D. Plant]

He talked about how, since Thriller Bark is an island native to the West Blue, and since everyone was born in that sea, it's as if they were buried in the West Blue or in native soil.

I also doubt that Yooki and the others came from Esperia, or they would have already appeared.

But the fog is typical of the Florian Triangle, not Thriller Bark.

I just read it you post, yea maybe you are got it right and it's as close to what my understanding is.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

Many things we already saw in the past:

-Royal romance like Kyros and Scarlett

-Island with bad economy like Water Seven before the Sea Train

-Brook poor but now with nobles. Similar to the Ace/Luffy/Sabo flashback

-Celestial Tribute not paid like Lulusia

Its all very repetitive in this flashback

 

[Buusatan94]

Many things we already saw in the past:

-Royal romance like Kyros and Scarlett

-Island with bad economy like Water Seven before the Sea Train

-Brook poor but now with nobles. Similar to the Ace/Luffy/Sabo flashback

-Celestial Tribute not paid like Lulusia

Its all very repetitive in this flashback

Oda just keeps recycling things over and over again.

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

The reason i feel Brook’s flashback is even there because Oda needs justification for Luffy to fight against Imu and make it personal .

At some point Luffy will hear this from Ussop and other crew about tragedy of his kingdom and Imus version will add up .

Loki vs Imu fight unfortunately will be off paneled , Loki is gonna lose .

 

[Senfret]

I feel bad for Reuben, he lost everything but at least he fought back... I'm glad he's not a Harald/Oden character

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

To be fair Esperia might be connected to Ancient Kingdom if it was erased silently.

Candle definitely was spying on the Esperia kingdom . Why exactly Leuvan is highly guarded and what happened to his father ?

 

[Veku]

Remember, Oda wrote Marineford, Skypia, Alabasta and Enies Lobby at some point...Maybe one of his editors has already replaced him, perhaps that guy that was crying at the end of the wedding at Whole Cake? At least that would explain a lot

 

[Sentinel]

Is Tsunade also > Kisame because muh narrative importance lol?

Even if we assume Bee would’ve won if he could transform into the full Gyuki, beating V2 Bee is still very impressive. Base Bee was bullying Hebi Sasuke and his squad.

Gai needed to use Hirudora to beat Kisame who wasn't even in his shark mode. The same attack completely destroyed Madara's V2 Susanoo and it even forced Juudara to defend himself from it.

Kisame definitely would have won against Bee because he didn't only have a massive match-up advantage, he was also known to be the "tail less" Bijuu, his chakra was already comparable to a Bijuu. Tsunade is the weakest among the Sannin and she definitely ain't strong enough to beat Kisame in a battle.

 

[Shikoku]

Remember, Oda wrote Marineford, Skypia, Alabasta and Enies Lobby at some point...Maybe one of his editors has already replaced him, perhaps that guy that was crying at the end of the wedding at Whole Cake? At least that would explain a lot

the editors are prolly the main reason as to why the show got shit, since they aren’t doing their job

OP prolly got to big to work in the usual author-editor duo, where the author brings in the ideas like a visionary and the editor makes sure it’s palpable to the audience and not just for self consumption (literally gear 5, which has exactly one real fan, oda himself)