By the way Seth, day 1 is the most unhelpful for new players because we rely a lot on how familiar we are with the way people play.
As a noob, I'm tossing out everyone's meta reads and "he always plays like that" stuff. It's impossible for me to know which of you are over/understating another player's usual style or wording things in a way that helps your own scummy team. I can't rely on claims of past play, so I'm gonna throw all my thoughts here.
I think Cin's explanation concerning why he asked about alignments makes sense. If he is independent, then I don't see what lynching him on the first day would do. There seems to be an equal chance that he could be either good or bad.
I also noticed Gianfi's fluff and thought it was weird. Medium sus.
Melon/Jew/Lanji/Neutral all seem a little aggressive, but I'm waiting to see how they react and argue with each other.
Seth just got here and he came in swinging. Medium sus.
And this caught my eye about the BIG NEWS thing.
I love our little revolution
I understand that claiming isn't allowed, but REVOLUTION just seems a little on the nose, doesn't it?? Since Seth is Rayan's sub, this adds up to possible scum for me.
I still think something was up with Final getting banned/unbanned/rebanned as soon as the game started. Who was the first person to mention it in here, and @that person, Where and how did you discover he was banned and why did you announce it in this thread? I also don't trust Nat telling us that it's not related to the game.
Marimo has my vote so far. This didn't sit well with me.
Regarding the set up- I doubt the hosts would make any of the newbies mafia when they are just learning the ropes.
I was kind of surprised he didn't realize that his suggestion would violate the integrity of the game. For a split second, my faith in Flower and Krogothwolf, RPGs, the United States Constitution, my own existence, and RNG games was destroyed. I got better though. I was glad to see people correct him about this bc it seemed so absurd to say.
I also want to hear from all the quieter people (I realize I've been one too, haha). Is everyone required to give reads on D1?
Vote lynch Marimo