Okay, time for these reviews. I'm not gonna do a review on everybody, ain't got that kinda time and energy. If I didn't give you a review in here and you want one, pm me for it. I'll probably say no but you can still try
I'll start with Mafia, specifically
@Tris and
@Midnight Delight (not you Larimo).
Mafia overall this game played much better than Town did. Tris, your claim was very good. You were able to back yourself well with your fake results without contradicting yourself. Town bit into your claim like candy and as a result, the attention shifted to Jew and Gambit with Town wasting 2 days on Jew. Even Zara was catching heat because ppl believed your claim more than they believed his. Well done.
As for you Midnight, you were decent. Nothing spectacular but not terrible either. You laid low for most of the game which was nice but as you play more games you're gonna have to progress into being more proactive in the day phase to get more town cred. The Escort claim wasn't the best idea. Had you not done it, Jew likely would have been lynched.
Now, for town...
@Melontonin you were the best townie by far. Your entrance saved Town from destruction. Your experience with ToS served you well. I think you were the first player to put some doubt on Tris's Spy claim. You stepped up as a leader during the day and guided Town in the right direction. Not much to say for you, just overall well done.
@Zara I understand the logic you were using to suspect Gambit and Jew. Gambit got set up by TAC and became very suspicious as a result. Tris's Spy claim had hoodwinked all of you thus leading to suspecting Jew. You just plainly got deceived and that's more of a credit to others' gameplay than to say you did bad. For your first ToS game, I actually think you had done rather well. Town before your entrance was dull and slow but your arrival allowed them to become more confident and more involved. Tho, you should have definitely studied those roles, at least the invest ones like I told you. Would have helped you out a lot.
@Jew D. Boy what I said for Zara applies to you as well. Tris's claim was believable, Gambit had already flipped town, you knew you were town so it left it as Zara being the liar. Can't blame you for that line of logic. Tho, I certainly you should have had a bit more patient with his results. He wasn't proven wrong just yet. You could have pushed for Tris's lynch and if she flipped town then you shoot Zara immediately the next night. And one more thing, you shouldn't have claimed Vigilante with a Witch running about. What would have served you better would be a Veteran claim. No scum would want to visit a Veteran who still has alerts left and if you faked your actions accordingly, it likely would have been believable, especially since this was a no Jailor game. Now, I do understand this is your first ToS game so you wouldn't have known that sort of strategy, but it's just something for you to know for next time.
Last thing I want to add for you guys, don't auto assume a commonly used role is gonna be in a game, especially not for any game that I'm hosting. I intentionally left out Jailor, Escort, and Doctor knowing y'all will think at least one of them, if not all three, existed without much evidence. Yeah, I cucked y'all
That will be it for reviews. Again, if you were not mentioned in here or simply want to talk more about your gameplay, pm me. No guarantee that I will do it though