Who will Zoro Cut (not the fish Kaido)


  • Total voters
    213
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Kaido D. Stronger

The truth is that KAIDO defeated sengoku while kaido did not have a DF and everyone was scared and BIG MOM gave him the DF, knowing that he would become the absolute monster in the world of one piece, the legendary beast.
Although kaido base did a low difficulty on 9 red scabbards, even without using DF and named attacks.
 
1. that you would have to say Kaido knows this somehow. Like how does Kaido know this very specific thing?
He figured out, just like everyone else figured out the abilities of his DFs.
2. Kaido has to be able to move under water even though he's a devil fruit user
Then again, exceptions prove the rule. Oda would make an exception for the sake of story telling.
@comrade @Bogard
Yo boys since we coming close to the legendary flashback with God valley(I hope it), how you guys would put these characters in powerlvl?
Xebec,Roger,Primebeard,Shiki,Bigmom,Kaido,Garp,Sengoku and the others?
Do you guys believe Xebec,Roger and Primebeard where on their on lvl? Like top top tier?
Hard to scale them all. Roger and Primebeard are definitely stronger than Xebec. Whitebeard probably didn't have his fruit back then. I also think Kaido is stronger than Xebec. After all he didn't have his Dragon ability prior to that. And since Big Mom is close to Kaido, she too is stronger than Xebec. Either way between the rest. With Xebec being probably somewhere in the mid top tier range.
 
Sengoku and Rayleigh had to be present. It doesn't make sense otherwise unless there was a betrayal from a Rocks member.
Yeah think the same too, otherwise it would not make much sense if Sengoku wasn't their too. Oda always portrayal Garp and Sengoku as equals and they beeing together in every big event like:
Shiki vs Roger> Garp and Sengoku going together to the war
Shiki attacking Marinefore> Garp and Sengoku beat him down
Roger wanting strong navy soldiers> he mentioned Garp and Sengoku together.

Im sure Sengoku was at the same lvl as Garp, the question for me is more like, where Garp and Sengoku already in their prime when they battle against Rocks? I doubt it and also it doesn't make much sense if the Navy just send Garp to deal with the Rocks.

Take in mind Garp and Roger alliance only get make when both meet each other in God valley. With mean neither the Navy+WG know anything about Roger beeing in God Valley. With means Garp was send with a fleet who was supposed to deal with the whole Rocks pirate and I doubt he was only the strong character against such monsters.

It make more sense that Sengoku was send too like they did it for God valley.
 
J

Jo_Ndule

Yeah think the same too, otherwise it would not make much sense if Sengoku wasn't their too. Oda always portrayal Garp and Sengoku as equals and they beeing together in every big event like:
Shiki vs Roger> Garp and Sengoku going together to the war
Shiki attacking Marinefore> Garp and Sengoku beat him down
Roger wanting strong navy soldiers> he mentioned Garp and Sengoku together.

Im sure Sengoku was at the same lvl as Garp, the question for me is more like, where Garp and Sengoku already in their prime when they battle against Rocks? I doubt it and also it doesn't make much sense if the Navy just send Garp to deal with the Rocks.

Take in mind Garp and Roger alliance only get make when both meet each other in God valley. With mean neither the Navy+WG know anything about Roger beeing in God Valley. With means Garp was send with a fleet who was supposed to deal with the whole Rocks pirate and I doubt he was only the strong character against such monsters.

It make more sense that Sengoku was send too like they did it for God valley.
If Sengoku went
It would explain why WB and sengoku seems to have a past together, wb knows that sengoku is always a tactical fighter .

Garp and Roger vs Xebec
Sengoku vs WB
Rayleigh and Scopper vs BM or Shiki
Rest of strong guys vs Shiki or BM
 
Yeah think the same too, otherwise it would not make much sense if Sengoku wasn't their too. Oda always portrayal Garp and Sengoku as equals and they beeing together in every big event like:
Shiki vs Roger> Garp and Sengoku going together to the war
Shiki attacking Marinefore> Garp and Sengoku beat him down
Roger wanting strong navy soldiers> he mentioned Garp and Sengoku together.

Im sure Sengoku was at the same lvl as Garp, the question for me is more like, where Garp and Sengoku already in their prime when they battle against Rocks? I doubt it and also it doesn't make much sense if the Navy just send Garp to deal with the Rocks.

Take in mind Garp and Roger alliance only get make when both meet each other in God valley. With mean neither the Navy+WG know anything about Roger beeing in God Valley. With means Garp was send with a fleet who was supposed to deal with the whole Rocks pirate and I doubt he was only the strong character against such monsters.

It make more sense that Sengoku was send too like they did it for God valley.
And yet only garp is hero of the marines
 
What's important to note about that Rocks fight is that there is probably a freakin huge gap inbetween high top tiers and high high-/ low top tiers.
Imagine shown Big Mom just weaker, perhaps even w/o Napoleon, younger~weaker base Kaido w/o his fruit, Shiki perhaps w/o his fruit.
Those guys would get sent flying to another dimension by stuff like Roger's "Kamusari".

Or imagine Prime Garp speedblitzing around with Soru and Geppou while pulling out monstrous internal destruction haki punches.
I can easily see how those guys could have been heavily outmatched by guys like Garp and Roger, even though they later turned into legends themselves.

Certain abilities are just THAT strong.
The admirals for example probably make a huge jump in power by just activating their DF awakening abilities.
"Recently you just fought low top tier Akainu, who pulled out magma punches here and there and a year later, he turns a freakin island into a sea of magma with Vulcanoes and shit."
Solely one new ability that made this happen.
 
He figured out, just like everyone else figured out the abilities of his DFs.
Then again, exceptions prove the rule. Oda would make an exception for the sake of story telling.
He figured out that he had to go Wano and climb a waterfall?

Really? You've seen someone in the story with this very specific power activation? And oda will explain how Kaido knows this right?

remember when devil fruits have complicated workings, oda does in fact explain how characters know what to do. For example law is specifically trained as a doctor to explain how he's so good with this complicated fruit.

So you expect oda to somehow explain to us how Kaido knows to go Wano turn into a fish and swim up a waterfall.

And again with the Kaido swimming as a devil fruit user, you are ignoring that Oda explains these things. Blackberry doesn't just eat two devil fruits and nothing is made of it. Oda intentionally adds that there's a reason for it. A devil fruit without the devil fruit weaknesses must come with an explanation as well. Is it the God of all devil fruits? Is it the original devil fruit? Something. There must be an explanation.

You are weirdly okay with "shit happens" as a mechanic in the story. Imagine if blackbeard ate two devil fruits marineford and everyone in the world was like "Shit happens, whatever"... hehehe... this would work for you?
 
If Sengoku went
It would explain why WB and sengoku seems to have a past together, wb knows that sengoku is always a tactical fighter .

Garp and Roger vs Xebec
Sengoku vs WB
Rayleigh and Scopper vs BM or Shiki
Rest of strong guys vs Shiki or BM
Good point. WB respected Sengoku more than Garp at MF. Sengoku was the only Marine who WB did not trash talk, but praise his intellect more than once. They had to have past confrontations.
Yeah think the same too, otherwise it would not make much sense if Sengoku wasn't their too. Oda always portrayal Garp and Sengoku as equals and they beeing together in every big event like:
Shiki vs Roger> Garp and Sengoku going together to the war
Shiki attacking Marinefore> Garp and Sengoku beat him down
Roger wanting strong navy soldiers> he mentioned Garp and Sengoku together.

Im sure Sengoku was at the same lvl as Garp, the question for me is more like, where Garp and Sengoku already in their prime when they battle against Rocks? I doubt it and also it doesn't make much sense if the Navy just send Garp to deal with the Rocks.

Take in mind Garp and Roger alliance only get make when both meet each other in God valley. With mean neither the Navy+WG know anything about Roger beeing in God Valley. With means Garp was send with a fleet who was supposed to deal with the whole Rocks pirate and I doubt he was only the strong character against such monsters.

It make more sense that Sengoku was send too like they did it for God valley.
It's kinda portrayed that Marine Top Tiers reach their Prime at 45-55.
Garp and Sengoku were 40/41 respectively at Gods valley, so i think we can say that they were very near their absolute peak.
Post automatically merged:

I really feel like sengoku would've been mentioned in the rocks teaser of he was there, that'd add even more hype and suspense. It just seems silly to leave him out of it
Same for Rayleigh. Why would Roger fight his main rival without his crew, doesn't make much sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top