Status
Not open for further replies.

BangOO🍅

Pepebusi Spammer
What is the criteria and what has he fit? How has he impacted the world in the last five years?
He keep fighting Kaido and never submit to join beast pirates even though he get clapped and killer forced to eat smile too.
Ace mentioned Kid wrecking some shit in the south blue, and now he will show the world why he is a D by landing a finishing blow against Kaido (if Oda stop doing a Luffy's show)
 
What is the criteria and what has he fit? How has he impacted the world in the last five years?
Law broke the Gears. Kid was in the New World, he didn’t make headlines. He was just independent. Could he be a D.? If Oda chooses that route, who am I to complain. But Oda doesn’t hand out D cards to just everyone.

So far the carriers of the Will of D shown have had worldwide impacting implications. Kid hasn’t had any although he’s at the height of his Piracy, and has been for five years. Law made massive moves, became a Warlord, broke the Gears, took down Caesar and Doffy, successfully led an alliance with Luffy against Kaido. Kid has rode Luffys coattails in any “definition” of D since Sabaody.
What do you mean he has to be impactful to the world in the last years? Blackbeard as far as we know is a D and spent most of his life not doing anything great, just riding along with Whitebeard, now he started doing his things. It could just mean Kidd hasn't started doing his shit yet.
 

Seth

𝐊𝐨𝐤𝐮𝐭𝐨 𝐒𝐡𝐮𝐬𝐮𝐢
Jaguar handed over and saved Nico Robin to Luffy, so the world can shift. He fulfilled a critical role that he accomplished with his death.
He was a fodder. Show me another D. as weak as that dumb giant.

He didn't save Robin. Aokiji did.
 
He keep fighting Kaido and never submit to join beast pirates even though he get clapped and killer forced to eat smile too.
Ace mentioned Kid wrecking some shit in the south blue, and now he will show the world why he is a D by landing a finishing blow against Kaido (if Oda stop doing a Luffy's show)
Kid is not landing any finishing blows on Kaido. He has CoC that’s why he’s not bending a knee. Ace bent a knee and Blackbeard bent a knee, does that now mean he’s not a D.

Jinbei is more accomplished than Kid, is he a D?

The Simple definition of the Will of D is the Will to Destroy/Radically shift the world. Each Will of D member has done so. Kid has not, even in Sabaody he got the credit for attacking a Celestial, when it was All Luffy.
 

yj

👑YNWA 👑
Kidd wasn't relevant up until just recently
I like Kidd but he will never have that screen time and focus like Law had, its just too late now
They’re dreaming they’re about to off a yonko because of the plan and alliance law proposed. Heck law is the key to finding out the truth behind the will of D and everything. that tin can never get that goldy portrayal. Bringing to Odas words he didnt expect Law to be this important.. he basically took over the plans Oda had for Kidd.
 
Zoro >= Luffy :

- Zoro spent 2 years training with WSS , Luffy spent 1.5 years training with Rayleigh

- Against the octopus , Zoro did the most damage to it

- Zoro one shot Hody Jones underwater

- Hyozou blocked a G2 jet pistol from Luffy and he called him pretty strong. Zoro one shot him and said " you're not enough to kill my boredom"

- Luffy couldnt even damage to the dragon in PH , Zoro one shot with a shi shishi sonson

- Luffy was losing to Monet , Zoro neg diffed her.

- Apoo 2 shotted Luffy , Zoro one shotted Apoo

------------------------------------------------------------------

Against the same opponents , Zoro outperformed Luffy.

In Post TS , Zoro has been given Enma as a tool to get stronger.
Luffy has been given Advanced Armament and Advanced Observation


Both Luffy and Zoro are on the roof now meaning that they will be fighting the yonkos. If Zoro was not at least as strong or stronger than Luffy , what reason would there be for him to be there?

In other words , Grandmaster is simply built different :finally:
 
What do you mean he has to be impactful to the world in the last years? Blackbeard as far as we know is a D and spent most of his life not doing anything great, just riding along with Whitebeard, now he started doing his things. It could just mean Kidd hasn't started doing his shit yet.
Blackbeard shook the world by eating a Second Devil Fruit and Killing Whitebeard and then defeating the Whitebeard Remnants, and then Becoming an Emperor. And now (massive logica speculation) he’s after an Ancient Weapon and/or Poneglyph
 

Seth

𝐊𝐨𝐤𝐮𝐭𝐨 𝐒𝐡𝐮𝐬𝐮𝐢
Aokiji kept her alive because Akainu blew up the ship, and he felt guilt. Jaguar D. Saul deliberately saved Nico Robin. Don’t let Power Scaling biases cloud your narrative judgement
Aokiji wouldn't kill her in the first place he's not fucking Akainu. He would inform the others that came with him to decide what to do with her or shit since she was a kid and you are right he did save her after he saw how fucked up Akainu is.

He did. Not that giant no one.
 
Blackbeard shook the world by eating a Second Devil Fruit and Killing Whitebeard and then defeating the Whitebeard Remnants, and then Becoming an Emperor. And now (massive logica speculation) he’s after an Ancient Weapon and/or Poneglyph
But he did that after spenting over 20 years doing nothing, just chilling and waiting for his moment. Kidd is still really young, so just because he didn't do shit so far, doesn't mean he can't do shit later on, that's my argument that you completely ignored. You're saying Kidd can't be a D because he's not doing shit, well 3 years before the start of the series Blackbeard also didn't do shit.
 

BangOO🍅

Pepebusi Spammer
Kid is not landing any finishing blows on Kaido. He has CoC that’s why he’s not bending a knee. Ace bent a knee and Blackbeard bent a knee, does that now mean he’s not a D.

Jinbei is more accomplished than Kid, is he a D?

The Simple definition of the Will of D is the Will to Destroy/Radically shift the world. Each Will of D member has done so. Kid has not, even in Sabaody he got the credit for attacking a Celestial, when it was All Luffy.
Whats the point Oda give Kid portrayal as Luffy's rival if he will not doing something mind blowing later in the story.

If he isnt D isnt a big deal anyway, the fact that he have CoC is kinda enough.
 

Seth

𝐊𝐨𝐤𝐮𝐭𝐨 𝐒𝐡𝐮𝐬𝐮𝐢
Blackbeard's downfall will mirror Ace's downfall. I think despite being a mastermind Blackbeard sooner or later will get so full of himself because he has 2 ( soon maybe 3 ) devil fruits and he will be a one-trick pony.

If you think about it for a minute. The only way Luffy can defeat him is thru Haki right now.
 
Aokiji wouldn't kill her in the first place he's not fucking Akainu. He would inform the others that came with him to decide what to do with her or shit since she was a kid and you are right he did save her after he saw how fucked up Akainu is.

He did. Not that giant no one.
Bruh the Giant died saving her. That’s what the story is telling us. He was a Vice Admiral, right under the Admiral position, it’s not like he was a fodder marine.

Not to mention he defected during a Buster Call mission which is crazy in itself and then he broke out Nico Olivia as well who was a threat to the WG cuz she was Poneglyph hunting. He was instrumental to the cause of the D. Aokiji wouldn’t kill her, but she would never listen to the ppl that burned down her country.
 
P
But he did that after spenting over 20 years doing nothing, just chilling and waiting for his moment. Kidd is still really young, so just because he didn't do shit so far, doesn't mean he can't do shit later on, that's my argument that you completely ignored. You're saying Kidd can't be a D because he's not doing shit, well 3 years before the start of the series Blackbeard also didn't do shit.
Blackbeard was patient, meticulous, and cunning. Kid is the exact opposite of that. Kid has already made his moves against three emperors and fucked them up. By your metric Jinbei can also have the Will of D since he’s been trying to free the Fishman and himself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top