Search results

How truly likeable and intetesting, or unlikeable and uninteresting, are the Straw Hat Pirates as characters and as protagonists of the story? Do you think that Oda succeeded at making the crew endearing and easy to root for, or at keeping them tha way, or did he fail?

What do you really think of the Straw Hat Pirates as a group and as characters and protagonists? Do you like them, or do you dislike them, or are you indifferent toward them ? Has your opinion of them changed over time and the progression of the manga? Do you find them better or worse than before?

Which One Piece arc, most likely before the timeskip but you can also choose a postskip arc, did truly give you adventures vibes and felt the most like an exploration and amusing discovery to you ?

Who are some characters in One Piece that are supposed to be great heroes or characters we should admire and love, or at least sympathetic but that fail to gain sympathy or respect from you with the manga making them appear as far from admirable or sympathetic as Oda intended them to be ? Old...

What are in your mind the worst cases and moments of writing in One Piece, whenever it's an arc, one or several characters and the way they are written and handled, one or several fights, or even the smallest moments that make absolutely no sense and were absolutely terrible ?

Who amongst OP characters do you think has the best character development and become a better character the most since the beginning of the manga ? Who on the other hand has regressed the most as a character, losing substance and development and being the worst victim of flanderization in the...

Which arc of One Piece had the best fights in the manga, visually, choregraphy and/or powerwise ? And which arc had on the contrary the very worst fights in the history of One Piece ? And also which arc had the best battle ? Which one had the worst battle ?

Of the many antagonist groups who faced and opposed the Straw Hats, WG-affiliated or not, which one(s) do you think was/were handled in the worst way by Oda, either failing to make them interesting or destroying their credibility as an antagonist group and threat or both?

What is or are your favorite power up(s) in the manga ? For which reasons do you love it and prefer it to others ? And what is/are your least favorite power up(s) ?

What is your opinion on the Pacifista, their powers and role in the story ? Do you like what has been done with them ? What were your theories, ideas, speculations on them and on what the next models after the originals shown in Saobody and Marineford and the ultimate phase of the project...

What are your ideas of new logia devil fruits and of the powers and techniques that could be done with them ? What are some elements that haven't been covered yet in One Piece ?

The title says it all, what are some characters that the manga treats as if we are supposed to admire and respect them, but that you don't find respectable or even likeable at all ? I'd say Roger doesn't really inspire any admiration or respect to me, the dude who screamed about freedom but was...

What is your opinion on Jewerly Bonney and how she has been written ever since her introduction in Saobody arc ? Do you like or dislike the character ? Do you think that her writing has been consistent, with how she was portrayed before the ts and after the ts ? Are you happy or unhappy with...

Who are One Piece antagonists who had some really amazing potential, both as characters and as fighters with their devil fruit, haki and/or physical abilities and/or other skills; but which potential was neglected or even outright wasted by Oda ? Which OP antagonists could have been portrayed...

What are some examples of pirate captain character who are likeable or interesting enough but whose crews are really lackluster and bland, being either too generic in appearance or very underdevelopped in terms of characterization and personalities ? I'd say that all of the Supernova crews...

Let's imagine than other than having one or several divisions of subordinates under their command and them having their own personal ships, the Yonko Commanders from the Whitebeard Pirates, Beast Pirates, Big Mom Pirates, Red Hair Pirates and Blackbeard Pirates had enough power and freedom given...

Who exactly do you think was the one above Sengoku who gave the order to Doflamingo to kill Moria, due to him being "too weak" ? Also why Doflamingo instead of an admiral, CP0 or any more trustworthy agent ?

What are some characters who are far too protected by Oda, during fights and when they do something stupid and should face consequences for it but face none, or both at the same time ? The Straw Hats, especially Luffy, Rayleigh, Shanks, Sabo, Boa Hancock, Law all come to mind.

What if One Piece actually made smarter uses of their devil fruits and ressources, and could make real plans, tactics and strategies in and outside of battle ? What are some plans for battle, assassination, thievery and other special missions that could be done with certain devil fruits ...

What plan should Whitebeard have made and done if he really wanted to save Ace from execution without sacrifying himself and at least half of his crew and allies ? What should he and his crew have done rather than directly attack Marineford and try to rescue Ace without any plan save from using...