My only argument is to look at my play so far, where I jumped onto Ratchet and fairly reliably proved Ekko (who was in PoE) wasn't really an option to be scum. I've only been in the game for a couple of phases but to be honest most of what I've said so far has been accurate.
I can't really speak for people that were in the slot before me because I don't know what they've posted, all I know is they weren't happy to be playing in the messages