Character Discussion Calling Yamato a she

[Tobra]

sideboob

 

[Natalija]

I think this would be a more interesting thing to discuss:

Why does Kaido call her a he? Does he do it because he respects her wish to be Oden/a man? Or does he do it because he always wanted a son?

@Jew D. Boy

 

[Red Night]

Claiming you're a man doesn't make you one.

 

[Staticshadic]

I think type character Yamato base on

These two know how speak Japanese language they might shed some light on the matter in terms what type character Yamato is

 

[Fn Lucci]

Tbh I avoid pronouns with Yamato because it's not all that clear.

When it comes to gender politics there are things I agree with or disagree with in any argument, but I at least respect the individual. Obviously we are talking about a fictional character, but I don't think it's about the subject more than projection of decency. Like don't say weird shit about Tama because it's a child character, right?

 

[Jew D. Boy]

I think this would be a more interesting thing to discuss:

Why does Kaido call her a he? Does he do it because he respects her wish to be Oden/a man? Or does he do it because he always wanted a son?

@Jew D. Boy

Gotta be the latter; when she was introduced, it kinda felt like it could go either way, but even considering how much he clearly respects his fallen rival, he’s also systematically destroyed everything about the guy’s legacy. Doesn’t feel like he does it out of respect for Yamato so much as disappointment that she isn’t an actual man.

 

[Jailer]

Tumblr and the blogs

Worse then

Post automatically merged: May 17, 2021

Kaido simply wanted a son to become the Shogun, can't have a female do that, why you think he got her wearing a mask.

 

[Staticshadic]

Worse then

Tell me about it Instagram user, Twitter and tumblr they make Yamato looks like guy it’s freaking gross.

 

[Natalija]

Gotta be the latter; when she was introduced, it kinda felt like it could go either way, but even considering how much he clearly respects his fallen rival, he’s also systematically destroyed everything about the guy’s legacy. Doesn’t feel like he does it out of respect for Yamato so much as disappointment that she isn’t an actual man.

I'm not entirely sure about this. Yamato clearly defies him at every corner, yet he still speaks of her in high regard (asks about her presence etc.).

If he didn't care, he wouldn't want to keep Yamato on the island either, not in a non-imprisoned manner anyways.

I am tinfoiling that Kaido likes her stubborn nature to do what she wants.

 

[Blother Fertitta]

Does it even matter?
Seems like your intent was just to cause an uproar

 

[Kucing Pencuri]

Yamato is a shemale

 

[Ballel]

Who opened this thread again??

Post automatically merged: May 17, 2021

does he do it because he always wanted a son?

maybe this

 

[Starbound Beast D. Draig]

Yamato is a shemale

Futanari

 

[Natalija]

Who opened this thread again??

maybe this

Me

We don't know this for a fact yet. Kaido never implied he cares about gender so far. He only ever cared about strength.

 

[Geo]

Me

We don't know this for a fact yet. Kaido never implied he cares about gender so far. He only ever cared about strength.

Why open it when it has already been proven false in the thread with manga Panels

 

[Natalija]

Why open it when it has already been proven false in the thread with manga Pamela

Yamato pronouns are very important to her and in the manga.

 

[Geo]

Yamato pronouns are very important to her and in the manga.

Did you read the posts in the first page?
Narrator calls her "Kaido's Daughter"
She only says she's a man because Oden is a man. Cosplaying as Oden
This is quite clear

 

[Natalija]

Did you read the posts in the first page?
Narrator calls her "Kaido's Daughter"
She only says she's a man because Oden is a man. Cosplaying as Oden
This is quite clear

I didn't say she's a man, did I. I said how she identifies is important, as well as how Kaido calls her.

If you have nothing to contribute to the thread, then don't.

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

The weird irony is that Yamato probably doesn’t care if you’re calling her with her or calling him with him!

what’s more funny is that people are sooooo sensetive about Yamato pronouns although it’s very controversial how she/he feels inside yet they are sooooo insensetive about Kiku’s pronouns although she admitted that she feels like a woman in her heart.. yet people are so insensetive towards her saying “he” always in a very sarcastic way

Hmmm... I wonder why that is!?


Is it because Yamato is born biologically as a woman that every single one has to act like a shining armor knight around for the thirst!?
Or is it for a different reason!?

 

[Geo]

I didn't say she's a man, did I. I said how she identifies is important, as well as how Kaido calls her.

If you have nothing to contribute to the thread, then don't.

And that is not the purpose of the thread.
If you want to discuss it's importance, then make a thread discussing it's importance.

I just contributed to the thread