Questions & Mysteries Can Roger become the pirate king in this era?

Can Roger become the PK?

  • Yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
#23
It depends on a lot of stuff. He in the end dethroned Xebec, who was the former "pirate king" in a way, even if he didn't care about the OP or even worse didn't manage to find it. Yet powerwise for sure he was a monster. But in the end he sonewhat beat him with the help of WB.

The Xebec of this gen is BB who is his inheritor, most likely at his prime he will be stronger than Xebec. If Roger can fight before he matures (and if Roger has to restart from scratch a point in time where Roger is somewhat stronger) or if Roger can team with somebody and go after BB ass (like he did with Xebec). And hoping for hik that it isn't BB to team up with somebody to go against him.

Then there is Im, in his era Im probably did nothing because he knew That ger was not a real menace and indeed Roger knew that too. But this generation it is different and Im will act very soon, so another big wild card. And since Roger is a D. for sure his wanted poster will replace Luffy's in Im castle.

Admirals and the navy side has weaker top tiers than Garp at least, so they lack somebody who can truly try to hunt the pirate king. At least If it is not going after a young Roger like the navy somewhat tried to do with pre G5 Luffy.

And also depends on a lot of other factors (excluding plot power of course). To make an example if somebody like Skypea Luffy met Enel he would be fried 110 times out of 100 but he was "very lucky" to have the rubber fruit. Or vs Kaido, he was again "very lucky" to have his fruit awaken and, not only resuscitate him, but also make him stronger or at least comparable to Kaido. Who was then "unlucky" to fall exactly in a volcano which exploded right when he was in. Very unlucky.
 
#24
Crews follow the basics of

Captain>YC1>YC2.

You don't think Gaban was Roger YC2 before Oden?
What is this YC nonsense? Roger was not a Yonko.
If you are asking me if Gaban was the 3rd Strongest after Roger and Rayleigh before Oden than its possible but not confirmed in any way.

But that's got nothing to do with the difference of strength between 1, 2, 3, etc of the crew
 
#26
What is this YC nonsense? Roger was not a Yonko.
If you are asking me if Gaban was the 3rd Strongest after Roger and Rayleigh before Oden than its possible but not confirmed in any way.

But that's got nothing to do with the difference of strength between 1, 2, 3, etc of the crew
Roger was not a Yonko because the title came after him.

What is a PK? Just a Yonko that won the PK race.

If any Yonko become PK, their crew dynamic remains the same.

Across all crews the YC1 is stronger than YC2, but it's not a gap so big that King/Zoro would Negg diff Queen/Sanji.
 
#28
Anyway, I won't discuss this anymore because it really... Don't matter.

Maybe Gaban will apear again or maybe not, but he will be a old man, his prime strength is non relevant unless he gets feats.

Its was just a level of strength I personally feel he should have, it's not backed by feats. And that's alright.
 
#29
Roger was not a Yonko because the title came after him.

What is a PK? Just a Yonko that won the PK race.

If any Yonko become PK, their crew dynamic remains the same.

Across all crews the YC1 is stronger than YC2, but it's not a gap so big that King/Zoro would Negg diff Queen/Sanji.
That is current Yonko and current PK. Very different in Roger's era.

Buggy becoming the PK destroys this dynamic that you are thinkng of anyway.

They do absolutely neg diff them btw
 

Warchief Sanji D Goat

Panty Anarchy!🩲
#33
Oda missed countless opportunities to introduce him.

Tbh if he doesnt show up in Elbaf or at least to have some connection with the burned man and/or underworld brokers i cant see him in the current story, maybe some fbs.
I agreed tbh.

It's kinda late to introduce him this late into the story but whatever.
 
Top