Controversial Convince me that One Piece is Bad..
- Thread starter Eagle
- Start date
my personal unbiased headcanon version of One Piece is infititely better (i am unbiased)
There is no way that One Piece can compete with the story my mind has concocted
Other than that
Kill characters
stop baiting/cliffhanging/offscreening
generally faster pace, like the current arc
finish some damn plotlines
stop introducing new formulaic side characters (especially the kid / female that every arc needs apparently)
There is no way that One Piece can compete with the story my mind has concocted
Other than that
Kill characters
stop baiting/cliffhanging/offscreening
generally faster pace, like the current arc
finish some damn plotlines
stop introducing new formulaic side characters (especially the kid / female that every arc needs apparently)
The premise of One Piece is quite simple. Oda created a story where the main characters can travel to islands and that island’s arc is a completely new genre. Oda can go from high seas adventure, fairytales, Shinto mythology, and science fiction without blinking an eye. We are supposed to learn about the world through the SHs.
The problem is that the One Piece world is so big and Oda only wants to focus on Luffy. Luffy is a great character during the pre time skip, and I still like him post time skip too. When a world is so vast, a writer needs to show multiple perspectives. Oda refuses to do that. Instead everything is through Luffy’s perspective and he’s a very straightforward character.
Furthermore, Oda has a habit of resetting his characters each arc. It’s like his world is expanding as his readers got older, but Oda refused to let the SHs grow. Instead they react to things the exact same way and it’s usually on a shallow level.
Basically Oda created a world and story that would have been more effective if he focused on multiple perspectives.
The problem is that the One Piece world is so big and Oda only wants to focus on Luffy. Luffy is a great character during the pre time skip, and I still like him post time skip too. When a world is so vast, a writer needs to show multiple perspectives. Oda refuses to do that. Instead everything is through Luffy’s perspective and he’s a very straightforward character.
Furthermore, Oda has a habit of resetting his characters each arc. It’s like his world is expanding as his readers got older, but Oda refused to let the SHs grow. Instead they react to things the exact same way and it’s usually on a shallow level.
Basically Oda created a world and story that would have been more effective if he focused on multiple perspectives.
H
How is it not about adventure now? They're still going to crazy and wild places just like they used to. It's just that they're going to each location with more purpose now 
They went to Dressrosa knowing they would face Doflamingo.
They went Zou knowing they would regroup.
They went WCI knowing they would take Sanji back and leave.
They went Wano knowing they would defeat Kaido.
Only now the adventure got back since they didn't knew they would end up in Egghead Island.
@Herrera95 this is the perfect thread for you, lmao.