Powers & Abilities Could it be that Zoro actually did go all out in dressrosa? Zoro doesn't know how to use asura

#62
Zoro used the same attack he used for Mihawk on Pica. That's all. Anything else is waffle. If you want to say that Zoro wasn't going all out Vs Mihawk, that's another matter
Arsenals evolve you know. Luffy used G2 attacks against admirals so is G2 Luffys ultimate mode?

Zoros peak evolved from Sanzen Sekkai to Ashura in EL, just like Luffys peak evolved from Bazooka to G3
 
#63
I don't see anything wrong with how Oda has portrayed Zoro. It could very well be that there wasn't an opponent on DR suitable for Zoro to go all out on. The moment Zoro pushed back an admiral and countered the admiral's attack, that was the moment you should've known that there wasn't going be an enemy among DD's underlings who will push Zoro to go all out.
If what you are saying is true, I'm just wondering why this is the case. Why couldn't Oda just make Pica stronger if ISDS wasn't Zoro's effective limit.

because like i said, every other straw hat has shown their limits.
Post automatically merged:

Why should Zoro be treated differently?
 
#64
If what you are saying is true, I'm just wondering why this is the case. Why couldn't Oda just make Pica stronger if ISDS wasn't Zoro's effective limit.

because like i said, every other straw hat has shown their limits.
I think its all to establish a narrative that Zoro is too strong to be a subordinate and no subordinate can match up to him hence hyping up Zoros ability to have exceptionally strong guys follow him.

For Zoro to get his match he needs to be fighting Luffys opponents not his own.
Or rather fighting captains and not RHM.
Post automatically merged:

Zoro vs Killer is perfect example of that.
Hyped hp worst gen RHM got low diffed because Zoro is at the level of Kidd not killer @Monkey D Theories

While Luffy is also on the level of Kidd
 
#65
I forget who, but someone made a good point that Zoro can't use Ashura unless he is severely damaged. In Buddhism, Ashura is apart of the Cycle of Samsara, or "The Cycle of suffering". So it stands to reason that the only way Zoro is able to draw Ashura out is after going through a substantial amount of pain and suffering.

It makes sense, because that is Oda's way of doing things. He won't simply give his protagonist a substantial power boost, without setting some kind of stipulation, or drawback for using said powerup. In Zoro's case, there is no major kickback for using Ashura, so setting up a stipulation in order for him to use it, seems the most logical.
 
#66
I think its all to establish a narrative that Zoro is too strong to be a subordinate and no subordinate can match up to him hence hyping up Zoros ability to have exceptionally strong guys follow him.

For Zoro to get his match he needs to be fighting Luffys opponents not his own.
Or rather fighting captains and not RHM.
Post automatically merged:

Zoro vs Killer is perfect example of that.
Hyped hp worst gen RHM got low diffed because Zoro is at the level of Kidd not killer @Monkey D Theories

While Luffy is also on the level of Kidd
And so Oda decides to not let him go all out until Onigashima? I just can't help but feel like, if this was the case, that Oda mismanaged Zoro.

There are easier ways to show that narrative than this.

But since:
  • Zoro doesn't use asura casually like Luffy uses G2/G3 and Sanji uses diable jambe
  • Zoro has only used asura twice in the entire series, and they were both pre-skip
  • we're 10 years into the post-timeskip and in one of the most pivotal parts of the series
  • Both Sanji and jinbe went all out against a similarly huge opponent in fishman island
  • santoryu Zoro could already rival G4 Luffy in terms of power
I think it makes sense that asura isn't a fully mastered power, and hence Zoro has only used it twice in a nearly 1000 chapter manga.
 

Don DaSlayer

The Peerless swordsman
#67
The more the series goes on, the more I think that Zoro actually might have gone all out in Dressrosa. Not that Asura magically doesn't exist post skip, but rather that Zoro asura is an unreliable power up.

In enies lobby, Oda introduced power ups for all of the m3. The gears for Luffy, diable jambe for sanji, and asura for zoro. However, out of these three power ups, it seems as if Asura is the only one that Oda is treating specially.

Asura seems like the most elusive power in the series. It was used only two times in the manga, and both of them happened pre-skip, effectively 10 years ago in real time.

In thriller bark, we see Luffy use the gears and sanji use diable jambe, but no asura from Zoro. Then post skip happens and we see Luffy with improved G2/G3 as well as G4, Sanji with improved diable jambe and hell memories, but we haven't even seen asura. It seems as if instead of mastering asura, Zoro instead focused on mastering his physical strength and haki, as his high end moves using black hardening can arguably rival G4 in terms of attack power.

So why no asura? According to Zoro fans, its because Zoro is simply too good to use asura. He is so all powerful, that he doesn't even need to use his full strength to defeat powerful enemies. While this argument might be fun to entertain, especially if you are a zoro fan, I feel as if it is a bit biased and lacking in insight. We are to believe that Oda would go 10 years without showing Zoro, one of the most popular characters, use his true strength?

I just don't see the logic in this. I don't get what's the point in making us wait so long. Doflamingo was hyped since pre-skip, there is no reason why Oda couldn't have made Zoro go all out in dressrosa. There is no reason for Oda to prolong this moment.

So here is my theory. To the dismay of Zoro fans, I think it is very likely that Zoro went all out in dressrosa. The reason for this is because I speculate that Zoro 1) doesn't have control over asura and 2) never did have control over asura.

from our observations, we can see that asura is used very infrequently. I mean it was never used in Thriller bark at all. This obviously wasn't because Zoro didn't go all out, as Oars was stronger than all of the straw harts combined, so was moria. Zoro was even temporarily knocked out one or two times. Oars was so strong that Luffy needed to use nightmare luffy to defeat him and then go G2+G3 to beat moria. So why didn't zoro just use asura? he had absolutely no reason not to, especially when kuma showed up.

And I think you can make a similar argument in dressrosa. If Oda was going to give Zoro the enma training as a power up in wano, why didn't he show zoro's full strength in dressrosa? Wouldn't it make sense to see Zoro use asura at least once in 10 years before having him surpass his limits with the enma training?

I think the answer is simple. Zoro doesn't know how to use asura. Even if he's pushed with his back against the wall, there's no guarantee he will be able to use asura. This is why Zoro's non asura atttacks are so powerful, why he created new moves like ISDS and rengoku oni giri, rather than mastering asura and learning how to use asura casually. Zoro simply wasn't able to control asura.

While many people might laugh or troll at the idea that Zoro went all out against pica. It isn't actually without precedent. There is very strong evidence that both Sanji and jinbe went all out against wadatsumi, who parallel's pica in that he is also extremely large. Sanji stated that he used his ultimate attack in fishman island and vagabond drill was the same attack jinbe used against big mom(where he had absolutely no reason to hold back).

I think it could be that rather than give Zoro, Sanji, and jinbe strong and serious opponents in the. new world, he instead had them go all out against goofy giants that are hard to take out.

And as for why Zoro cant use asura on command. I think it might be due to the sandai kitetsu. The sandai is the weakest kitetsu after all. If asura is from the kitetsu, maybe zoro needs a stronger kitetsu sword, like the nidai, before he can fully control asuraa.
How tf is a one shot = All out .
You fucking 3 piece reader.:gokulaugh:
 
#69

Break Week WG is probably the worst forum. I just don't know if people are trolling.

So you're posting the panel where Pica's IQ drops to zero and then he diotically jumps right into Zoro's swords and then loses as proof that he shouldn't have been dodging earlier or something? I'm not sure what you think you did there. Perhaps if you used words to show your thought process?
 
#70
If what you are saying is true, I'm just wondering why this is the case. Why couldn't Oda just make Pica stronger if ISDS wasn't Zoro's effective limit.

because like i said, every other straw hat has shown their limits.
Post automatically merged:

Why should Zoro be treated differently?
Because unlike what some might want you to believe, Oda tries to stay consistent with power structure. He can't make Pica too strong because Pica is under Doffy.

And like I said, a character like Robin hasn't been shown her limits.

So it is not only Zoro.
Post automatically merged:

think it makes sense that asura isn't a fully mastered power,
But then you need to ask yourself if there was any indication when Zoro used Asura twice preskip, that he didn't have mastery over it
 
#71
IMHO
Doffy underling is so weak because oda intend to show us that SHC level is above sichibukai now, look at doffy vs luffy, when luffy use g4 doffy cant touch him, this is the way oda shows 2 years training for SHC, this is forshadow that SHC is ready for yonko crew level but not on par, still have so much to do,
Even brook one shotted giolla (i forget her name)


Luffy is already on another level
While monster trio ZSJ is sichibukai/YC level
As long as he meet strong opponents ashura will show up again
I don't think they are weak, it's just that Oda doesn't do High diff fights anymore unless if your name is Luffy or it's Off Panel.
 

Don DaSlayer

The Peerless swordsman
#73
This thread is making me laugh as a mf. Look at these creditless thing zorohaters are saying. Keep saying creditless things. Make me laugh. Amuse me clowns.
Post automatically merged:

He got new power up in this arc so he obviously went all out.
U literally don’t kno what all out is. All out is when a mf literally uses evey move taht he has to defeat his opponent. Your headcanon is ass Dawg. Quit reading op and start reading Juan Piece. 😂 Zoro was toying with Pica he made him look like fodder.
 
#75
So you're posting the panel where Pica's IQ drops to zero and then he diotically jumps right into Zoro's swords and then loses as proof that he shouldn't have been dodging earlier or something? I'm not sure what you think you did there. Perhaps if you used words to show your thought process?
I answered the specific question you presented. For all else said, you can't say Zoro couldn't stop him if Zoro stopped him, can't say he was able to keep dodging Zoro if he gave up on dodging, etc.

Not wasting my time if you hope to troll though. Please come up with an argument that isn't just refuted by the incident you mention being put in proper context.
 
#77

Break Week WG is probably the worst forum. I just don't know if people are trolling.
Next Thread: Zoro doesnt exist. He is an imagination created by Luffy after hearing Pirate Hunter's name from Koby:finally::finally:

1st time when Luffy meets Zoro, he was actually already dead due to starving. The scene we saw was an imaginary char Luffy subconsciously created on the spot due to shock of seeing his 1st mate dead b4 even joining him. Luffy's pain and sadness overwhelmed him. he wasnt sad bcuz of Zoro but due to the fact that he cant keep his promise with Shanks. i mean how do u surpass a yonko's crew when u dont even have a crew:suresure:. So Luffy created a imaginary swordsman that joins him as his 1st mate. and Luffy also doesnt know that Zoro he knows never existed:josad::josad:. and rest of the cast and enemies and allies never spoke to Luffy about this. as they understood that the pain would be too much for the young man to handle. to tell him on his face that his life has been a lie:pepecry::pepecry:. thats why u see arc villain going -iq while fighting Luffy. its not that they are suddenly stupid BUT they feel sorry for Luffy and they decide to tank Luffy's last attack head-on out of pity and sympathy(Lucci/Dofla etc)
:ronalugh::ronalugh:
 
#78
Pica himself was never on Zoro's level I'll agree, but still having to take that long to locate and beat him, says alot about Zoro. He's just not up to YC par.
I'm just hoping Zoro fans aren't going to keep claimoring about Ashura if it doesn't happen in Wano etc.
You mean pica being ONE STAT above Zoro makes Zoro not YC level? Pica only had mobility above Zoro and used it to run very well.

Okay Diamond Jozu has better Durability than White beard. Jozu has ONE STAT above whitebeard. I guess that means Whitebeard isn't Yonkou level??? Since he has ONE STAT lower than a YC
 
#79
You mean pica being ONE STAT above Zoro makes Zoro not YC level? Pica only had mobility above Zoro and used it to run very well.

Okay Diamond Jozu has better Durability than White beard. Jozu has ONE STAT above whitebeard. I guess that means Whitebeard isn't Yonkou level??? Since he has ONE STAT lower than a YC
? You sound Salty. Maybe you should leave the interwebs for a while.

Pica Subordinate of Doflamingo, Same as Trebel and Diamante. Hold no candle to Cracker. Kyros handled Diamante just fine. Is Kyros YC level?
 
#80
I just don't think it makes sense from a writing perspective to make Zoro the only straw hat who hasn't gone all out. Its been about a decade since sabaody.

it would have cost Oda zero dollars to make Pica a worthy opponent for Zoro
@Monkey D Theories No it would cost Oda a lot.

Again just look at pre time skip

Just like how I explained Oda made Zoro not use Sanzen Sekai for 400 chapters like how Asur a isn't being used, the Consideration of how strong Zoro is is always important.

Remember that for a large portion of Pre time skip, it's always been arguable that Zoro is pretty much as strong as luffy. And Oda knows that. Oda intentionally writes things like the two fighting in Whiskey peak because he knows they are relative.

And do you know what that leads to? That leads to Oda having to write the opponents of Zoro a certain way.

If Zoro is relative to Luffy in strength, that means that the opposing side must have a number two who is also relative to the final boss. And THAT CANNOT HAPPEN.

Understand, it's a special case that the strawhats have a vice captain who is relative to the captain. It's supposed to be special. That's why it's believable that other pirates keep confusing Zoro for the one who is the captain. Because it's extremely rare for their to be a subordinate who is relative to their captain.

And so the other gimmick of Zoro's pre time skip fights comes up. Zoro MUST BE NERFED. Since its supposed to be rare for a number two to be relative to the captain, Zoro who is relative to Luffy must get NERFED so that he can match up well to the number two.

See the pattern.

And guess what happened post time skip?

Zoro stopped getting NERFED. Oda finally got tired of having Zoro get nerfed so he had to settle for Zoro doesn't go all out.

If post time skip Zoro is relative to luffy (which we can argue about elsewhere) then unless Zoro gets nerfed similar to pre time skip, Pica would have to be relative to Doflamingo to match up. And this cannot happen. The literal story cannot allow pica to be relative to doffy or else it makes Zoro being relative to luffy less special.

I hope you see what I'm getting at.

It would cost Oda hundreds of chapters of setting up shit like urouge wondering how Zoro isn't a captain or Zoro tanking luffy's pain or Zoro beating the final villain hody in the arc itself before luffy.

Oda does these things to remind us that it's special that The strawhats have a number two who is relative to the captain and it cannot be special if every arc just has a bunch of number twos who are also relative to their captains.
Post automatically merged:

? You sound Salty. Maybe you should leave the interwebs for a while.

Pica Subordinate of Doflamingo, Same as Trebel and Diamante. Hold no candle to Cracker. Kyros handled Diamante just fine. Is Kyros YC level?
Okay. I guess you don't have an answer.

I hope you've learned something
 
Top