Powers & Abilities Debunking Literally Every Argument Against Ryokugyu’s Black Blade UPDATE: Remembering The Fallen

[Dragon777]

Of course it's wild. Only 2 in the story.

Then ask Oda why it was colored black. Not us anyway.

Post automatically merged: Oct 19, 2023

I’m not sure why people are acting like this was wild. The one panel we have of the sword was black. That’s the automatic conclusion without more info

Because they are sore about it for agenda.

 

[Shiroyru]

I’m not sure why people are acting like this was wild. The one panel we have of the sword was black. That’s the automatic conclusion without more info

Because GB made it clear that swordsmanship isn’t his primary fighting style, and it would make 0 sense for someone like that to have a black blade

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Because GB made it clear that swordsmanship isn’t his primary fighting style, and it would make 0 sense for someone like that to have a black blade

But again, when the manga shows his sword once and it’s black, what’s the conclusion supposed to be? He was using armament on his sword tucked in his belt?

 

[Dragon777]

Because GB made it clear that swordsmanship isn’t his primary fighting style, and it would make 0 sense for someone like that to have a black blade

Yeah, like Aokiji that before (almost) chapter 1100 probably didn't throw a single punch in the entire manga and then we discovered he was a brawler?

Everyone has an opinion about Aramaki's blade and that's fine, but:

- the sword is black/dark in the manga chapter and official (revised) volume;

- we haven't seen Aramaki's serious style at all, just like we did with Kizaru's "guard" and Aokiji's CQC before their big fights.
And we have seen Kizaru and Aokiji much more than Aramaki.

Post automatically merged: Oct 19, 2023

But again, when the manga shows his sword once and it’s black, what’s the conclusion supposed to be? He was using armament on his sword tucked in his belt?

They don't like the implications (understandable, but still), so they won't admit under any circumstances that was just logic question.

 

[gz89]

Is it officially over?

 

[Albino 👑]

If the sword is never coated in hardening at any point in the anime are we just supposed to ignore the actual manga

 

[Lor D. Coast]

If the sword is never coated in hardening at any point in the anime are we just supposed to ignore the actual manga

Chapter and page that GB is said to have a black blade?

 

[Cruxroux]

If the sword is never coated in hardening at any point in the anime are we just supposed to ignore the actual manga

That's simply ink lol.
You seriously thought he would have Black blade.

 

[Albino 👑]

Chapter and page that GB is said to have a black blade?

That's simply ink lol.
You seriously thought he would have Black blade.

If his sword isn’t colored in any way when the scene gets animated the anime isn’t a reliable source (it isn’t in general).

Idc what color you think it was at this moment but it obviously isn’t the color of a plain sword

 

[Cruxroux]

If his sword isn’t colored in any way when the scene gets animated the anime isn’t a reliable source (it isn’t in general).

Idc what color you think it was at this moment but it obviously isn’t the color of a plain sword

You know there's a high possibility some blades are black since the time they were made. Maybe the ore was mixed with something to make it an alloy and turn it black.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

If his sword isn’t colored in any way when the scene gets animated the anime isn’t a reliable source (it isn’t in general).

Idc what color you think it was at this moment but it obviously isn’t the color of a plain sword

Yeah—people coming with a “gotcha” don’t make any sense. Based on everything in the manga, that’s a black blade.

 

[MonsterKaido]

GB got destroyed by shanks haki ; only mihawk in current generation owns a black blade ; not even roger/ray/shanks have black blades.

If someone like greenbull has BB then it makes BB far less special. Its obvious fraudbull doesn't have one.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

GB got destroyed by shanks haki ; only mihawk in current generation owns a black blade ; not even roger/ray/shanks have black blades.

If someone like greenbull has BB then it makes BB far less special. Its obvious fraudbull doesn't have one.

Just not off the actual manga image, but your headcanon.

 

[swarna]

Yeah—people coming with a “gotcha” don’t make any sense. Based on everything in the manga, that’s a black blade.

Based on that picture, what would you say his hair colour is?

 

[Cruxroux]

Based on that picture, what would you say his hair colour is?

I wonder if Zoro got Green pubic hairs or black

:zorothink:

 

[Albino 👑]

You know there's a high possibility some blades are black since the time they were made. Maybe the ore was mixed with something to make it an alloy and turn it black.

Okay so at the very least we both can agree that the blade in the manga isn’t plain colored whether or not it is a black blade

Like if in the anime the blade for some reason plain steel colored the whole time it doesn’t somehow mean it’s more canon than the actual manga itself

Yeah—people coming with a “gotcha” don’t make any sense. Based on everything in the manga, that’s a black blade.

Even if it isn’t a black blade or even hardened somehow it very obviously isn’t a normal colored blade
Ignoring the manga makes no sense at all

 

[Dragon777]

You know there's a high possibility some blades are black since the time they were made. Maybe the ore was mixed with something to make it an alloy and turn it black.

And if they'll explain it is some way, okay.

However, if the anime outright draws white the sword that in the manga was twice black/dark (original chapter and then official volume), then that just talks about anime reliability.

 

[U c 4 up da idly]

Yeah—people coming with a “gotcha” don’t make any sense. Based on everything in the manga, that’s a black blade.

You see no one called it a black blade in the manga so it's not a black blade!

 

[Lor D. Coast]

If his sword isn’t colored in any way when the scene gets animated the anime isn’t a reliable source (it isn’t in general).

Idc what color you think it was at this moment but it obviously isn’t the color of a plain sword

Nothing? Thought so.
What color is GB's left arm in the panel you posted? What color are his boots?

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Based on that picture, what would you say his hair colour is?

Have you ever heard of a green blade?