Questions & Mysteries Did Oda write himself into a corner regarding black blades?

Did Oda write himself into a corner?

  • Total voters
    25
Gaimon The Pirate

Gaimon The Pirate

‎
#41
#41
nik87 said:
>Oden Nitoryu is the greatest there is...
Literally Oden's words... It is time to accept that all others are weaker than Mihawk/Zoro.
All others are copium straws that keep sinking one after another.
Click to expand...
So usop is the greatest pirate, or Croc or anyone that claims anything is real?
Is Buggy the god of the pirates?
 
Gaimon The Pirate

Gaimon The Pirate

‎
#44
#44
nik87 said:
Except, Oden Nitoryu was indeed the greatest.
Until Zoro created his Santoryu. Moot point, Gai-chin.
Click to expand...
Oden nitoryu could barely scar kaido, strongest scar-giving style.
Leave lethality to hakimen like Luffy, the ones actually defeating enemies without using magic supreme swords made in the lava of the magic mountain by a magic artisan.
Just their haki fists.
 
Warine

Warine

‎
#45
#45
Gaimon The Pirate said:
Oden nitoryu could barely scar kaido, strongest scar-giving style.
Leave lethality to hakimen like Luffy, the ones actually defeating enemies without using magic supreme swords made in the lava of the magic mountain by a magic artisan.
Just their haki fists.
Click to expand...
Half of the top tiers are frauds if that's the case
 
kurwa

kurwa

‎
#47
#47
Sir Yasheen said:
You’re comparing people who’ve spent their life honing their skill and connection to their swords with people who treat their swords merely as weapons like Roger and Whitebeard.
Click to expand...
Aramaki treats his sword as a tool and still achieved a black blade
meanwhile Venus every time we see him keeps jerking off his sword and yet still no black blade
 
ImmaIvanoM

ImmaIvanoM

‎
#48
#48
BornInAbyss said:
If that is the case a supreme grade black blade is superior to a supreme grade non black blade.
Click to expand...
This has already been confirmed

Tashigi, Mihawk and databooks all say Yoru is the strongest sword in the world… They don’t say “Among the strongest swords in the world”… they say it’s straight up stronger than all other supreme grades

So for Yoru specifically we see it’s possible to surpass other supreme grades
Post automatically merged:

Sir Yasheen said:
You’re comparing people who’ve spent their life honing their skill and connection to their swords with people who treat their swords merely as weapons like Roger and Whitebeard.
Click to expand...
@Sir Yasheen what about this guy whose been doing this for 800 years with this one sword, whybusnt


You guys run with your headcanon too much. No one in the manga ever said Black blades are formed from “caring about your sword”…

This is a headcanon you guys made up and then just started saying like it was fact

Zoro is gonna turn Enma black at the same time as Wado and sandai… Yet he clearly only cares about Wado and can replace all the other swords any time
 
Last edited:
Sir Yasheen

Sir Yasheen

‎
#49
#49
ImmaIvanoM said:
This has already been confirmed

Tashigi, Mihawk and databooks all say Yoru is the strongest sword in the world… They don’t say “Among the strongest swords in the world”… they say it’s straight up stronger than all other supreme grades

So for Yoru specifically we see it’s possible to surpass other supreme grades
Post automatically merged:


@Sir Yasheen what about this guy whose been doing this for 800 years with this one sword, whybusnt


You guys run with your headcanon too much. No one in the manga ever said Black blades are formed from “caring about your sword”…

This is a headcanon you guys made up and then just started saying like it was fact

Zoro is gonna turn Enma black at the same time as Wado and sandai… Yet he clearly only cares about Wado and can replace all the other swords any time
Click to expand...
Easy Mihawk > Nesjuro. And we don’t know if he’ll turn all his swords black let alone at the same time.
 
ImmaIvanoM

ImmaIvanoM

‎
#57
#57
Sir Yasheen said:
Easy Mihawk > Nesjuro. And we don’t know if he’ll turn all his swords black let alone at the same time.
Click to expand...
Well Enma has already been set up and Wado is guaranteed so I expect the third will happen there too

I’m just saying the one on panel stated method of forging black blades is Onimaru’s statement that “ryuma forged his sword black through countless battles”

All we know is that it’s some kind of combat feat… Not a ”caring about your sword” feat
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top