General & Others Egghead Island Arc Rating so far?

[pg13]

Worst One Piece arc so far. Can't believe twitter hivemind are hyping this mid

Worse than Syrup Village?

 

[Tensub]

Worse than Syrup Village?

Syrup village is good in the manga because the pacing is not dragged. In the anime sure it's bad, but it's a quick short arc in the manga.

 

[zoinks0dandelion]

7.5-8. it can go higher if it explains some of Punk Hazard

 

[kumae]

From 1065-1069 worst chapters from 1070-now goat chapters rn 7 could go higher but there 2 or 3 things I didn't like it

 

[NikaInParis]

Almost 20 chapters into it, and I don't see it resolving in the next 10
It's pretty average with some good to great moments and ideas thrown in. But due to how Oda writes the story, as soon as something interesting is shown we cut away from it for months of irl time

 

[Paperchampion23]

Imo, Egghead is still an 8, for at least payoff potential. I dig the scenes out of the arc, but it needs to start addressing its main points:

- Traitor
- Kuma's flashback
- The eventual point of CP0
- Vegapunk's history with Bakkin/Weevil/Rocks
- Most importantly: Kizaru/Saturn and the Marine Assault on Egghead

 

[MagnetoEustassKidd]

Everything higher than a 7 is dick riding.

My rating currently: 4

My rating after the big event thats coming: maybe 6

 

[Midhawk]

I liked ark in the beginning, but it quickly became boring. Yes, and Vegapunk disappointed, although at the beginning of the arch I liked Vegapunk

 

[pg13]

Any opinions change?

 

[Zaretball]

5/10
It's still better than Wano

 

[Sir Yasheen]

8/10 best post timeskip arc to date. May be 10/10 depending on how the climax comes through fruition

 

[MonsterKaido]

9/10

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

I'll give my rating if Zoro faces kizaru

If Luffy faces Kizaru I'll give it a solid 0/10
If Zoro faces Kizaru I'll give it a conservative 10/10

Hello

 

[Balen]

I'll give my rating if Zoro faces kizaru

If Luffy faces Kizaru I'll give it a solid 0/10
If Zoro faces Kizaru I'll give it a conservative 10/10

honestly i feel like sanji is more deserving of facing him

 

[Hako Sama]

I liked ark in the beginning, but it quickly became boring. Yes, and Vegapunk disappointed, although at the beginning of the arch I liked Vegapunk

Damn, the boring flashback killed my pal MidHawk.


This arc is a 10/10.

 

[Rednick]

Aside of the 4 bad chapters of luffy vs kizaru, i would say its pretty good. Solid 8/10(or even 9 if the climax is worthy). Best post timeskip arc and second best overall after marineford. Kuma flashback has to end in the next chapter though.

 

[Balen]

Kuma flashback has to end in the next chapter though.

yeah anything more than another chapter about kuma's flashback would be stretching it

 

[ShinichiMugi]

A solid 8/10.

 

[NAMELESS]

What are your thoughts so far?

To be clear We'll be evaluating Chapters 1060-1101

Spoiler: EGGHEAD HIGHLIGHTS

Leave Your thoughts....

10! best arc post skip.

 

[Balen]

9/10