Yes, he was. He was in and out through the entirety of the phase but when he was here, he was all about lynching you. Today, the day phase just started. To say him not being in and out is a bad look on him is taking the game out of context and a bad frame attempt by you.
He entered the phase with the same confidence he entered last phase, it grow as the reaction you gave him today is a night and day difference from the one from yesterday. Not rocket science to figure this out, mate. You're trying to force suspicion on him.
Bad reaction, insufficient explanation. You've got one last chance to prove yourself and that's with a full claim. Run it.