Controversial General Political Discussion

[Indigo]

What happened to those humans who died before the Bible was written? Are they in hell now?

they are in the Erdtree

 

[NAMELESS]

I get your point but did you understand what I meant??

killing is considered wrong but in some cases its also right

so there's no objective morality

By killing you mean murder or self defense?

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Ok, agreed. Good luck creating your own morals though.

Every set of morals was made up by someone. What makes one more of an authority than another?

we're discussing the technicalities of words we defined as humans lmao

Words are not real.

Erdtree

The what?

 

[Indigo]

The what?

It's an Elden Ring joke, forgive me

 

[NAMELESS]

Every set of morals was made up by someone. What makes one more of an authority than another?

Words are not real.

The what?

Pretty sure robbing,killing,adultery and so on are a no no everywhere. So some things just are BAD you know...

 

[Uncle Van]

Ok, agreed. Good luck creating your own morals though.

I already have my own morals and code like millions of others. I don't need religion to be moral.

 

[NAMELESS]

they are in the Erdtree

are young going to mimick that immature man child or we having an adult debate?

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Pretty sure robbing,killing,adultery and so on are a no no everywhere. So some things just are BAD you know...

For Vikings etc robbery was a business model.

 

[Mathias]

there is a lot of contemporary pragmatists that you could discuss like Richard Rorty, Jurgen Habermas and Robert Brandom

Habermas is the only name I know in there. I didn't get into contemporaries so much tbh.

But anyway, I wouldn't be ready for it. It's been a long time... maybe I can still hold up with the big mustache guy that @Bisoromi Bear hates with all of his heart

So it isn't part of reality that all fucking humans ever in existence had their codes to make their communities survive. Are we not part of reality?

"If something exists within reality, it's objective." ?????

Also you just said "communities" had their "codes". Acknowledging that by using plural that they don't all believe in the same stuff ?

There is a famous anthropologist who came with "no killing, no incest and no eating human flesh" as rules established in every societies. At least you could have tried with that instead of the 10 commandmants which are 100% judeo-christian

 

[NAMELESS]

I already have my own morals and code like millions of others. I don't need religion to be moral.

Theft ,adultery ,rape ,muder and so on... Those were defined as wrong way before you were a thing,they will be wrong after you are gone and its possible that it is ingrained in your genes that you detest these things. How is it exactly you created your own moral code?

 

[Uncle Van]

they are in the Erdtree

More like in the Crucible. Pre-Golden Order(Moses) days.

 

[Indigo]

are young going to mimick that immature man child or we having an adult debate?

so comedy stops a person from being an adult?

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

the big mustache guy that @Bisoromi Bear hates with all of his heart

Who?

 

[NAMELESS]

For Vikings etc robbery was a business model.

Not among themselves.

 

[AL sama]

By killing you mean murder or self defense?

both

 

[Indigo]

More like in the Crucible. Pre-Golden Order(Moses) days.

bro i just got called a man child for talking about Elden Ring

be careful

 

[NAMELESS]

so comedy stops a person from being an adult?

low level baits and trolls posts are immature.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

There is a famous anthropologist who came with "no killing, no incest and no eating human flesh" as rules established in every societies. At least you could have tried with that instead of the 10 commandmants which are 100% judeo-christian

Absolute bs.
Killing and cannibalism are pretty much a staple of most ancient societies.

 

[Mathias]

Who?

"I am not human, I am dynamite"

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

so comedy stops a person from being an adult?

Yes. Adults can't have legal laughing rights.