2 and 3 have happened.
Evacuate.. where?
Palestinians cannot leave the country, and the whole cournry is bombed.
The march toward south was a death march, with civilians marching towarda another death zone now being bombed.
So, 2 and 3 have happened.
1 we could argue the gaza strip is a concentration camp itself.
And there are countless palestinian imprisoned , they cannot be re-educated because you are born jewish.
The march towards the south was a death march where not even 1% of the people migrating died? It sounds like it’s just displacement and Israel ended up killing civilians to the areas they sent aka war crimes

Imprisonment doesn’t mean re education nor concentration camp. And I’m pretty sure Israel accepts converts into its country, so the “they’re not jewish” explanation as to why they haven’t done so doesn’t hold up. A clear sign of genocide is destruction of the culture of its people.
 
The march towards the south was a death march where not even 1% of the people migrating died? It sounds like it’s just displacement and Israel ended up killing civilians to the areas they sent aka war crimes

Imprisonment doesn’t mean re education nor concentration camp. And I’m pretty sure Israel accepts converts into its country, so the “they’re not jewish” explanation as to why they haven’t done so doesn’t hold up. A clear sign of genocide is destruction of the culture of its people.
My man in christ, the israel leadership claims that palestinians don't exist.
Is that not itself intent?
Using your word, claiming somebody does not exist is not the same as destruction of the culture?
 
My man in christ, the israel leadership claims that palestinians don't exist.
Is that not itself intent?
Using your word, claiming somebody does not exist is not the same as destruction of the culture?
Again, hitler never gave the order to eliminate all the Jews, we know of his intent due to policy, is there a policy in place ensuring the erasure of the Palestinian identity?
 
Again, hitler never gave the order to eliminate all the Jews, we know of his intent due to policy, is there a policy in place ensuring the erasure of the Palestinian identity?
At the moment they don't even have a state.
A foreign entity controls their infrastructure.
The foreign entity has also invaded most of the territory and bombed the rest before moving in.
The foreign entity occupies the west bank with colonisers and enforces apartheid laws based on race.
The foreign entity blocks and controls all water sources.
So yes, if i claim something doesn't exist while i make mine the only proof that something exist i.e. its land, i would say it is genocide.
 
At the moment they don't even have a state.
A foreign entity controls their infrastructure.
The foreign entity has also invaded most of the territory and bombed the rest before moving in.
The foreign entity occupies the west bank with colonisers and enforces apartheid laws based on race.
The foreign entity blocks and controls all water sources.
So yes, if i claim something doesn't exist while i make mine the only proof that something exist i.e. its land, i would say it is genocide.
Agree to disagree. What you mention is typical oppression of the occupied people the bombing of warfare

as far as I can tell, people in Gaza and the West Bank can speak Arabic, are recognized under law as Palestinians and are allowed to have their own semi government. Is that really an erasure of their identity?
 
Agree to disagree. What you mention is typical oppression of the occupied people the bombing of warfare

as far as I can tell, people in Gaza and the West Bank can speak Arabic, are recognized under law as Palestinians and are allowed to have their own semi government. Is that really an erasure of their identity?
What you write is on paper, in reality the actions perpetuated in the last 60 years describe the opposite.
Some would argue that Hamas was put there to be useful idiots, too.
But i agree, let's agree to disagree.
In the end our opinions don't matter, we could call what is happening BANANA or whatever, it is still a tragedy, and the silence of the west compared to the loudest noise during Russia's less destructive invasion is appalling.
 
Agree to disagree. What you mention is typical oppression of the occupied people the bombing of warfare

as far as I can tell, people in Gaza and the West Bank can speak Arabic, are recognized under law as Palestinians and are allowed to have their own semi government. Is that really an erasure of their identity?
The fact that all international orgs are accusing Israel of breaking international law and the Geneva convention constantly, I don't think this is typical oppression and bombing.

The Palestinians haven't been allowed to hold elections in almost 20 years.
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
Anyways, I’m going to ask everyone in the thread to put a moratorium on the “is this a genocide, is it not a genocide” discussion. It’s listed in the rules as a taboo topic and has the potential to get uncomfortable at any given post.

Content supporting genocide or denying its existence is not allowed. Here is a Wikipedia list of genocides.
Users are welcome to have a final post on the topic but further discussion will be deleted.
 
Anyways, I’m going to ask everyone in the thread to put a moratorium on the “is this a genocide, is it not a genocide” discussion. It’s listed in the rules as a taboo topic and has the potential to get uncomfortable at any given post.



Users are welcome to have a final post on the topic but further discussion will be deleted.
Thanks for the moderation, and I think is sensible to just drop it.
I would just point out that despite being very sensible, the conversation was not heated and we were quite level headed, even when butting heads.
 
Anyways, I’m going to ask everyone in the thread to put a moratorium on the “is this a genocide, is it not a genocide” discussion. It’s listed in the rules as a taboo topic and has the potential to get uncomfortable at any given post.



Users are welcome to have a final post on the topic but further discussion will be deleted.
Stick to posting fake spoilers buddy. This is ridiculous.
 
Anyways, I’m going to ask everyone in the thread to put a moratorium on the “is this a genocide, is it not a genocide” discussion. It’s listed in the rules as a taboo topic and has the potential to get uncomfortable at any given post.



Users are welcome to have a final post on the topic but further discussion will be deleted.
Free speech is dead
 

Zolo

Cope Doctor
Anyways, I’m going to ask everyone in the thread to put a moratorium on the “is this a genocide, is it not a genocide” discussion. It’s listed in the rules as a taboo topic and has the potential to get uncomfortable at any given post.



Users are welcome to have a final post on the topic but further discussion will be deleted.
Alex jones is back, they did two hours interview with musk and other great people
 
Top