Versus Battle Hunter x Hunter vs One Piece

[Rednick]

I ve watched hxh up until chimera arc. Seriously i dont understand all this hype. Its a well written story with a few interesting characters, decent power scaling and thats pretty much it.
One piece has a far better universe and more epic characters-villains (donflamingo and crocodile>meruem). And while it has suffered plot wise at times(wano, arabasta) in general has delivered far more epic moments that hxh could ever hope to do.( Episode 0, ennies lobby, marineford, egghead).
So to conclude, i would give one piece a 7/10(universe, characters) and HXH a 7.5/10(consistency-power scaling) but one piece can easily reach 9/10 at its peak arcs while hxh a 8/10 at best.

 

[Just a member]

Rate of production does not matter in the slightest
Devil may cry 5's last game was years ago and people still were excited for the new entry.

People need to have patetince. Dont be the trend of the week type guy else you end up like the mcu where everyone hates or likes it for a week then forgets it about it

Yes, quality is not related to the production of the manga. You can do a good manga delivering one chapter each week for a decade but even a good one delivering a chapter a month for 2 years. But at the same time you have to somewhat recognize Oda's monumental effort in this field (Togashi got unlucky because of health, still what Oda did and is still doing is a unique in manga history, at least as far as I know). If for example we compare OP with HxH or Berserk at this point I can agree the average quality is better in HxH and Berserk (even because Oda probably even dragged sone chapters, like running chapters in Dressrosa, WCI and Wano) but I know that most likely Oda will bring OP to an end. I don't know if it will be good, epic, bad a train wreck but it will be an end. I can not say the same for Berserk (RIP to the original author) and HxH. I love HxH but at this point this bursts we see every few years are almost irritating. Everybody knows Togashi will never end HxH or, and maybe it is even worse, he will give it a rushed ending (like it happend for his other great manga aka Yu yu hakusho, sorry if it is written wrong).

If an author does a good manga, even if it is short the perfect, Pluto for example is a masterpiece, same for Monster (even if you have to like the genre, it is far from a shounen, me myself I don't enjoy it very much but it is nonetheless a great manga even for me) but if you start with something which is good, ok, but you also plan to go in for years / hundreds of chapters then you are chained to this point as well. HxH at this point is going on from.. 30 years? There is people who died literally of old age. OP has the motivation that actually Oda delivered almost every single week in 20 years. Togashi got extremely unlucky with health issues but still this difference matters for me.

And obviously I recognize I have no right to whine because I read the manga online, and even if I bought the physical copies I would still get what I payed for (nobody payed for copies that have still to be delivered), nonetheless I think it is a pity we will, 99% sure, never see the end of this beautiful manga (or at best a rushed one).

 

[Bob74h]

well. HxH at this point is going on from.. 30 years? There is people who died literally of old age

It's long so what?
Godzilla as a franchise is older then me yet things like the monsterverse still make decent money

But at the same time you have to somewhat recognize Oda's monumental effort in this field (Togashi got unlucky because of health, still what Oda did and is still doing is a unique in manga history, at least as far as I know). If for example we compare OP with HxH or Berserk at this point I can agree the average quality is better in HxH and Berserk (e

Mcu can pump out content quickly too
I get you care about media like you do porn ie jerk to it then forget it a day later but just cause you like media in that way does not mean jack shit to others nor does it mean your viewpoint is a shared project which the rest of us share

People still talk about older dbz characters and naruto characters where nobody is talking about dead trends like among us or whatever kids with no attention span like these days.

You say you understand berserk has better quality but your literal defense is rate of production at which oda produces manga at so you dont understand the principle of quality over quantity and are just saying this to divert the actual criticism which was quantity ie the amount of something would not equate to it's quality

Anyhow dont ping me if your just going to spew ignorant garbage like this. Nobody in the real world views media like porn other then trenders

It's why ip recognition and ip as a whole exists like you think batman vs superman sold well cause it's new or perhaps becausr dc is a very well known ip. Im sure the success of noname flims like the mummy can attest to your new is better type trender bs

 

[Just a member]

It's long so what?
Godzilla as a franchise is older then me yet things like the monsterverse still make decent money




Mcu can pump out content quickly too
I get you care about media like you do porn ie jerk to it then forget it a day later but just cause you like media in that way does not mean jack shit to others nor does it mean your viewpoint is a shared project which the rest of us share

People still talk about older dbz characters and naruto characters where nobody is talking about dead trends like among us or whatever kids with no attention span like these days.

You say you understand berserk has better quality but your literal defense is rate of production at which oda produces manga at so you dont understand the principle of quality over quantity and are just saying this to divert the actual criticism which was quantity ie the amount of something would not equate to it's quality

Anyhow dont ping me if your just going to spew ignorant garbage like this. Nobody in the real world views media like porn other then trenders

It's why ip recognition and ip as a whole exists like you think batman vs superman sold well cause it's new or perhaps becausr dc is a very well known ip. Im sure the success of noname flims like the mummy can attest to your new is better type trender bs

Ok Karen, please just don't bother to reply next time if this is the level of the discussion. Stay well.

 

[Bob74h]

Ok Karen, please just don't bother to reply if this is the level of the discussion next time. Stay well.

This is the level of discussion coming from the guy who argues what amounts to quantity above quality. Means about nothing
You have zero depth to your view point here

One piece better cause more new chapters is a moronic argument and your utter lack of a rebuttal only insulting me shows your very low iq.
You wouldt say dragon ball super and boruto are as good as one piece cause of production now would you. You hold selective judgements about certain matters cause your unaplogically biased

Anyways you can stay mad about quality being above quantity, you moronic trender

Post automatically merged: Oct 26, 2022

If i made bloody stick figures fighting each other more frenquently then one piece made it's manga then my stick figure drawings would be better
Remember quantity is above quality, is that right trender?

Post automatically merged: Oct 26, 2022

The very fact you even like one piece which has a preexisting source material dating back decades now shows you dont actually care about muh new content or that the age of hunterxhunter's manga matters

If you dumb trender types really cared about meh new shit then you wouldt solely support existing ips instead you would support things like seraph of the end,gates and candy flurry but you didt support those new projects when they came out

So you dont actually care about muh production time. You are simply saying whatever you can to make one piece look like the better product even if you sound like a total fucking retard by doing so

Im not a karen, for pointing out the bs related to your claims. Your the karen for getting offended over me pointing out how you are wrong and your fine to get mad about it idaf if a hypocrite wants to cry over some dude on the web

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Picked up HxH recently. Let's see how it goes.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Picked up HxH recently. Let's see how it goes.

Anime or manga?

You should pace yourself with manga. Cause there's like a lot of text. Especially in the later parts. It can get very tedious.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Anime or manga?

You should pace yourself with manga. Cause there's like a lot of text. Especially in the later parts. It can get very tedious.

I watched the first 7 episodes of the anime. When Gon and Killua play with Netero. Then I switched to the manga, for like 5 chapters, the majority phase. I'll probably mix it up as I can, but will most likely stick with the manga.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

I watched the first 7 episodes of the anime. When Gon and Killua play with Netero. Then I switched to the manga, for like 5 chapters, the majority phase. I'll probably mix it up as I can, but will most likely stick with the manga.

You should watch the 2011 anime fully imo. Its a great adaptation with amazing ost and voice acting.

But, read the first chapter. It's kind of different in anime.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

You should watch the 2011 anime fully imo. Its a great adaptation with amazing ost and voice acting.

I don't have the time for the anime unfortunately.

But, read the first chapter. It's kind of different in anime.

Oh I didn't know that. I'll read it then. Thanks.

 

[Mathias]

Probably the only anime adaptation of manga that I like. I would never advise anyone to start One Piece with the anime for instance.

 

[Chrono]

I care more about side characters ive met in 1 chap of HxH than side characters who have been in multiple OP arcs.

HxH just does way better in characterisation. Everyone feels individual, with their own set of goals and interests.

 

[RayanOO]

Probably the only anime adaptation of manga that I like. I would never advise anyone to start One Piece with the anime for instance.

The anime was great for like ~300 episodes (Sabaody)

After that yeah the manga became much superior

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

You should watch the 2011 anime fully imo. Its a great adaptation with amazing ost and voice acting.

But, read the first chapter. It's kind of different in anime.

So I read the first chapter and yeah I noticed the differences. The most notable one being the inclusion of Kite and him telling Gon about Ging.

 

[RayanOO]

I watched the first 7 episodes of the anime. When Gon and Killua play with Netero. Then I switched to the manga, for like 5 chapters, the majority phase. I'll probably mix it up as I can, but will most likely stick with the manga.

I think some episode def needs to be watch with the anime, some fights etc. More impactful

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

I think some episode def needs to be watch with the anime, some fights etc. More impactful

I'll probably check out the clips on YT lol.

 

[Mathias]

The anime was great for like ~300 episodes (Sabaody)

After that yeah the manga became much superior

It worsened with the "1 chapter = 1 episode" policy. But I always preferred the manga. Also, the anime doesn't even start with romance dawn

 

[Bob74h]

It worsened with the "1 chapter = 1 episode" policy. But I always preferred the manga. Also, the anime doesn't even start with romance dawn

Why are you stating you prefer manga on forum solely about manga, that's the literal default assumption any logical person would have

I prefer anime over any manga and that annoys people cause it's a manga based site.
But difference between me and you, your repeating shit everyone has heard billion times where im not

We get you prefer manga cause muh canon or whatever, I heard thousand other people say the same line of dialogue as if literal npcs in a game.
Anyway if your going to post try adding something to the reasoning like im to prefer manga cause of the art or whatever reason. Or guesss you could just repeat the consensus mindlessly without adding anything cause saying murder is bad or the grass is green are really things that im to need to be informed that you think not like those are the defaulted beliefs most people have or anything

 

[Mathias]

Why are you stating you prefer manga on forum solely about manga, that's the literal default assumption any logical person would have

I prefer anime over any manga and that annoys people cause it's a manga based site.
But difference between me and you, your repeating shit everyone has heard billion times where im not

We get you prefer manga cause muh canon or whatever, I heard thousand other people say the same line of dialogue as if literal npcs in a game.
Anyway if your going to post try adding something to the reasoning like im to prefer manga cause of the art or whatever reason. Or guesss you could just repeat the consensus mindlessly without adding anything cause saying murder is bad or the grass is green are really things that im to need to be informed that you think not like those are the defaulted beliefs most people have or anything

Nice, but why do you sound a bit on your nerves though ? I wasn't even trying to make a bit fuss about it.

And I was originally making a comparison with the 2011 HxH anime. That's why I stated that I prefer the manga to the anime, while it's the opposite for HxH

 

[PeperLevi]

As you guys say that HunterXHunter delivers as Shit Piece never does,i have decided start to read it.
Where i can read all the chapters in good quality?
@RayanOO @Chrono @ZoroMazino @style @Ar1sE1998 @Warchief Sanji D Goat @Franosuke @Sentinel @lee33