Powers & Abilities If Green Bull Found or Forged a Black Blade ?

#22
Thread.
If he has one, he obv. forged It himself. The thought of him, idk, finding It under his bed It's just another form of cope.

There is no point at all in giving a BB to someone of said person didn't forge It.
Zoro? Acting like it's impossible for him to have one without making it himself is stupid.
 
#24
Zoro is a different matter.
It was destiny for him to pick up and bring back the national treasure of Wano.
Why are yall assuming there are black blades lying around for people to pick up? :milaugh:
Like Zoro, there could be a plot reason for why Ryokugyu has one without making it, someone even gave an example earlier in this thread even.

And honestly, the idea that there has absolutely only been two black blades in the entirety of One Piece history is nonsensical, the two we know of are only from the last couple hundred years alone, and they're indestructible, so one made five thousand years ago could still be around.
 
#29
But he didn't forge Shusui did he?
No, but came from his mythical ancestor and at his full Power, replicating what Ryuma did, he Is going to forge his own.

Are you suggesting Ryo has two BB, one that came from his mythical ancestor that he didn't forge and one that he forged on his own?
Post automatically merged:

Imho Greenbull found the black blade somewhere.
Found It under his bed in 3, 2, 1
 
#30
the idea that there has absolutely only been two black blades in the entirety of One Piece history
That is exactly route Loda has picked there are only 2 of them because forging them is an extraordinary feat trying cope won't multiply them. No swordsmen in history have reached same heights as Ryuma and Mihawk only Zoro is joining them by eos
 
#31
No, but came from his mythical ancestor and at his full Power, replicating what Ryuma did, he Is going to forge his own.

Are you suggesting Ryo has two BB, one that came from his mythical ancestor that he didn't forge and one that he forged on his own?
All I'm saying is that it's possible that he has one without making it, we've seen those circumstances in the manga already lol, Oda can create any number of reasons to explain it if that's what he wants to do.
 
#32
Like Zoro, there could be a plot reason for why Ryokugyu has one without making it, someone even gave an example earlier in this thread even.

And honestly, the idea that there has absolutely only been two black blades in the entirety of One Piece history is nonsensical, the two we know of are only from the last couple hundred years alone, and they're indestructible, so one made five thousand years ago could still be around.
ironically you doing what nik usually does trying to brute force it through "facts and logic"

There is no NARRATIVE reason for GB have a BB that he didnt forge because he is a opponent. We know a BB on its own its not much hot shit from shisui as a end product. So the only reason for oda to do that would be to make him forge one because thats the only part, so far, that is worth something at all

This is like saying someones next major opponent will be weaker, cause they are stasticaly more weaker guys around in the world than stronger ones. Thats not how the story works
 
#33
People having faith in Oda suddenly when it comes to black blades?
:usoprice:

Greenbull is lame as fuck, but him actually having a black blade is not out of the realm of possibility, logic doesn't apply to this manga.
:suresure:
 
#34
All I'm saying is that it's possible that he has one without making it, we've seen those circumstances in the manga already lol, Oda can create any number of reasons to explain it if that's what he wants to do.
And I undestand, but what I am saying It that Oda gives BB to people that forged them or that are going to forge one in the future.

There Is absolutely no point in giving someone a BB if he didn't forge It or Isn't going to forge one, because It has no meaning. Another normal sword would do the job.
 

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
#35
Like Zoro, there could be a plot reason for why Ryokugyu has one without making it, someone even gave an example earlier in this thread even.

And honestly, the idea that there has absolutely only been two black blades in the entirety of One Piece history is nonsensical, the two we know of are only from the last couple hundred years alone, and they're indestructible, so one made five thousand years ago could still be around.
Ryokugyu ain't bringing back someone's blade and for him to have one without being able to use its benefits is nonsensical.
There are only 3 World's Strongest titles, is that also nonsensical?
Only two characters were strong enough to create Black Blades.
Zoro's ancestor and character he is based on and Zoro's target.
The only other person capable of doing the same is Zoro himself.
They are that rare because they are marks of ultimate Power, Sky-chin. Yoru isn't #1 weapon in the world for lulz. :goyea:

Why? Lolo found it in Thriller Bark.
Do black blades scare you that much?
They shouldn't.
Only #1 weapon in the world should scare you.
 
#36
Ryokugyu ain't bringing back someone's blade and for him to have one without being able to use its benefits is nonsensical.
There are only 3 World's Strongest titles, is that also nonsensical?
Only two characters were strong enough to create Black Blades.
Zoro's ancestor and character he is based on and Zoro's target.
The only other person capable of doing the same is Zoro himself.
They are that rare because they are marks of ultimate Power, Sky-chin. Yoru isn't #1 weapon in the world for lulz. :goyea:
1. These are conjectures, visual evidence should bear more relevance.
2. There are no stated benefits to using a black blade apart from its likely toughness and sharpness. You don't need to be an expert at swords to use one.
3. Yoru is the ultimate sword, not weapon.
Do black blades scare you that much?
They shouldn't.
Only #1 weapon in the world should scare you.
What the hell are you talking about?
 
#38
There's nothing more Oda would have to do in portraying swordsmanship as an irrelevant sidequest, than to give it's pinnacle to a fruit-merchant. If I were a sword swallower, I too would sweating rashes at the possibility
:josad:
 
#39
One forged by his ancestor which he later returned to it's rightful place.
I mean, he just exchanged it. Brook's shadow was also using a black blade so... you don't need to be a relative. You guys are making up some weird stuff, not even all top-tier swords have strict requirements to be wielded, some can be used by children.
There is little more that Oda would have to do in portraying swordsmanship as an irrelevant sidequest, than to give it's pinnacle to a fruit-merchant. If I were a sword swallower, I too would sweating rashes at the possibility
:josad:
Forging a black blade is the pinnacle of swordsmanship, not wielding one. As a matter of fact Shusui wasn't even a supreme grade.
 
Top