Chapter Discussion Inconsistency with garling scarring Whitebeard

[GoldDiamond]

During the flashback with roger, whitebeard has no scars, so him getting scarred by garling in valley can't happen unless oda retcons it

Why would garling fight wb and wouldn't his crew know about this, since wb stays with his crew?

 

[mmd]

During the flashback with roger, whitebeard has no scars, so him getting scarred by garling in valley can't happen unless oda retcons it

Why would garling fight wb and wouldn't his crew know about this, since wb stays with his crew?

In the last pages, there is a wound on wb's body at the bottom of the page

 

[Salah WG]

Or maybe Holy Knights targeted Fishmen Island after Fisher Tiger Incident, just like they targeted Sabo now
And since Fishmen Island was under WB's Rule, He intercepted them & Clashed against Garling

This is assuming that Scar is important & related to Shanks which isn't really confirmed yet

 

[ConquistadoR]

I dont understand why that statement from Whitebeard is used to wank Garling.
It can very well still be Rox or Roger who Whitebeard was referring to.

 

[mmd]

Oda forgot a few pages later

 

[Lor D. Coast]

There's no inconsistency, it never happened. Garlind lost his country and Kaido who was there doesn't know this mf and he had WB, Rocks and Roger in his "top 5".

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Oda forgot a few pages later

Oda always forgets to draw scars and shit

 

[ShadyOjiro]

Thing is readers are assuming he did the scarring.

So there's inconsistency.

 

[GoldDiamond]

under WB's Rule, He intercepted them

his crew would be with him so wouldn't his crew know about garling?

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Bandages are inconsistent in OP just like Haki.

Lucci pierces Sentomaru's stomach yet there's bandages on his head instead of his stomach lmao.

 

[Garp the Fist]

The most realistic answer is that Oda fucked up with remembering Whitebeard‘s scars, or remembering the line with Shanks, whether he got them from Roger, Garling, or whoever.

In the flashback of Roger’s last meeting with Whitebeard it doesn’t look like Whitebeard has any of his three distinctive scars. The sake bowl might be blocking the central one.

It could also be like the Shanks’ scar situation where Shanks’ has apparently got tons but we only really see the one from Blackbeard. Poorly done from Oda if that’s the case.

I think Oda forgot that he had Whitebeard mention his scars to Shanks.

 

[Phoenix D. King]

I dont understand why that statement from Whitebeard is used to wank Garling.
It can very well still be Rox or Roger who Whitebeard was referring to.

it was so obviously Roger
idk why its being retconned by fancanon

 

[Midnight Delight]

The most realistic answer is that Oda fucked up with remembering Whitebeard‘s scars, or remembering the line with Shanks, whether he got them from Roger, Garling, or whoever.

In the flashback of Roger’s last meeting with Whitebeard it doesn’t look like Whitebeard has any of his three distinctive scars. The sake bowl might be blocking the central one.

It could also be like the Shanks’ scar situation where Shanks’ has apparently got tons but we only really see the one from Blackbeard. Poorly done from Oda if that’s the case.

I think Oda forgot that he had Whitebeard mention his scars to Shanks.

Shanks also talked about his homeland when he was in the Grandline his entire life

 

[Garp the Fist]

Shanks also talked about his homeland when he was in the Grandline his entire life

That’s not really a problem. We don’t actually know what Roger did between him picking up Shanks and then us seeing Shanks at his youngest other than God’s Valley, which would not have taken years.

For all we know they went to West Blue for a bit, made an island their base, sailed from there for a couple of years while Shanks and Buggy grew up then hit the Grand Line again when Shanks was a bit older.

 

[Kiiro]

We dont even know what Scar WB is talking about

 

[GoldDiamond]

n the flashback of Roger’s last meeting with Whitebeard

Wano flashback

 

[Sir Yasheen]

This means whitebeard didn’t get any scars from roger either since that was their last clash and he didn’t get any scars from that.

So either whitebeard got scarred from a nobody or oda thought whitebeards shirt was enough to cover them

 

[Seth]

During the flashback with roger, whitebeard has no scars, so him getting scarred by garling in valley can't happen unless oda retcons it

Why would garling fight wb and wouldn't his crew know about this, since wb stays with his crew?

Uh.

God's Valley?


But aside that.

Man.

We are in the fucking era of retcons for One Piece.

Any of you seriously think Oda has this mfking shit planned all along? Lmfao.

He will speedread and see where he could possibly tie something and call it a day.

 

[Date]

WTF this havnt even happend and u already calling a inconsistence

 

[JayKitetsu]

This fandom has a weird obsession with inserting their headcannon into the story and expecting Oda to follow through with it lol

Also, this is the last time we see prime WB and the sake cup is blocking his chest scars

He got them after God Valley and Roger is still the likely candidate that gave them to him